What company car... Audi/BMW/Other
What company car... Audi/BMW/Other
Author
Discussion

T1547

Original Poster:

1,248 posts

165 months

Friday 26th April 2013
quotequote all
I'm moving into a company car in a few weeks and with a budget of £27500 have been having a look to see what's available. It seems this price is on the high end of premium hatchbacks (A3/BMW1) or low end of premium saloons (A5 hatch/BMW 3). These are what I have come up with as a shortlist..

Audi A3 1.8 TFSI S line S tronic (3/5 dr) - 0-60 7.3s (50mpg)

BMW 125d M sport (manual) - 0-60 6.5s (58mpg)

BMW 120d Msport auto with NAV - 0-60 7.3s (64mpg)

BMW 320i m sport (manual) - 0-60 7.2s (45mpg)

Audi A5 hatchback 1.8 TFSI poverty spec (manual) - 0-60 8.2s (46mpg)

Things that are important to me - speed, refinement, toys, looks, economy (all the above are economical enough for me). I haven't listed the CO2 figures for company tax but they're all within budget.

Coming from an E60 525d.

Which would you choose? Any other suggestions?

Would be great to hear from anyone with experience of these cars.


A900ss

3,314 posts

183 months

Friday 26th April 2013
quotequote all
What mileage and what sort of mileage do you do?

For me it would be between the 120 auto and 125 manual depending upon type of miles you drive.

I do fairly big miles so I went with the x20d auto. The 8 speed auto is fantastic from BMW.

Good luck.


T1547

Original Poster:

1,248 posts

165 months

Friday 26th April 2013
quotequote all
Should be in the region of 15-20k pa and mix of long motorway journeys and driving around town (London). I do quite fancy an auto - will be a first for me.

I've always been a big fan of BMW but there's also something very attractive about the A3 in Sportback S line guise as an overall package. What's the handling like on these? Substantially worse than the BMs?

Bonefish Blues

36,997 posts

254 months

Friday 26th April 2013
quotequote all
If you're interested in an interesting drive then cross that off your list now!
ETA something more positive.

Probably the 120D then, given your criteria.

Edited by Bonefish Blues on Friday 26th April 13:35


ETA - is a Golf GTI DSG obtainable on your list by any chance?

Edited by Bonefish Blues on Friday 26th April 13:39

oyster

13,802 posts

279 months

Friday 26th April 2013
quotequote all
T1547 said:
I'm moving into a company car in a few weeks and with a budget of £27500 have been having a look to see what's available. It seems this price is on the high end of premium hatchbacks (A3/BMW1) or low end of premium saloons (A5 hatch/BMW 3). These are what I have come up with as a shortlist..

Audi A3 1.8 TFSI S line S tronic (3/5 dr) - 0-60 7.3s (50mpg)

BMW 125d M sport (manual) - 0-60 6.5s (58mpg)

BMW 120d Msport auto with NAV - 0-60 7.3s (64mpg)

BMW 320i m sport (manual) - 0-60 7.2s (45mpg)

Audi A5 hatchback 1.8 TFSI poverty spec (manual) - 0-60 8.2s (46mpg)

Things that are important to me - badgespeed, badgerefinement, badgetoys, badgelooks, badgeeconomy (all the above are economical enough for me). I haven't listed the CO2 figures for company tax but they're all within budget.

Coming from an E60 525d.

Which would you choose? Any other suggestions?

Would be great to hear from anyone with experience of these cars.
Edited for the truth.

em177

3,150 posts

195 months

Friday 26th April 2013
quotequote all
Conventional:

- Diesel BMW/VAG with an auto box and as many toys as you can get to ease mile munching

Outside the box:

- GT86?



- Volvo V60 R Design



-

T1547

Original Poster:

1,248 posts

165 months

Friday 26th April 2013
quotequote all
oyster said:
Edited for the truth.
Haha can see how it would look that way.......

Care to offer an alternative? (ETA that would fit my criteria - the Germans have really wrapped this up from what I can see..)

