Upgrades that turn out to be downgrades.
Upgrades that turn out to be downgrades.
Author
Discussion

Kozy

Original Poster:

3,169 posts

249 months

Monday 22nd April 2013
quotequote all
Serious performance mods, stuff like huge grip increases, big power increases etc are obviously going to do exactly what they say on the tin and make the car a lot faster, but I'm interested to hear what the PHers have bought as smaller performance upgrades, that ended up making no difference or actually making things worse, either in terms of outright performance, driveability, reliability or anything else really. What should have been better, but in reality really wasn't?

I have done a few.

Cold Air Intake - Was on the car when I bought it. Made loads of noise, sucked up a puddle and wrote off an engine. After replacing the engine, I swapped the CAI for a standard airbox and seemed to perform much better during normal driving.

Most notable was fitting bigger front brakes from a higher performance model. Thought I'd stop much quicker. Ended up with loads of nose dive, twitchy back end and actually taking longer to stop. Ended up going back to the smaller brakes as they seemed to work just fine.

Another one which I very nearly ended up doing, was forking out 4 figures on a close ratio gearbox build thinking it would turn my car into a racing car. Glad I didn't, as I think I would have been bitterly disappointed with my 'investment'.

What have PHers bought that doesn't do what it says on the tin, or done that didn't work as intended? Did you end up undoing the work?

Sorry if this thread has been done before, haven't seen it anywhere.

TameRacingDriver

20,662 posts

303 months

Monday 22nd April 2013
quotequote all
My Eunos RS Limited, when I bought it, came with a supercharger. If I'm honest, that was part of the appeal for me. However, this was just a bog standard supercharger with a box to increase the fuelling so the engine didn't self-destruct.

However, I ended up taking it off and selling it to recoup some of the money I spent trying to make it work properly. It was running low boost (5 psi) so probably was only about 25% more power than stock, but had to be run on super unleaded, did 17 mpg, and still wasn't THAT quick.

Worse still was the fact the guy who tried to install it made a right old mess of it, and it kept trying to go its own separate way from the engine.

I got the car put back to standard, and as well as not really being hugely slower, it was probably more fun anyway, no longer needed super unleaded, and was suddenly capable of almost twice the MPG.

On my DC2 Integra Type-R I had a mystery noise and was told that it was likely the baffles had gone in my backbox. So I went and got a brand new stainless steel, custom made back box. Not only did it not solve the problem, but it made the car louder, and not in a good way either. Sold the car 2 weeks later so it was a waste of money all round really.

My old Clio 172 came with 17" wheels were clearly too big for the car, Apex springs which removed any compliancy the car had, and a crappy Scorpion exhaust which made a horrible noise. Spent money fixing those issues , as well as other issues it had, but it just got too expensive and had to go. Wished I'd run a mile from that one and got a nice standard example.

Kozy

Original Poster:

3,169 posts

249 months

Monday 22nd April 2013
quotequote all
It's funny you mention the MX5 supercharger. I've got a completely stock one and I have to keep telling myself that modifying it won't make it any more fun...

Mr2Mike

20,143 posts

286 months

Monday 22nd April 2013
quotequote all
I learnt my lesson with polybushes on my old Astra GTE, they are utter waste of time on a road car. Not only did they make the ride noticeably harsh, they squeaked to the point of driving me insane unless stripped and regreased regularly. And after all that, they didn't even last very long. My findings were mirrored by a friend with a tarmac rally 205 GTi, where polybushes on the wishbones would fall apart within a few events.

Bill

58,926 posts

286 months

Monday 22nd April 2013
quotequote all
My MG ZTT with the Mustang V8 came with X-Power back boxes and sounded absolutely fantastic and epically loud, outside the car at least. In the car it was a loud droning rumble that reverberated so much that I got a couple of MPG more (worthwhile when you're doing low teens...) when I went back to standard as I didn't accelerate through the worst of the noise and could trundle round one gear higher.

ReaperCushions

7,607 posts

215 months

Monday 22nd April 2013
quotequote all
Not performance, but there are often some options that get ticked that are actually less useful than other options. Sat nav is a classic, the one built in is never as good as a £100 Tom Tom for functionality, but it looks nice in the dash doesn't it!

Another of mine is leather seats (I've mentioned this previously). Expensive and very desriable option, but.... hot in the summer, cold in winter (even with heated seats as they take a minute to warm through). They wear much more easily and most of the time look awful after 100k miles compared to cloth.

Lastly some performance suspension upgrades can ruin a cars ride. The ones on teh EsseEsse version of the 500 Abarth make it almost undrivable on UK roads (track driving aside, I'm sure its great on a track). A lot can be said about various 'MSport / S-Line / AMG' packs on derv rep mobiles.

TameRacingDriver

20,662 posts

303 months

Monday 22nd April 2013
quotequote all
Kozy said:
It's funny you mention the MX5 supercharger. I've got a completely stock one and I have to keep telling myself that modifying it won't make it any more fun...
It made a nice noise, and gave more torque, but ultimately it wasn't more fun.

On another thread today someone told me they had a 270 bhp MX5 that they found frustrating, as they constantly looked to floor it, but rarely had the opportunity.

Depends what you want out of the car though really.

Captain Muppet

8,540 posts

296 months

Monday 22nd April 2013
quotequote all
Kozy said:
It's funny you mention the MX5 supercharger. I've got a completely stock one and I have to keep telling myself that modifying it won't make it any more fun...
I put a turbo on mine and for road driving I think it may have made it less fun. Faster yes, and certainly more sideways. But for the sort of driving you're actually allowed to do on a public road it was more fun thrashing it through the gears and not speeding.

That said we're all different. I know people who couldn't have an MX5 unless it was fast. Plus it's not like I've taken it off because I don't like it biggrin


It was a successful upgrade because I needed it for driving sideways at speed on tracks, which is what the car is for.

Kozy

Original Poster:

3,169 posts

249 months

Monday 22nd April 2013
quotequote all
TameRacingDriver said:
Depends what you want out of the car though really.
ITB's. I really want ITB's. biggrin About 160-170bhp would be perfect, with all the throttle response and noise, and none of the complication of FI. (I realise it'll take more than just ITBs to get that powe)

I know it'll only be an exercise in spending £1k+ for it to be posted up here though.


Edited by Kozy on Monday 22 April 15:10

surveyor

18,707 posts

215 months

Monday 22nd April 2013
quotequote all
Aftermarket radio in the Merc.

Does not auto-adjust the sound with speed. Steering wheel adaptor that should have worked does not. Satnav does not have traffic. Radio does not fit properly.

The fit could be adjusted if everything else worked.

Original is gong back in with an old fashioned bluetooth kit.

sato

591 posts

242 months

Monday 22nd April 2013
quotequote all
HID lights on the Elise.
The headlights were absolutely useless, and I was driving down dark lanes at night a fair bit so it made sense to upgrade them.
They are marginally better, but now I cant get any radio signal when the headlights are on. If I do drive at night now, it is mostly on well lit motorways so they are more of annoyance than an asset.

AC43

13,722 posts

239 months

Monday 22nd April 2013
quotequote all
I wanted to upgrade the suspension on my S14 200SX.

By "upgrade" I mean increase the spring and damper rates whilst retaining a standard ride height.

Couldn't find uprated springs that didn't include a drop so had to lose an inch or two or wheel travel.

Added in a set of Tokico dampers that didn't have enough damping in comparison to the spring rates.

Ended up with an over-sprung, under-damped car that graunched over speed bumps.

Wish I'd just stuck a set of adjustable Bilstiens or Koni on.

Fantuzzi

3,297 posts

177 months

Monday 22nd April 2013
quotequote all
Apperntly at DK engineering, people who swap Ferrari standard exhausts for aftermarkets actaul reduce power when theyve had them on the dyno.

Also heard that alot of those boy racer air filters do the opposite than stated.

I dont know why people dont just by racier tyres, seems one of the most drastic things you can do to get a car to go faster, and feel better.

750turbo

6,164 posts

255 months

Monday 22nd April 2013
quotequote all
Fitted a twin choke webber and manifold from a MKII Cortina 1600E to my lowly 1300... made all the right noises, but totally borked the fuel consumption and performance...

Well, I was 17 at the time wink

thinkofaname

401 posts

164 months

Monday 22nd April 2013
quotequote all
Not sure if this is the sort of thing the OP is after, but I just spent a weekend (or two, if I'm honest) putting soundproofing stuff into the doors of my car, to reduce road noise. An absolute bh of a job getting all the door trim and subpanels off and back on (modern car doors are surprisingly complicated things).

Having read the glowing reviews, I couldn't wait to test drive my econobox with its now Lexus-like levels of silence. Result? It has not made any noticeable difference. A total waste of time/money/effort. The only benefit is that the doors sound like they're made of granite when you tap them.

Sexual Chocolate

1,583 posts

175 months

Monday 22nd April 2013
quotequote all
750turbo said:
Fitted a twin choke webber and manifold from a MKII Cortina 1600E to my lowly 1300... made all the right noises, but totally borked the fuel consumption and performance...

Well, I was 17 at the time wink
I did the same. If I remember rightly it was the 32 or 38 DFM . I topped mine off with a pancake air filter thing. It did make a lot of noise but it didn't really go any faster. In my tiny teenage head though it was faster than anything else on the road.

Cactussed

5,364 posts

244 months

Monday 22nd April 2013
quotequote all
I've had good and bad experience and the overriding factor has been that mods done in a comprehensive manner are usually good, but ones done piecemeal or on the cheap are often not worth doing.


mnkiboy

4,409 posts

197 months

Monday 22nd April 2013
quotequote all
I used to have a yellow Punto, and decided to spruce up the interior with a black and yellow gearknob. After spending about an hour cutting the original plastic gearknob off with a hacksaw, I got round to fitting the new gearknob. Unfortunately I could never get it to fit properly. It was constantly loose and would often come off in my hand as I changed gear.
To make matters worse I'd completely butchered the original gearknob, so had to live with it. Wished i'd never bothered!

Krikkit

27,943 posts

212 months

Monday 22nd April 2013
quotequote all
Cactussed said:
I've had good and bad experience and the overriding factor has been that mods done in a comprehensive manner are usually good, but ones done piecemeal or on the cheap are often not worth doing.
This.

I've added an induction kit on my car from the original setup, I'm not bothered that the power is probably down a touch - the noise is better!

S10GTA

13,817 posts

198 months

Monday 22nd April 2013
quotequote all
Mr2Mike said:
I learnt my lesson with polybushes on my old Astra GTE, they are utter waste of time on a road car. Not only did they make the ride noticeably harsh, they squeaked to the point of driving me insane unless stripped and regreased regularly. And after all that, they didn't even last very long. My findings were mirrored by a friend with a tarmac rally 205 GTi, where polybushes on the wishbones would fall apart within a few events.
This. Polly bushes on my old GTA. Was the final nail in its coffin.