Why is there no car club/Zip Car for enthusiasts?
Why is there no car club/Zip Car for enthusiasts?
Author
Discussion

.blue

Original Poster:

726 posts

211 months

Thursday 25th April 2013
quotequote all
Since living primarily in London now and having had enough of splurging on the luxury that is TPFT car insurance and since buying a motorbike, I have been thinking about selling my car. I still love driving, want access to a car on weekends and evenings and for the odd track day. There is nothing however that fits my needs.

Joining a supercar club like Ecurie is too expensive. And at this age and income, I don't care much for driving supercars.

ZipCar have a boring fleet, are not good value for weekend-long rentals.

What I'm looking for is a middle-ground. Does anything exist? If not, why not? It seems like a big opportunity. I can spend most of what i would otherwise spend on my car which I would be saving with a car club like this:

Insurance - £750
Tax - £200ish
MOT/Servicing - £180
Ownership/Depreciation costs - £250ish

TOTAL = £1,380.

If anyone has experience of setting up a car club, I would love to hear from you.

PaulMoor

3,209 posts

194 months

Thursday 25th April 2013
quotequote all
I remember seeing one in Evo years ago. I can't remember the name, but they had all sorts. Everything from super cars to Sevens and classics. The cheapest as I remember was a soft top Morris Minor and for the basic membership you could get something like 30 days of driving that in winter, up to about 3 days of driving one of the supercars in mid summer.

Is that the sort of thing you were thinking of?

I'll see if I can find them (If they still exist).

Edited by PaulMoor on Thursday 25th April 10:44

hairykrishna

14,539 posts

234 months

Thursday 25th April 2013
quotequote all
That would be quite cool. I think you can forget the 'odd track day' element for that budget though.

jeremyc

28,407 posts

315 months

Thursday 25th April 2013
quotequote all
How about ClubGT (no affiliation).

Membership packages from £1,250 and up. smile

braddo

12,420 posts

219 months

Thursday 25th April 2013
quotequote all
classiccarclub.co.uk

You'll have to hire track cars for track days (e.g. Javelin, bookatrack)

.blue

Original Poster:

726 posts

211 months

Thursday 25th April 2013
quotequote all
Classic Car Club is far too expensive at £3000+

GT Club is interesting.

What I am thinking about though is one with just basic cars (MX-5, Abarth 500, Jag XF, Qashqai etc.) for people who want to replace owning a car with access to a fleet. This way you would usually have the right car for the occasion (e.g. Qashqai for weekend visits across the country, Abarth 500 on a sunny weekend in London, MX-5 for a blast on some B-roads etc...)

Am I the only one that thinks something like this would be really useful? It might explain why no one I have spoken to so far has been enthusiastic...

It makes financial sense to me because I would sell my car (+£2500 at least); save on insurance (+£750 per year) and other fixed costs of owning a car (>+£300 per year). If in return I paid £1000 per year for access to a fleet such as the above, I'd be happy.

Gruber

6,313 posts

245 months

Thursday 25th April 2013
quotequote all
.blue said:
Am I the only one that thinks something like this would be really useful? It might explain why no one I have spoken to so far has been enthusiastic...
You're probably not "the only one", but I bet you're in a pool that's so small it doesn't make financial sense for anyone to roll it out on a large scale.

hairykrishna

14,539 posts

234 months

Thursday 25th April 2013
quotequote all
.blue said:
If in return I paid £1000 per year for access to a fleet such as the above, I'd be happy.
I'm not sure 1k offers enough margin, if any, for anyone to offer such a service though.

jeremyc

28,407 posts

315 months

Thursday 25th April 2013
quotequote all
Others have tried a similar idea but giving you cars on a three month rota (which looks to not have survived): The Carrot Club.

You'd probably need some form of fractional ownership club whereby you'd be happy for others using the car you contribute in return for being able to use theirs. Can'o'worms getting that to work though.

Bjam99

231 posts

166 months

Friday 26th April 2013
quotequote all
hairykrishna said:
.blue said:
If in return I paid £1000 per year for access to a fleet such as the above, I'd be happy.
I'm not sure 1k offers enough margin, if any, for anyone to offer such a service though.
Quite - the nice idea of WhipCar was a good one, people would rent out their own car (any old car I believe as long as it was under three years old) but alas - its closed as of March.

http://www.whipcar.com/

northwest monkey

6,370 posts

220 months

Friday 26th April 2013
quotequote all
.blue said:
There is nothing however that fits my needs.
Enterprise?