Edited by T1547 on Friday 26th April 13:42

T1547

Original Poster:

1,248 posts

165 months

Friday 26th April 2013
quotequote all
em177 said:
Conventional:

- Diesel BMW/VAG with an auto box and as many toys as you can get to ease mile munching

Outside the box:

- GT86?



- Volvo V60 R Design



-
That Volvo looks very nice. GT86 a bit lary for work unfortunately.

What's the volvo engine? Mpg/0-60/CO2 wise?

mrslowly

64 posts

166 months

Friday 26th April 2013
quotequote all
Top-spec Mk7 Golf, or if the badge is important how about a Merc A220CDI?

Raoul Duke

939 posts

194 months

Friday 26th April 2013
quotequote all
Volvo with the D5 is 215bhp.
The S60 is 6.9s to 60, the V60 a fraction slower.
You'll struggle to get more poke for your money, with a sensible C02 output.

T1547

Original Poster:

1,248 posts

165 months

Friday 26th April 2013
quotequote all
Raoul Duke said:
Volvo with the D5 is 215bhp.
The S60 is 6.9s to 60, the V60 a fraction slower.
You'll struggle to get more poke for your money, with a sensible C02 output.
Would of been ideal but just checked and sadly out of budget.

Amateurish

8,290 posts

253 months

Friday 26th April 2013
quotequote all
Golf VII GTD 5 door DSG - comes just in budget

Zyp

16,178 posts

220 months

Friday 26th April 2013
quotequote all
Has to be a new car?

Amateurish

8,290 posts

253 months

Friday 26th April 2013
quotequote all
A 250 BlueEFFICIENCY AMG Sport DCT

211 bhp, 45.6 mpg, £27k

Faxo

449 posts

169 months

Friday 26th April 2013
quotequote all
Wouldn't entertain the poverty A5 - I'm thinking SE yea? No toys whatsoever, and the 1.8 is boring

The A3 is brilliant, go for Tech Pack for the handwriting recognition nav, DVD player etc

T1547

Original Poster:

1,248 posts

165 months

Saturday 27th April 2013
quotequote all
Ok so bit of an update, I received the paperwork through for the co. car policy and (unfortunately) it states has to be diesel. It also has to be Audi, Bmw, Ford, Mazda, Vauxhall, VW, Volvo - value up to 28k - no other restrictions.

I've been through the online Audi/BM car builders online and for the sort of options I'd like to add the car really needs to come in at around £25/26k.

Contenders from original list are now restricted to Bmw 120d m sport or Audi A3 2.0tdi sportback s line. Probably both manual to save cost.

Bmw 1 seems to be more expensive, worse spec, not as luxurious but a better steer and quicker.

Audi A3 interior is real nice, cheaper so can be specced with more toys, amazing economy/co2, more space, 5 door, bigger boot but performance is down (0-60 8.5s) and probably not as fun to drive.

To me the Audi seems somehow the more 'grown up' car - not sure why.

Other options could be Golf GTD (seems lot of money for Golf) or the new Mazda6 estate 2.2d fully loaded (gets positive reviews..)

Maybe the solution is comfy Co. diesel box + weekend car....

Edited by T1547 on Saturday 27th April 14:04

billzeebub

3,913 posts

230 months

Saturday 27th April 2013
quotequote all
Scirocco

legless

2,064 posts

171 months

Saturday 27th April 2013
quotequote all
Check out the VW CC too. I preferred mine to the BMW F30 that replaced it.

GreatGranny

9,519 posts

257 months

Saturday 27th April 2013
quotequote all
If the S/V60 is out of budget what about he V40?
Your budget will get the R-Design with 177 bhp and 114 co2 with about £5k left over for options or the R-Design Lux with about £1k for options.

Superhoop

4,919 posts

224 months

Sunday 28th April 2013
quotequote all
If you want toys, something that looks good and diesel with auto, from that list, I'd be looking at the new Mazda6 - 28k buys you a fully loaded Sport with 175ps and sub 120g/km

I am slightly biased though, having just picked one up