How accurate is your speedo then?
How accurate is your speedo then?
Author
Discussion

405dogvan

Original Poster:

5,329 posts

296 months

Monday 22nd April 2013
quotequote all
It's never even occured to me to doubt my speedo's accuracy - in set limits I tend to keep-up with other traffic but last week they installed one of those nannying speed readout signs on a road I drive down regularly and it's suggesting my speedo is overreading!?

It tells you your speed in BIG GREEN NUMBERS if you're 29 or under and BIG RED LETTERS if it's 30 or higher so the fact I was going a bit quick (35ish) and it said 28 in GREEN caught my attention!!

I guess I get one of those GPS speedos to check it but is this unusual or have they just set-it-up badly?

I parked-up and watched it for a bit tonight and a few people got high numbers, most were under 30 tho.

I just assumed they'd set those a bit low to scare people - not high to encourage me to speed up!?

p.s. yes, it's a Peugeot (Jaeger) speedo and so it waves around like mad under 25ish - but it's actually quite steady by the time you get to 30 so it's not that wink

lightthefuse

426 posts

203 months

Monday 22nd April 2013
quotequote all
Interesting you mention the Jaeger, the 607s had a VDO which read absolutely fine at all speeds.

What usually causes overreads here is the change to winter tyres, usually accompanied with smaller wheels and a bigger profile. Could have a good few kph difference between the two even if it's within tolerance.

kambites

71,717 posts

252 months

Monday 22nd April 2013
quotequote all
The Elise's over-reads by around 7-8% all the way up. A read-out from the diagnostics port shows a very accurate speed though, so it's only the actual dial that's miscalibrated.

The Octavia is within 1mph at 70.

callmedave

2,686 posts

176 months

Tuesday 23rd April 2013
quotequote all
I was always under the impression a speedo over reads, this would make you travel slower than you thought you were. Anytime ive had to drive with a sat-nav, ive always compared the sat-nav speed to the dash and the dash has read a higher speed by a few mph.

If you have a smart phone it would be easy enough to set up something that tracks your speed and work out the difference.

JimbobVFR

2,822 posts

175 months

Tuesday 23rd April 2013
quotequote all
My Audi A2 has a hidden combination of buttons to display the speed on the stereo display and also a user settable speed warning in the OBC. Both of these are cock on accurate according to GPS but the speedo itself does over read. If I set the speed warning to 80 it beeps at about 84ish on the speedo.

It does seem the speedo over reading could be on purpose based on that

lufbramatt

5,696 posts

165 months

Tuesday 23rd April 2013
quotequote all
I expect the speedo on most if not all cars over-reads by 5-10% to stop people sueing the car manfacturer when they get caught speeding.

callmedave

2,686 posts

176 months

Tuesday 23rd April 2013
quotequote all
lufbramatt said:
I expect the speedo on most if not all cars over-reads by 5-10% to stop people sueing the car manfacturer when they get caught speeding.
Yes! i reakon so, thats what i meant in my post earlier.

RizzoTheRat

29,157 posts

223 months

Tuesday 23rd April 2013
quotequote all
callmedave said:
I was always under the impression a speedo over reads,
I believe legally the speedo has to be within 0-10% fast. I find mine reads about 70 when the GPS says I'm doing 75.

When comparing with GPS don't forget that it's only accurate on the flat as it's only measuring your horizontal speed, up or down hill the GPS will under read.


Bear in mind as well that the difference between 8mm* and 1.6mm of tread on a 20" tyre** is over 2.5% on the rolling radius, so how worn your tyres are can have a fairly big impact on speedo accuracy

*what do new tyres start with?
**rough guess for an 18" wheel, can't remember my tyre sizes

Edited by RizzoTheRat on Tuesday 23 April 12:48

robinessex

12,044 posts

212 months

Tuesday 23rd April 2013
quotequote all
lufbramatt said:
I expect the speedo on most if not all cars over-reads by 5-10% to stop people sueing the car manfacturer when they get caught speeding.
Checked by GPS, my speedo is +2mph all the way to 100mph. Opps, shouldn't have said that !!!

DanielJames

7,543 posts

199 months

Tuesday 23rd April 2013
quotequote all
Mine is actually GPS accurate now as the tyres are a bit too big for it since fitting the 16" alloys


405dogvan

Original Poster:

5,329 posts

296 months

Tuesday 23rd April 2013
quotequote all
See this - item 19

http://www.legislation.gov.uk/uksi/2001/25/pdfs/uk...

Cannot overread - cannot underread by more than

V/10+6.25 mph
where V=the true speed of the vehicle in mph.

It also says a speedo is required (unless the vehicle is only capable of less than 25mph) and must read the full range of the vehicles capable speeds and yet they don't test speedos in the MOT, do they?

As for wheels/tyres - I have no idea if I'm running the right combo as the original handbook is long gone, Haynes specifies 2 different sizes for 405 Estates and the 2 mechanics who work on this car disagree whether it had 14" or 15" wheels originally - so that may well be the problem right there!

MikeyLCR

501 posts

212 months

Tuesday 23rd April 2013
quotequote all
My JDM Forester reads about 10% fast, always put it down to the fact theat the speedo only had kph printed on it and had to be re-calibrated to mph for UK

Riknos

4,701 posts

235 months

Tuesday 23rd April 2013
quotequote all
They should all over-read - for a reason. See several posts above explaining the reasons.

I'm shocked that more people don't realise this?

405dogvan

Original Poster:

5,329 posts

296 months

Tuesday 23rd April 2013
quotequote all
Update: Took the car out with my mobile jammed onto the screen showing a GPS speedo today and the results are in!

When my speed is

At 30mph - 25mph!!

At 40mph - 34mph!!

At 60mph - 55mph

At 70mph - 62mph

At 80leptons - 71leptons

Thing is, I've always driven 'a bit above the limit' and all these years I've been assuming I was rad and cool and subversive and - oh bugger...

That does explain why we think there's really an 80 limit on motorways tho - that's because it's just 70!