Buyer not happy
Discussion
Sold an Alfa Romeo 156 at the beginning of the month. It had around 2 months MOT remaining at the time. The last MOT picked up no advisories and I sold the car in good faith, believing it to pass its MOT without issue. The owner obviously presented it a month or so early and phoned today saying it was rusty underneath and the MOT station believed it should be scrapped. It was a 1999 car with 30,000 miles on the clock which I sold for £950 privately. The lady and her partner came and viewed the car, gave it a long test drive and seemed happy enough with the car. I said I'd phone back later today but not sure what to say really. Thanks.
P325 said:
Sold an Alfa Romeo 156 at the beginning of the month. It had around 2 months MOT remaining at the time. The last MOT picked up no advisories and I sold the car in good faith, believing it to pass its MOT without issue. The owner obviously presented it a month or so early and phoned today saying it was rusty underneath and the MOT station believed it should be scrapped. It was a 1999 car with 30,000 miles on the clock which I sold for £950 privately. The lady and her partner came and viewed the car, gave it a long test drive and seemed happy enough with the car. I said I'd phone back later today but not sure what to say really. Thanks.
This is VERY simple.Buyer beware. I assume you are a private seller and not a trader. They inspected the car, and chose to buy it.
Tell them to f*ck off. DO NOT get into dialogue with them.
Caveat emptor to them, but explain that you believed it to be in perfectly decent condition.
How is it that this car has gone from 0 advisories last year to being a wreck inside 12 months? Suggest they take it to another MOT station as this guy sounds like he's lining up to buy the "scrap".
How is it that this car has gone from 0 advisories last year to being a wreck inside 12 months? Suggest they take it to another MOT station as this guy sounds like he's lining up to buy the "scrap".
P325 said:
Sold an Alfa Romeo 156 at the beginning of the month. It had around 2 months MOT remaining at the time. The last MOT picked up no advisories and I sold the car in good faith, believing it to pass its MOT without issue. The owner obviously presented it a month or so early and phoned today saying it was rusty underneath and the MOT station believed it should be scrapped. It was a 1999 car with 30,000 miles on the clock which I sold for £950 privately. The lady and her partner came and viewed the car, gave it a long test drive and seemed happy enough with the car. I said I'd phone back later today but not sure what to say really. Thanks.
To take the middle ground here, since I assume you're not planning on being outright rude to someone, I'd point out firmly (assuming private seller etc etc) that you sold the car in good faith and no refunds will be taking place. However, your genuine surprise (which they will no doubt have picked up on) and your desire to be a nice guy means have spent the price of this phone call to suggest they MOT it somewhere else, on the basis the previous MOT had no advisories and you are astonished that it's gone from passable to too rusty to pass in a year. This alone is pretty logical.Also, try not to let the inevitable Alfa jokes get you down and no matter what, if they're shirty, or start insisting on anything, simply put the phone down. End the call with, "this is my final position on the matter". They can curse you all they like, but as has been said, you buy privately, it's up to you to check the car.
Private Sale
The buyer has no come back - he bought the car after inspecting it and taking it for a test drive.
As an end to the conversation(and without entering into any debate) I would suggest that you point him in the direction of the previous MOT which showed a pass and no advisories.
For future reference, whenever I sell a car I always include a receipt that both parties sign which clearly states something along the lines of.....
Having thoroughly inspected my car (make, model, reg) the buyer (insert name), being entirely satisfied with it's condition has purchased the car for the sum of (insert price). As point of purchase (time, date), the seller (insert my name) ceases to have any responsiblity for the vehicle, legal or otherwise.
Signed (seller)
Signed (buyer)
The buyer has no come back - he bought the car after inspecting it and taking it for a test drive.
As an end to the conversation(and without entering into any debate) I would suggest that you point him in the direction of the previous MOT which showed a pass and no advisories.
For future reference, whenever I sell a car I always include a receipt that both parties sign which clearly states something along the lines of.....
Having thoroughly inspected my car (make, model, reg) the buyer (insert name), being entirely satisfied with it's condition has purchased the car for the sum of (insert price). As point of purchase (time, date), the seller (insert my name) ceases to have any responsiblity for the vehicle, legal or otherwise.
Signed (seller)
Signed (buyer)
B.J.W said:
Private Sale
The buyer has no come back - he bought the car after inspecting it and taking it for a test drive.
As an end to the conversation(and without entering into any debate) I would suggest that you point him in the direction of the previous MOT which showed a pass and no advisories.
For future reference, whenever I sell a car I always include a receipt that both parties sign which clearly states something along the lines of.....
Having thoroughly inspected my car (make, model, reg) the buyer (insert name), being entirely satisfied with it's condition has purchased the car for the sum of (insert price). As point of purchase (time, date), the seller (insert my name) ceases to have any responsiblity for the vehicle, legal or otherwise.
Signed (seller)
Signed (buyer)
A template for this is also on the AA website...The buyer has no come back - he bought the car after inspecting it and taking it for a test drive.
As an end to the conversation(and without entering into any debate) I would suggest that you point him in the direction of the previous MOT which showed a pass and no advisories.
For future reference, whenever I sell a car I always include a receipt that both parties sign which clearly states something along the lines of.....
Having thoroughly inspected my car (make, model, reg) the buyer (insert name), being entirely satisfied with it's condition has purchased the car for the sum of (insert price). As point of purchase (time, date), the seller (insert my name) ceases to have any responsiblity for the vehicle, legal or otherwise.
Signed (seller)
Signed (buyer)
Just follow any of the advice given from my slightly short version, to the more polite version.
Dont get into dialogue. Factual, you bought it after inspecting it, good faith, I am not a mechanic, very surprised it would go from pass to rust bucket in a year, please do not contact me again.
Dont get into dialogue. Factual, you bought it after inspecting it, good faith, I am not a mechanic, very surprised it would go from pass to rust bucket in a year, please do not contact me again.
Well, if you made up a purchase receipt that clearly elaborates on the fact that the car was inspected and sold as seen then the new owner is either poorly informed or trying it on. Either way, you hold all of the cards and can politely point out that the car ceased to be your responsibility at the start of the month.
They have no grounds to make any claim, private sold as seen. They should of asked you to put full mot on it.
Explain this to them calmly then any further action if they wish to come from their lawyer. Saying stuff like f**k off and go f**k yourself don't help in my opinion.
They have learned a lesson at a cost if a grand, it could of been a lot more!
Explain this to them calmly then any further action if they wish to come from their lawyer. Saying stuff like f**k off and go f**k yourself don't help in my opinion.
They have learned a lesson at a cost if a grand, it could of been a lot more!
Makem said:
They have no grounds to make any claim, private sold as seen. They should of asked you to put full mot on it.
Explain this to them calmly then any further action if they wish to come from their lawyer. Saying stuff like f**k off and go f**k yourself don't help in my opinion.
They have learned a lesson at a cost if a grand, it could of been a lot more!
I don't think its a grand they have lost. It was £950, scrap value is upwards of £200 and if it were advertised on ebay as a spares or repairs but still be around £500 due to the fact it has to be one of the lowest mileage 156 Alfas.Explain this to them calmly then any further action if they wish to come from their lawyer. Saying stuff like f**k off and go f**k yourself don't help in my opinion.
They have learned a lesson at a cost if a grand, it could of been a lot more!
Pothole said:
Why does (at least) one of these threads appear on a weekly basis? Does nobody search and read before asking the same stupid question?
I always struggle with the PH search facility. I also find that for a lot of people this is a grey area....I'd rather see a stupid question answered by a helpful PH member, than have someone worried about something that need not be worried about.

Gassing Station | General Gassing | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff



