F*CKING INSURANCE!
Author
Discussion

richb77

Original Poster:

889 posts

192 months

Friday 26th April 2013
quotequote all
I know this has probably been done to death but what is really up with the insurance companies?

I have just bought a Saab Aero.

I go to insure it.

My current insurance is through Adrian Flux and has been on all my vehicles (peeked at 4) for 5 years.

I go through the online comparison sites first to find out that AXA will cover me fully comp with all the bells and whistles for £252. Not too bad...Not great though.

I try Zurich....£749 ("I'm sorry, a brain fart meant i heard seven hundred and forty nine English pounds"...."Yes thats correct")

I then ring up Flux and hope there is a deal to swap over from my last car (departed yesterday). Yes they can do that....But its £414.50 a year.

What the hell!

Same car and prices from £250-£750.

All the details where the same, 35 years old. Full clean licence since i was 17, One no fault accident 4 years ago and 10 years NCD (Which has been 10 years for at least the last 3 fking years).

Is there an industry approved dart board for quoting or are they just made up on an whim?

trickywoo

14,287 posts

261 months

Friday 26th April 2013
quotequote all
richb77 said:
they just made up on an whim?
This HTH

Freddy88FM

474 posts

165 months

Friday 26th April 2013
quotequote all
Different organisations have different strategies for determining and managing risk. They offer differing services in the event of a claim and differing levels of customer service and contact centre resource. The all have differing overheads and, for example, charge different rates for inbound calls, altering policies, adding drivers etc etc.

As far as I can see there is no reason insurance firms should charge similar amounts as their business plans can vary significantly.

richb77

Original Poster:

889 posts

192 months

Friday 26th April 2013
quotequote all
Freddy88FM said:
As far as I can see there is no reason insurance firms should charge similar amounts.
Really?

So AXA (A HUGE insurance company) with offices in Ipswich can charge less than someone like Zurich (Also a huge company with probably equally huge office somewhere) despite having similar overheads?

I can understand maybe £50 difference but £500 is just fking wrong.

rohrl

8,984 posts

176 months

Friday 26th April 2013
quotequote all
It's totally scandalous that different insurers with different underwriting criteria, different claims experience and different target customers should charge different premiums.

In fact it's almost as if the insurance market is made up of different companies, some of whom would really like you as a customer so offer a low premium while other insurers don't really want you as a customer so offer a higher premium.

richb77

Original Poster:

889 posts

192 months

Friday 26th April 2013
quotequote all
rohrl said:
It's totally scandalous that different insurers with different underwriting criteria, different claims experience and different target customers should charge different premiums.

In fact it's almost as if the insurance market is made up of different companies, some of whom would really like you as a customer so offer a low premium while other insurers don't really want you as a customer so offer a higher premium.
Sarcasm IS the lowest form of whit.

But i take the point about experience and targets.

Freddy88FM

474 posts

165 months

Friday 26th April 2013
quotequote all
richb77 said:
Really?

So AXA (A HUGE insurance company) with offices in Ipswich can charge less than someone like Zurich (Also a huge company with probably equally huge office somewhere) despite having similar overheads?

I can understand maybe £50 difference but £500 is just fking wrong.
It's less about overheads and more about strategy and approach to risk. Here Zurich (which is actually quite different structurally to AXA) thinks you're of higher risk than AXA...

Or at least, they feel the level of risk you represent does not fit with their strategy and would not be adequately hedged.

PH lurker

1,301 posts

188 months

Friday 26th April 2013
quotequote all
richb77 said:
Really?

So AXA (A HUGE insurance company) with offices in Ipswich can charge less than someone like Zurich (Also a huge company with probably equally huge office somewhere) despite having similar overheads?

I can understand maybe £50 difference but £500 is just fking wrong.
You're a specifc type of risk. Some firms want that risk more than others, shirly?

I know someone who will take a (similar 'value') £20 10/1 bet on a bike race, but not a £20 10/1 on a touring car race.

