What company car... Audi/BMW/Other
Discussion
I'm moving into a company car in a few weeks and with a budget of £27500 have been having a look to see what's available. It seems this price is on the high end of premium hatchbacks (A3/BMW1) or low end of premium saloons (A5 hatch/BMW 3). These are what I have come up with as a shortlist..
Audi A3 1.8 TFSI S line S tronic (3/5 dr) - 0-60 7.3s (50mpg)
BMW 125d M sport (manual) - 0-60 6.5s (58mpg)
BMW 120d Msport auto with NAV - 0-60 7.3s (64mpg)
BMW 320i m sport (manual) - 0-60 7.2s (45mpg)
Audi A5 hatchback 1.8 TFSI poverty spec (manual) - 0-60 8.2s (46mpg)
Things that are important to me - speed, refinement, toys, looks, economy (all the above are economical enough for me). I haven't listed the CO2 figures for company tax but they're all within budget.
Coming from an E60 525d.
Which would you choose? Any other suggestions?
Would be great to hear from anyone with experience of these cars.
Audi A3 1.8 TFSI S line S tronic (3/5 dr) - 0-60 7.3s (50mpg)
BMW 125d M sport (manual) - 0-60 6.5s (58mpg)
BMW 120d Msport auto with NAV - 0-60 7.3s (64mpg)
BMW 320i m sport (manual) - 0-60 7.2s (45mpg)
Audi A5 hatchback 1.8 TFSI poverty spec (manual) - 0-60 8.2s (46mpg)
Things that are important to me - speed, refinement, toys, looks, economy (all the above are economical enough for me). I haven't listed the CO2 figures for company tax but they're all within budget.
Coming from an E60 525d.
Which would you choose? Any other suggestions?
Would be great to hear from anyone with experience of these cars.
Should be in the region of 15-20k pa and mix of long motorway journeys and driving around town (London). I do quite fancy an auto - will be a first for me.
I've always been a big fan of BMW but there's also something very attractive about the A3 in Sportback S line guise as an overall package. What's the handling like on these? Substantially worse than the BMs?
I've always been a big fan of BMW but there's also something very attractive about the A3 in Sportback S line guise as an overall package. What's the handling like on these? Substantially worse than the BMs?
If you're interested in an interesting drive then cross that off your list now!
ETA something more positive.
Probably the 120D then, given your criteria.
ETA - is a Golf GTI DSG obtainable on your list by any chance?
ETA something more positive.
Probably the 120D then, given your criteria.
Edited by Bonefish Blues on Friday 26th April 13:35
ETA - is a Golf GTI DSG obtainable on your list by any chance?
Edited by Bonefish Blues on Friday 26th April 13:39
T1547 said:
I'm moving into a company car in a few weeks and with a budget of £27500 have been having a look to see what's available. It seems this price is on the high end of premium hatchbacks (A3/BMW1) or low end of premium saloons (A5 hatch/BMW 3). These are what I have come up with as a shortlist..
Audi A3 1.8 TFSI S line S tronic (3/5 dr) - 0-60 7.3s (50mpg)
BMW 125d M sport (manual) - 0-60 6.5s (58mpg)
BMW 120d Msport auto with NAV - 0-60 7.3s (64mpg)
BMW 320i m sport (manual) - 0-60 7.2s (45mpg)
Audi A5 hatchback 1.8 TFSI poverty spec (manual) - 0-60 8.2s (46mpg)
Things that are important to me - badgespeed, badgerefinement, badgetoys, badgelooks, badgeeconomy (all the above are economical enough for me). I haven't listed the CO2 figures for company tax but they're all within budget.
Coming from an E60 525d.
Which would you choose? Any other suggestions?
Would be great to hear from anyone with experience of these cars.
Edited for the truth.Audi A3 1.8 TFSI S line S tronic (3/5 dr) - 0-60 7.3s (50mpg)
BMW 125d M sport (manual) - 0-60 6.5s (58mpg)
BMW 120d Msport auto with NAV - 0-60 7.3s (64mpg)
BMW 320i m sport (manual) - 0-60 7.2s (45mpg)
Audi A5 hatchback 1.8 TFSI poverty spec (manual) - 0-60 8.2s (46mpg)
Things that are important to me - badge
Coming from an E60 525d.
Which would you choose? Any other suggestions?
Would be great to hear from anyone with experience of these cars.
Ok so bit of an update, I received the paperwork through for the co. car policy and (unfortunately) it states has to be diesel. It also has to be Audi, Bmw, Ford, Mazda, Vauxhall, VW, Volvo - value up to 28k - no other restrictions.
I've been through the online Audi/BM car builders online and for the sort of options I'd like to add the car really needs to come in at around £25/26k.
Contenders from original list are now restricted to Bmw 120d m sport or Audi A3 2.0tdi sportback s line. Probably both manual to save cost.
Bmw 1 seems to be more expensive, worse spec, not as luxurious but a better steer and quicker.
Audi A3 interior is real nice, cheaper so can be specced with more toys, amazing economy/co2, more space, 5 door, bigger boot but performance is down (0-60 8.5s) and probably not as fun to drive.
To me the Audi seems somehow the more 'grown up' car - not sure why.
Other options could be Golf GTD (seems lot of money for Golf) or the new Mazda6 estate 2.2d fully loaded (gets positive reviews..)
Maybe the solution is comfy Co. diesel box + weekend car....
I've been through the online Audi/BM car builders online and for the sort of options I'd like to add the car really needs to come in at around £25/26k.
Contenders from original list are now restricted to Bmw 120d m sport or Audi A3 2.0tdi sportback s line. Probably both manual to save cost.
Bmw 1 seems to be more expensive, worse spec, not as luxurious but a better steer and quicker.
Audi A3 interior is real nice, cheaper so can be specced with more toys, amazing economy/co2, more space, 5 door, bigger boot but performance is down (0-60 8.5s) and probably not as fun to drive.
To me the Audi seems somehow the more 'grown up' car - not sure why.
Other options could be Golf GTD (seems lot of money for Golf) or the new Mazda6 estate 2.2d fully loaded (gets positive reviews..)
Maybe the solution is comfy Co. diesel box + weekend car....
Edited by T1547 on Saturday 27th April 14:04
Gassing Station | General Gassing | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff




