How can people just drive past an accident?
Discussion
I was driving down the M3 last night and a guy about 150yds ahead of me suddenly lost it completely (possibly a blowout) and went head-on into the central reservation, bounced off and came to rest parked sideways across the middle lane (car was totalled). I stopped and checked he was ok, phoned it in, waited for the police, helped push the wreck off the carriageway etc as I thought anyone would. The emergency services were great, the police and ambulance were there in about 5-10 minutes and were very pleasant to deal with and the situation was under control fairly quickly but what astonished me was this:
There were several cars in between me and the accident (and just behind me) who saw it happen and instead of stopping just went round and f
d off into the distance. In fact the only people who stopped were myself, a paramedic who happened to be passing and a couple of guys from the borders agency who also happened to be passing. All the other members of the public just drove straight on past, crunching over glass and bits of plastic to do so. How can people just drive past after seeing someone crash at some speed and not at least stop to see if everyone was ok? It reminded me of those youtube videos of accidents in China where everyone just drives on by without giving a f
k.
There were several cars in between me and the accident (and just behind me) who saw it happen and instead of stopping just went round and f
d off into the distance. In fact the only people who stopped were myself, a paramedic who happened to be passing and a couple of guys from the borders agency who also happened to be passing. All the other members of the public just drove straight on past, crunching over glass and bits of plastic to do so. How can people just drive past after seeing someone crash at some speed and not at least stop to see if everyone was ok? It reminded me of those youtube videos of accidents in China where everyone just drives on by without giving a f
k.krisdelta said:
Surely the fact that people had already stopped meant others felt they didn't need to.
Not everyone has the confidence to step into situations like that so the fact that people with the right skills did stop is a result?
That's just it, there were people in front of me who just drove round and off into the distance when nobody had stopped at all yet.Not everyone has the confidence to step into situations like that so the fact that people with the right skills did stop is a result?
I'd have no idea what to do to help, and would probably just get in the way. I'll stop to call the emergency services, and wait for the police if I witnessed the actual crash so that I can give a statement.
I guess if I was first on the scene, I'd try and help, but I really don't know. Fortunately, I've never been in that situation.
I guess if I was first on the scene, I'd try and help, but I really don't know. Fortunately, I've never been in that situation.
Krikkit said:
Aside from the people that saw it happen, how many need to stop? If everyone did you'd have a huge car park pretty quickly. You and a few other folks stopped, and the ambulance was there within 10 minutes.
Well yes, once at least one or two people have stopped then there is no point everyone else stopping if they can safely drive past, it was the people right behind the accident before anyone had stopped at all that got me, all they could think to do was drive round and get home quicker?I've had this twice now.
The first one was a similar scenario to what you described; heading down the M6, a chap in the middle lane drifted right, then snapped immediately left shooting off down an embankment, through two fences and coming to a stop embedded in a tree a good distance from the motorway. Despite him being a good 2/ 300 yards in front of me, and a number of cars between us, no-one stopped other than myself.
Second one, was just down the road from me - in fact, if anyone knows it, it was on the roundabout outside Bell & Colvill Lotus. Some old dear failed to stop at said roundabout and flattened a biker who was part way round it at the time. Granted I was the first on the scene as I was behind her at the time, but this guy was clearly shook-up & mildly injured.
Inserting some rehashed joke about not being powerfully built and all that noise, it was left to me to pick up his bike. I'm not big on bikes, but I'm 95% sure it was a Triumph Thunderbird or equivalent which is a f***ing heavy bike. Yeah fine, it doesn't take 6 people to phone for an ambulance, but the fact people just sat in their cars, staring away like it was some TV series pissed me off a bit.
Even more so the stupid cow that tried crossing the roundabout whilst all this was still going on, despite seeing exactly what had just happened.
The first one was a similar scenario to what you described; heading down the M6, a chap in the middle lane drifted right, then snapped immediately left shooting off down an embankment, through two fences and coming to a stop embedded in a tree a good distance from the motorway. Despite him being a good 2/ 300 yards in front of me, and a number of cars between us, no-one stopped other than myself.
Second one, was just down the road from me - in fact, if anyone knows it, it was on the roundabout outside Bell & Colvill Lotus. Some old dear failed to stop at said roundabout and flattened a biker who was part way round it at the time. Granted I was the first on the scene as I was behind her at the time, but this guy was clearly shook-up & mildly injured.
