Compact 2.5ti - advice / opinions please
Compact 2.5ti - advice / opinions please
Author
Discussion

e21Mark

Original Poster:

17,749 posts

204 months

Thursday 25th April 2013
quotequote all
I have a little cash spare and want to buy something that can be used for track days, sprints & hillclimbs. Usually I would just go with another e21 however I have been offered a super clean 2.5ti Compact. I know the styling isn't to everyones taste but I quite like them. I'd like a 135i but they're just too much cash for my meagre means. So the question is should I go for it?

Do Compacts come with an LSD or do they have an electronic driver aid thing? Can an LSD easily be retro fitted?

Can any more power be released via a chip or remap?

What's the best suspension option?

What size wheel & tyre combo?

Is this a bad idea?

s m

24,494 posts

234 months

Friday 26th April 2013
quotequote all
e21Mark said:
I have a little cash spare and want to buy something that can be used for track days, sprints & hillclimbs. Usually I would just go with another e21 however I have been offered a super clean 2.5ti Compact. I know the styling isn't to everyones taste but I quite like them. I'd like a 135i but they're just too much cash for my meagre means. So the question is should I go for it?

Do Compacts come with an LSD or do they have an electronic driver aid thing? Can an LSD easily be retro fitted?

Can any more power be released via a chip or remap?

What's the best suspension option?

What size wheel & tyre combo?

Is this a bad idea?
Assuming it is an E46 version, then no Compacts came with a LSD. People have retro fitted an E46 M3 rear end into one with a fair bit of work.
I don't think E36 LSDs will fit into E46 casing without a fair bit of work either although no doubt someone has fitted one.

Quaife offer a torsen-type diff but unless you find one second hand I think it would cost you over 1k to have one fitted.
Drexler do very nice plate diffs but they're probably around double that cost.

As standard a 325ti will have the normal E46 DSC system which is stage switchable - if you press and hold the button down until both lights are on the dash you will be, effectively, in a normal open-diff car

drophead

1,056 posts

188 months

Friday 26th April 2013
quotequote all
e21Mark said:
I have a little cash spare and want to buy something that can be used for track days, sprints & hillclimbs. Usually I would just go with another e21 however I have been offered a super clean 2.5ti Compact. I know the styling isn't to everyones taste but I quite like them. I'd like a 135i but they're just too much cash for my meagre means. So the question is should I go for it?
Do Compacts come with an LSD or do they have an electronic driver aid thing?
They come with ASC. So no LSD unfortunately.

Can an LSD easily be retro fitted?
Yes but it is expensive. Most people fit an M3 rear subframe plus driveshafts or go to Quaife.

Can any more power be released via a chip or remap?
No idea but don't expect much more than 10% from an N/A M54 engine.

What's the best suspension option?
Can't help you on that one i'm afraid!

What size wheel & tyre combo?
See above. Sorry.

Is this a bad idea?
Not at all. There are a fair amount of people who use the Compact to go racing/rallying with the M54 still in place or drop an S54 in it instead!

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Nwqwn5vxITQ Although that has an M3 engine fitted!

http://forums.eurocca.net/showthread.php/36159-E46...




Ranger 6

7,736 posts

280 months

Friday 26th April 2013
quotequote all
Mark - I think it's a good little car with loads of potential.
Have a look on http://www.bmw-rallying.co.uk there's a wealth of knowledge. It's not the busiest place, but the folk there know their stuff.

ratty6464

637 posts

241 months

Friday 26th April 2013
quotequote all
I had a 51 plate 325Ti. was an excellent car with willing engine. you'll release loads of potential just by stripping the interior out and upgrading the brakes.

s m

24,494 posts

234 months

Friday 26th April 2013
quotequote all
By the way, nice E21 Mark, enjoyed my old 323i a lot ( 5-speeder, LSD, Recaros, BBS spoiler and wheels, henna orange.... )
Look forward to reading more about yours


I think you'll find a Compact has a bit of the same 'wieldy' feel

e21Mark

Original Poster:

17,749 posts

204 months

Friday 26th April 2013
quotequote all
Thanks for the input guys. I'm pretty much sold on the idea but the lack of an LSD is the only fly in the ointment really.

The 2.5 seems powerful enough for now and am going to junk the OE seats and replace the rear and side windows with lexan. I figure it will still be civilised enough for the road but still fun on track.

As an aside I wish the e21 was a bit closer to being finished. The engine swap is taking longer as we've gone with custom mounts instead of 323 ones. The new brake kit arrived and we junked the stupid linkage that BMW used to convert to RHD.

No stupid half ton servo mount and a much neater look. I found a nice remote servo kit to add.



Bigger discs & calipers plus Hawk pads, which are the best I've used at the price.





I know I'm biased but it should look awesome. I've not cut any corners and even the bumpers and light lenses are brand new! I could have bought a brand new Fiat Panda instead.


gro8885

27 posts

168 months

Saturday 1st October 2016
quotequote all
Old topic I know, but I have a lot of the same questions, having just acquired an e46 325ti compact for track days.

What's the best suspension option?

What size wheel & tyre combo?

@e21mark what did you go for in the end?


Mr Tidy

31,905 posts

158 months

Monday 3rd October 2016
quotequote all
gro8885 said:
Old topic I know, but I have a lot of the same questions, having just acquired an e46 325ti compact for track days.

What's the best suspension option?

What size wheel & tyre combo?

@e21mark what did you go for in the end?

Head to the "325ti Appreciation Thread" in BMW general - you should find answers to your questions there. thumbup

e21Mark

Original Poster:

17,749 posts

204 months

Tuesday 4th October 2016
quotequote all
gro8885 said:
@e21mark what did you go for in the end?


I did run a 325ti for a while though and I think they're cracking little cars. An LSD and some decent suspension, along with a set of 16 x 8 / 225/50's would be my suggestion for mods. An m52/2.8 with an inlet swap and remap maybe? Or an s50?

iSore

4,011 posts

175 months

Tuesday 4th October 2016
quotequote all
3.0 M54, a direct swap - you could do it in a day with assistance. 231 bhp on the shorter 2.5 diff and a little less weight.

KrisP

624 posts

211 months

Tuesday 4th October 2016
quotequote all
iSore said:
3.0 M54, a direct swap - you could do it in a day with assistance. 231 bhp on the shorter 2.5 diff and a little less weight.
Any guides or pointers for this swap? I'm handy enough with the spanners, but would like to read around first

FredClogs

14,041 posts

192 months

Tuesday 4th October 2016
quotequote all
KrisP said:
iSore said:
3.0 M54, a direct swap - you could do it in a day with assistance. 231 bhp on the shorter 2.5 diff and a little less weight.
Any guides or pointers for this swap? I'm handy enough with the spanners, but would like to read around first
Head over to the appreciation thread and there are some reader cars build threads to detailing the work people on here have done. I know a guy with a 3.2 M3 engine in a compact, it's a beast and not massively difficult to do but unless you're buying one that's written off (his was a savaged engine fire car for £300 and a rolled M3 for £1500) then financially you could just buy a cheaper e46 M3. The later face lifted compacts have the 6 speed box so make the engine swap much easier I think.