.blue

Original Poster:

726 posts

211 months

Friday 26th April 2013
quotequote all
Interesting responses and thanks for the links.

So if this could be delivered for £1000/year, would you lot consider using it? With a fleet of for example: Jag XF, Fiat 500 Abarth, Mazda MX-5.

Would it be a replacement for your car or used in conjunction?

hairykrishna

14,539 posts

234 months

Friday 26th April 2013
quotequote all
.blue said:
So if this could be delivered for £1000/year, would you lot consider using it? With a fleet of for example: Jag XF, Fiat 500 Abarth, Mazda MX-5.
How often would I get to use the cars?

Matt UK

18,084 posts

231 months

Friday 26th April 2013
quotequote all
.blue said:
Since living primarily in London now and having had enough of splurging on the luxury that is TPFT car insurance and since buying a motorbike, I have been thinking about selling my car. I still love driving, want access to a car on weekends and evenings and for the odd track day. There is nothing however that fits my needs.

Joining a supercar club like Ecurie is too expensive. And at this age and income, I don't care much for driving supercars.

ZipCar have a boring fleet, are not good value for weekend-long rentals.

What I'm looking for is a middle-ground. Does anything exist? If not, why not? It seems like a big opportunity. I can spend most of what i would otherwise spend on my car which I would be saving with a car club like this:

Insurance - £750
Tax - £200ish
MOT/Servicing - £180
Ownership/Depreciation costs - £250ish

TOTAL = £1,380.

If anyone has experience of setting up a car club, I would love to hear from you.
OP, I get your thinking, but..

a) You are looking at costs - in order for anyone to bother doing this they need to factor in risk, profit and tax to make it a business - so their margin to cover goes on top of costs to create price.

b) What car is this and what miles were you doing that it cost you:
Insurance - £750
Tax - £200ish
MOT/Servicing - £180
Ownership/Depreciation costs - £250ish

.blue

Original Poster:

726 posts

211 months

Friday 26th April 2013
quotequote all
Approx. 35 days of use, including/up to 5 weekends.

Matt - Just an MX-5. Around 10 years old.

Matt UK

18,084 posts

231 months

Friday 26th April 2013
quotequote all
hairykrishna said:
.blue said:
So if this could be delivered for £1000/year, would you lot consider using it? With a fleet of for example: Jag XF, Fiat 500 Abarth, Mazda MX-5.
How often would I get to use the cars?
Not very often...

Also, OP it's not just days but also miles - are there restrictions?

.blue

Original Poster:

726 posts

211 months

Friday 26th April 2013
quotequote all
Matt UK said:
Not very often...

Also, OP it's not just days but also miles - are there restrictions?
There will have to be. But I have no reason to believe that it would be overly restricting... just over 1,000/year/customer should be manageable.

Matt UK

18,084 posts

231 months

Friday 26th April 2013
quotequote all
Fair enough. I personally think that your costs are very light and have no contigency, even if this was a project amongst mates to share cars and costs.

I certainly don't think you'll find a business that would want to provide what you suggest for the sums of money involved, espcailly in London. Willing to be proved wrong though.

carreauchompeur

18,334 posts

235 months

Friday 26th April 2013
quotequote all
Interesting, but if you want to give members availability then the fleet size would have to be quite large.

I suppose there's scope for "sub-contracting" from various rental firms...

ClubGT looks good, but basically it's £600+ per weekend for the more interesting cars, and the following scary excesses:


The member is liable for the
following
insurance excess
es
in the event of
a claim being
made
:
Class 0 Cars:
£5
0
00
Class 1 Cars:
£
45
00
Class 2 Cars:
£4
0
00
Class 3 Cars:
£3
000
Class 4 Cars:
£2000
In the event of an accident, the member will be charged for any costs for
recovery of the vehi
cle.

braddo

12,420 posts

219 months

Friday 26th April 2013
quotequote all
If one or a few of the cars are allowed to be used as track cars the £1000 per year membership won't be anywhere near enough to cover costs.

Have you even done any quick calcs to see what costs of a given fleet would be? Financing, depreciation, maintenance, insurance, storage, website, legal framework, advertising etc etc.