Diesel, is it actually worth it?
Diesel, is it actually worth it?
Author
Discussion

Juber

Original Poster:

569 posts

169 months

Tuesday 23rd April 2013
quotequote all
I have searched this topic on here and each time the answers drift onto other subjects, so I hope you don’t mind me posting again.

I was originally after a BMW 330D (e46) have around the £5k mark to spend. I do an average of 45 miles a day 90% of it being motorway every day to get to work and back. The weekends maybe more?

However I just bought a house which means my daily commute will now be walking. So would a diesel be worthwhile buying? I recon weekends and leisure days out will be around 150 miles MAX a weekend.

I hear that buying a diesel isn’t as economical if youre not doing the miles and if you do lots of town driving.

I want something that has a bit of grunt, and faily high spec, would you rule out the 330d?

Lanxx

217 posts

198 months

Tuesday 23rd April 2013
quotequote all
MX5.


Sorry, standard reply to anything.

Prawo Jazdy

5,037 posts

245 months

Tuesday 23rd April 2013
quotequote all


"We asked a hundred PHers what they would find funny."

Lanxx said:
MX5.


Sorry, standard reply to anything.

simoid

19,774 posts

189 months

Tuesday 23rd April 2013
quotequote all
Diesel thread bingo time!

I'll have: devil, torque and smoke.

smile

anonymous-user

85 months

Tuesday 23rd April 2013
quotequote all
Time to paste in my generic diesel thread response:

The fuel costs more
The diesel model costs more
More to go wrong / costly repairs
Sound like a taxi (330d not so much but still not a nice sound)
Tiny power band, no fun in my view


Diesels have their place; those covering very high miles where it makes financial sense, and those who dont but enjoy pub talk of mpg figures and torque.

Dr Interceptor

8,183 posts

227 months

Tuesday 23rd April 2013
quotequote all
So you'll be walking all week, and doing 150 miles at the weekend - that's 600 miles per month.

A petrol BMW should still get you 300 miles from a tank, and pricing a tank at £75, if you're happy with £150 on fuel, get a petrol.

heebeegeetee

30,264 posts

279 months

Tuesday 23rd April 2013
quotequote all
simoid said:
Diesel thread bingo time!

I'll have: devil, torque and smoke.

smile
I'll go for mapped and dpf. smile

crostonian

2,427 posts

203 months

Tuesday 23rd April 2013
quotequote all
Buy a 330i instead

tbc

3,017 posts

206 months

Tuesday 23rd April 2013
quotequote all
I think some car magazine

was either Evo or Auto Express worked out that to jusify owning a diesel you would need to be doing over 18000 miles a year

if you take in the extra cost and higher price of diesel

maffski

1,905 posts

190 months

Tuesday 23rd April 2013
quotequote all
simoid said:
Diesel thread bingo time!

I'll have: devil, torque and smoke.

smile
Darn, I was going to have smoke. I'll go with: injectors, 'real world mpg' and v8.

AC43

13,722 posts

239 months

Tuesday 23rd April 2013
quotequote all
maffski said:
simoid said:
Diesel thread bingo time!

I'll have: devil, torque and smoke.

smile
Darn, I was going to have smoke. I'll go with: injectors, 'real world mpg' and v8.
I'll go with DPF, gearing, taxi

heebeegeetee

30,264 posts

279 months

Tuesday 23rd April 2013
quotequote all
Truck, tractor and dmf.

heebeegeetee

30,264 posts

279 months

Tuesday 23rd April 2013
quotequote all
Oh, and BMW, 328, 45mpg smile.

BRMMA

1,908 posts

203 months

Tuesday 23rd April 2013
quotequote all
Get a 330i instead, the additional fuel costs will be minimal with the mileage you'll be doing and will be more than offset by the cheaper purchase/maintenance costs plus you get to listen to that lovely petrol straight 6

McWigglebum4th

32,414 posts

235 months

Tuesday 23rd April 2013
quotequote all
The favs are taken

I'll have to go with smelly and slippery roundabouts

rj1986

1,107 posts

199 months

Tuesday 23rd April 2013
quotequote all
I'll go with the outsiders "VAG/VW/Audi" and some comment about it being white/grey/silver.

mnkiboy

4,409 posts

197 months

Tuesday 23rd April 2013
quotequote all
You're walking to work, so take the opportunity to buy something interesting for the weekend. Nobody wants big engined petrol cars so they're much cheaper than the equivalent diesels.

ts86net

133 posts

260 months

Tuesday 23rd April 2013
quotequote all
For ~6k miles per year, get a petrol.

RobM77

35,349 posts

265 months

Tuesday 23rd April 2013
quotequote all
At least in BMWs (my preferred choice of daily driver for handling), petrol gives a throttle lag and diesel doesn't, so it's an instant decision for me cause cornering and control means more to me than power. I've owned a 330ci; never again, I'm sticking with a 320d.

Before people reply mentioning turbo lag, that's something different entirely and doesn't bother me as it's only apparent in some straight line situations, and nobody needs control in a straight line (unless you have enough power to cause wheelspin, which isn't an issue in a straight line with under 300bhp and RWD).

simoid

19,774 posts

189 months

Tuesday 23rd April 2013
quotequote all
It's important to remember the likely higher residual values of a diseasal, too.