Family hot hatch ponderings
Family hot hatch ponderings
Author
Discussion

stueys

Original Poster:

127 posts

234 months

Tuesday 23rd April 2013
quotequote all
Hi guys/gals. I know this has probably been done before but here we go. I have a 16 month old boy, and his baby seat will not fit in the back of my Clio 200 Cup. It wont go between the seat back and the b pillar! This got me thinking that at 40 perhaps I should grow up slightly, and maybe a 5 door is in order. I know people manage with 3 doors, but its hard enough getting in the back without a toddler trying to escape!
My thought turned to the options, really I dont want bigger than a Golf/Focus etc sized car. One requirement is if I need to start using it for my journey to work (46 miles mostly dual carriageway) I would like at least 35mpg whilst gently making the trip. Another is I would like something at least a bit of fun!
My immediate thoughts turned to a Golf Mk5 GTi. Having had a late Golf VR6 which started to fall apart due to the inbuilt VW booby traps (sills/jacking points, dirt behind front wheel arch, rear arches) I was surprised and dismayed to see things may not have moved on much from some research. The idea that a quality marque can have rust issues after half a dozen years onwards is not filling me with confidence. I am not sure if the A3/Leon ranges are better than what I have read??
Skoda Octavia is just a bit big for my parking at home, but does look to get good press.
If anyone has some thoughts on this please join in, but I dont want it to get moody so light hearted please :-)

mike9009

11,022 posts

274 months

Tuesday 23rd April 2013
quotequote all
We have a three year old girl and a 2 week old boy!

Yesterday we all managed to fit into my Mini Clubman S. Kids seemed fine....

It will do 35mpg easily, has a decent quality 'feel' about it, and is good fun to hoon around in. I can just fit a travel system in the boot, but also have a roof box which should fit the other gubbins I may need for a longer trip away.

Not to everyones taste though....



We also have a Nissan Note and VW T25 to help with other family type duties.


Mike

anonymous-user

85 months

Tuesday 23rd April 2013
quotequote all
What's your budget?

MysteryLemon

4,968 posts

222 months

Tuesday 23rd April 2013
quotequote all
Get a smaller car seat?

Seriously. We have a daughter and a son on the way in a few months. We currently have a car seat for each of our cars. The missus tends to use the Britax seat we originally purchased. It stays in her Scenic 100% of the time. We purchased a second seat for my car (currently a Lupo) as it saved swapping the seats about all the time.

The Brittax is huge. Massive bulky thing that simply will not fit in my Lupo. It's really tall (ideal for the sprog to look out the window) and very deep, so whilst the width allows it to take up a single passenger space, the depth is so much that the front seat in the Scenic needs to be almost all the way forward to allow my daughter to have any legroom.

The other seat (unsure of the brand) fits in anything. It's much lower down so just sits on the seat nicely and gives the child the use of a normal passengers legroom rather than needing to move the front seat forward. Only disadvantage is that being lower down, in a 3 door car with high rear windows, they wont be able to see out. Not really the end of the world though.

Have a hunt around for a new seat... Cheaper than changing cars.

stueys

Original Poster:

127 posts

234 months

Tuesday 23rd April 2013
quotequote all
Thanks for the replies. I would say as my car is very low mileage if I could get around £8k (just guessing tbh) I could probably put max £6k on top so maybe £13-14k? This would get a pretty new Octavia VRS, maybe it would fit on the drive?
My sis in law mentioned the smaller seat, so could be an option.
Having done one trip to my work and back in my Clio Cup, even though for what it is the ride is very good I dont know how long I could handle it before going nuts the roads are so pants.
I'm not really a Mini man, especially the newer 'lets make another variant' jobs but thanks anyway :-)
Oh forgot to say this would have to be a long term change, so reliability and longevity v.important!!