Inserting some rehashed joke about not being powerfully built and all that noise, it was left to me to pick up his bike. I'm not big on bikes, but I'm 95% sure it was a Triumph Thunderbird or equivalent which is a f***ing heavy bike. Yeah fine, it doesn't take 6 people to phone for an ambulance, but the fact people just sat in their cars, staring away like it was some TV series pissed me off a bit.
Even more so the stupid cow that tried crossing the roundabout whilst all this was still going on, despite seeing exactly what had just happened.
I once followed somebody down a side street in the dark when they for no apparent reason crossed to the other side of the road. It was only as I got closer that I realised they had driven around an old lady who had fallen in the road. They continued merrily on their way, I stopped and got her home.
I was in a the same situation a few years ago, I witnessed a car speeding in front of me lose control hit a couple of cars and split in two this was at 7.15 in the morning I stopped about 20 yards behind and ran to the car there was a passenger in the back wearing his seat belt and I checked him but he was killed on impact, on the pavement was another lad who had tried to run away after the crash but had broke both his ankles in the impact.
I heard moaning from underneath and knelt down to see another lad who when the car opened fell out and was dragged along underneath by his seat belt he had lost skin on his body, legs and face and his skull was clearly fractured, the fuel tank had split and smoke was coming from under the bonnet, I couldn't move the lad so got under as best I could lying in the petrol and blood I spoke to him and held his skull in place where it was opened on impact the other two occupants made off but were later arrested.
Now during all this which was no more than about three or four minutes local residents had come out of their homes after hearing the impact and only a couple of people came to help me and looked after the lad with the broken ankles, I heard comments such as "leave him to die mate their just scum" Now this may or may not have been the case but at the time they were all someone's son, the emergency services arrived and I left it to them. One of the residents who came over let me wash the blood off my hands in their house.
I think it's just the way people are, up until this moment happened I had never been in that sort of situation and never have since, no one knows what they will do when the moment arises to step up an do, it just came instinctively to me at the time and I'm proud off the actions I took and hopefully should I come across something similar do the right thing again.
I heard moaning from underneath and knelt down to see another lad who when the car opened fell out and was dragged along underneath by his seat belt he had lost skin on his body, legs and face and his skull was clearly fractured, the fuel tank had split and smoke was coming from under the bonnet, I couldn't move the lad so got under as best I could lying in the petrol and blood I spoke to him and held his skull in place where it was opened on impact the other two occupants made off but were later arrested.
Now during all this which was no more than about three or four minutes local residents had come out of their homes after hearing the impact and only a couple of people came to help me and looked after the lad with the broken ankles, I heard comments such as "leave him to die mate their just scum" Now this may or may not have been the case but at the time they were all someone's son, the emergency services arrived and I left it to them. One of the residents who came over let me wash the blood off my hands in their house.
I think it's just the way people are, up until this moment happened I had never been in that sort of situation and never have since, no one knows what they will do when the moment arises to step up an do, it just came instinctively to me at the time and I'm proud off the actions I took and hopefully should I come across something similar do the right thing again.
Worse i've had was an old dear who hit a parked car outside my house, and ended up on her roof.
A few people came out to help until the police and fire got there.
Luckily, i had parked on the drive that day.
Another was coming out of lakeside, near the Decathlon.
Newish R1 bike overtakes me and 2 cars in front. Get up to the top roundabout, about 2-300yards up the road, and see the biker in the air, above the cars in front.
He's high-sided, landed pretty hard straddling L3 and L2, and has his bike laying in the middle of the L2. 2nd car stops and helps, I move over to L2 to block traffic and stop him getting hit even more. 1st car zooms off.
Another biker comes up and turns his bike off, and assists with directing traffic around the stopped cars.
Eventually police turn up and ask if there were any witnesses. Turns out the car in front wasn't very happy about being overtaken, accelerated to cut off the bikers gap and clipped/rammed the biker when he tried to go round him. And then drove off.
A few people came out to help until the police and fire got there.
Luckily, i had parked on the drive that day.
Another was coming out of lakeside, near the Decathlon.
Newish R1 bike overtakes me and 2 cars in front. Get up to the top roundabout, about 2-300yards up the road, and see the biker in the air, above the cars in front.
He's high-sided, landed pretty hard straddling L3 and L2, and has his bike laying in the middle of the L2. 2nd car stops and helps, I move over to L2 to block traffic and stop him getting hit even more. 1st car zooms off.
Another biker comes up and turns his bike off, and assists with directing traffic around the stopped cars.