SpudLink

8,336 posts

223 months

Friday 26th April 2013
quotequote all
rohrl said:


In fact it's almost as if the insurance market is made up of different companies, some of whom would really like you as a customer so offer a low premium while other insurers don't really want you as a customer so offer a higher premium.
That's how I see it. Some companies would rather you go elsewhere, and they will stick to ensuring elderly ladies, or whatever their underwriters deem lowest risk.

iaincb1

1,406 posts

180 months

Friday 26th April 2013
quotequote all
Do some insurance companies not target a particular demographic so you may fall within one and they price well but another may not want you so price you out?

richb77

Original Poster:

889 posts

192 months

Friday 26th April 2013
quotequote all
currybum said:
Maybe AXA need to balance their risk portfolio by encouraging 35 year old angry internet men to sign up.
Thats my anger gone. Couldnt help but LOL at your comment smile

A13

294 posts

193 months

Friday 26th April 2013
quotequote all
Different insurer's have different rates.
Go for the cheapest and get on with it.

rohrl

8,984 posts

176 months

Friday 26th April 2013
quotequote all
iaincb1 said:
Do some insurance companies not target a particular demographic so you may fall within one and they price well but another may not want you so price you out?
They do. Some insurers for example specialise in drivers who have been banned for drink-driving. Those are their target customer so they deliberately give a premium 10% or so lower than the rest of the market. If you gave them your details as a 100% safe driver who has never had so much as a parking ticket they wouldn't be interested and they'd give you a "fk-off premium" (a premium designed to get you to fk off).

You may wonder why anyone would want to insure someone who has just been banned for drink driving but the specialist insurer will know all about this market. They may well be able to look at other variables to work out who is likely to get another ban and who will never make the same mistake again. Banned drivers of course are already expecting to pay a large premium so premium income is high.

In short you will always be someone's ideal customer so the answer is to shop around and not to take it personally if one insurer or other doesn't give you a competitive premium. Fortunately it's never been easier to shop around for insurance with the number of price comaprison sites available. I can't think of a more transparent market than vehicle insurance right now.

fjord

2,143 posts

168 months

Friday 26th April 2013
quotequote all
>Gets quoted £252 on an Aero.
>Proceeds to complain.


richb77

Original Poster:

889 posts

192 months

Friday 26th April 2013
quotequote all
fjord said:
>Gets quoted £252 on an Aero.
>Proceeds to complain.

Missed the point.

I was complaining about the wild variation NOT the premium wink

petrolsniffer

2,567 posts

205 months

Friday 26th April 2013
quotequote all
^^^^ what he said

My rewnewal is due soon cheapest thus far is £1800 although I do have a colorful history in the past year (three accidents two my fault) so will prob have to suck it up an pay i'd love to swap shoes and take your highest quote!

tom2019

770 posts

226 months

Friday 26th April 2013
quotequote all
Add the value of insurance onto petrol , while you're at it add road tax and be done with it.

fjord

2,143 posts

168 months

Friday 26th April 2013
quotequote all
richb77 said:
Missed the point.

I was complaining about the wild variation NOT the premium wink
Why should everybody be the same? They wouldnt make any money if every company charged the exact same price as everyone else. It's kinda to be expected.

Nedzilla

2,439 posts

205 months

Friday 26th April 2013
quotequote all
I recieved quotes of between £580 and £8000+ at my last renewal!!

JayP1

280 posts

204 months

Friday 26th April 2013
quotequote all
rohrl said:
It's totally scandalous that different insurers with different underwriting criteria, different claims experience and different target customers should charge different premiums.

In fact it's almost as if the insurance market is made up of different companies, some of whom would really like you as a customer so offer a low premium while other insurers don't really want you as a customer so offer a higher premium.
By the way, not strictly accurate - there are only a very few actual insurance companies, but just trading until a multiple of different names.

Edited by JayP1 on Friday 26th April 16:50