Eventually police turn up and ask if there were any witnesses. Turns out the car in front wasn't very happy about being overtaken, accelerated to cut off the bikers gap and clipped/rammed the biker when he tried to go round him. And then drove off.
Its the same when people have broken down (non-motorway). Everyone will happily queue and moan for half an hour about the delay. But will anyone get out and help the poor chap/chapess to move their car to somewhere a little more convenient? Of course not.
re: your original post, I would have stopped too but if I was a few cars back and saw that several other cars had stopped I would have carried on. Had I witnessed the accident, I would have stopped regardless. Carrying on after seeing someone potentially need urgent help or just some reassurance that help is on the way from someone/anyone - and to ignore that - goes against everything that is human and decent.
re: your original post, I would have stopped too but if I was a few cars back and saw that several other cars had stopped I would have carried on. Had I witnessed the accident, I would have stopped regardless. Carrying on after seeing someone potentially need urgent help or just some reassurance that help is on the way from someone/anyone - and to ignore that - goes against everything that is human and decent.
kdri155 said:
I was in a the same situation a few years ago, I witnessed a car speeding in front of me lose control hit a couple of cars and split in two this was at 7.15 in the morning I stopped about 20 yards behind and ran to the car there was a passenger in the back wearing his seat belt and I checked him but he was killed on impact, on the pavement was another lad who had tried to run away after the crash but had broke both his ankles in the impact.
I heard moaning from underneath and knelt down to see another lad who when the car opened fell out and was dragged along underneath by his seat belt he had lost skin on his body, legs and face and his skull was clearly fractured, the fuel tank had split and smoke was coming from under the bonnet, I couldn't move the lad so got under as best I could lying in the petrol and blood I spoke to him and held his skull in place where it was opened on impact the other two occupants made off but were later arrested.
Now during all this which was no more than about three or four minutes local residents had come out of their homes after hearing the impact and only a couple of people came to help me and looked after the lad with the broken ankles, I heard comments such as "leave him to die mate their just scum" Now this may or may not have been the case but at the time they were all someone's son, the emergency services arrived and I left it to them. One of the residents who came over let me wash the blood off my hands in their house.
I think it's just the way people are, up until this moment happened I had never been in that sort of situation and never have since, no one knows what they will do when the moment arises to step up an do, it just came instinctively to me at the time and I'm proud off the actions I took and hopefully should I come across something similar do the right thing again.
The view of those residents is a view more often then not expressed on hereI heard moaning from underneath and knelt down to see another lad who when the car opened fell out and was dragged along underneath by his seat belt he had lost skin on his body, legs and face and his skull was clearly fractured, the fuel tank had split and smoke was coming from under the bonnet, I couldn't move the lad so got under as best I could lying in the petrol and blood I spoke to him and held his skull in place where it was opened on impact the other two occupants made off but were later arrested.
Now during all this which was no more than about three or four minutes local residents had come out of their homes after hearing the impact and only a couple of people came to help me and looked after the lad with the broken ankles, I heard comments such as "leave him to die mate their just scum" Now this may or may not have been the case but at the time they were all someone's son, the emergency services arrived and I left it to them. One of the residents who came over let me wash the blood off my hands in their house.
I think it's just the way people are, up until this moment happened I had never been in that sort of situation and never have since, no one knows what they will do when the moment arises to step up an do, it just came instinctively to me at the time and I'm proud off the actions I took and hopefully should I come across something similar do the right thing again.
I'm usually the one to stop, can't help it, someone needs to take control and in the absence of anyone official I'll usually step in, once everything is in order to be honest a load of useless folk who don't know what to do will hinder the job more than help it, if they just drive past it is obvious they're not able to help (eg off duty doctor or cop) so best they keep going and don't crowd the situation.
I used to drive for a community transport charity (old and disabled people, in a minibus, as a volunteer) and one time came around the corner and saw an old dear take a real fall, I whipped across and blocked her from traffic with my bus till the ambulance arrived (called by me) and did basic first aid on her, I had a bus full of old people at the time, apologised to them for the delay but they were all reasonable about it, I got a round of applause when I got back on board
I used to drive for a community transport charity (old and disabled people, in a minibus, as a volunteer) and one time came around the corner and saw an old dear take a real fall, I whipped across and blocked her from traffic with my bus till the ambulance arrived (called by me) and did basic first aid on her, I had a bus full of old people at the time, apologised to them for the delay but they were all reasonable about it, I got a round of applause when I got back on board

Gassing Station | General Gassing | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


