EVO and Autocar, who's right?
EVO and Autocar, who's right?
Author
Discussion

Bezza1969

Original Poster:

777 posts

179 months

Friday 26th April 2013
quotequote all
Im really confused this week (well most of the time these days.) Last week EVO 183 dropped through my letterbox and there were first drives of the new Golf GTI and basic model Porsche Cayman, the latter of which for me, is just about perfection. Nick Trott drove the Golf GTI, gave it 4 stars and said it was clinical. Harry Metcalfe drove the Cayman gave it 4 stars and said it doesnt deliver. Fast forward to weds and I buy Autocar. Steve Sutcliffe drives new Golf, gushes about it being so good "im blown away" and gives it 4.5 stars. Full Road test of Porsche Cayman, basic model and the full 5 stars with the statement "utterly dominant class champion". Now Im a big fan of EVO but also highly respect Steve Sutcliffe so who could be right? Recently EVO and Autocar seem more and more at odds on stuff like this and the Toyota GT86 which Autocar love and EVO sort of love a bit....Seems to be a theme here though, EVO seem to expect full fireworks in the straight line performance category, whereas AUTOCAR seem to be more interested in the overall package. Confusing for us enthusiasts who take an interest in the motoring mags.

rohrl

8,984 posts

176 months

Friday 26th April 2013
quotequote all
Historically and generally Autocar are always piss-their-pants excited about any new car while Evo are a little more measured. Evo do seem to be a bit power obsessed though, similar to some posters here who would never consider anything with less than 400bhp and consider a Sierra Cosworth dangerously underpowered. I suppose different testers have different opinions and different examples of the same car can feel different depending on the road, weather and which side of bed the tester got out of bed that morning.

As an aside it's odd how important a largely arbitrary star rating applied by a total stranger can be to some people - ever seen the letters from owners complaining that their chosen conveyance only got 4 stars when they felt it was a solid 4 and a half?

The Vambo

7,797 posts

172 months

Friday 26th April 2013
quotequote all
rohrl said:
Historically and generally Autocar are always piss-their-pants excited about any new car while Evo are a little more measured. Evo do seem to be a bit power obsessed though, similar to some posters here who would never consider anything with less than 400bhp and consider a Sierra Cosworth dangerously underpowered. I suppose different testers have different opinions and different examples of the same car can feel different depending on the road, weather and which side of bed the tester got out of bed that morning.
You have just ruined this thread by pretty much summing it up in the first post.

Ozzie Osmond

21,189 posts

277 months

Friday 26th April 2013
quotequote all
Bezza1969 said:
Harry Metcalfe drove the Cayman gave it 4 stars and said it doesnt deliver.
If he doesn't like the Cayman, I wonder what he'd spend his £40k on instead?

R5YUP

1,187 posts

244 months

Friday 26th April 2013
quotequote all
rohrl said:
Historically and generally Autocar are always piss-their-pants excited about any new car
Spot on! I want to like this magazine so much, but I'm afraid it's just full of crap articles and sensationalist headlines.

(Unless its changed recently?)

037

1,377 posts

178 months

Friday 26th April 2013
quotequote all
I saw a new Caymen this morning. It looked stunning!!

stevesingo

5,048 posts

253 months

Friday 26th April 2013
quotequote all
I find Evo a little pretencious. Always gushing about the same cars, particularly when looking at the older stuff. They masturbate furiously over 911s, in fact I can't remember the last issue without a 911 featured of some sort.. Just a bunch of very lucky people who seem to rub the readers noses in the fact 99% of readers will never get the opportunity to do what they do.

simonrockman

7,136 posts

286 months

Friday 26th April 2013
quotequote all
stevesingo said:
I find Evo a little pretencious. Always gushing about the same cars, particularly when looking at the older stuff. They masturbate furiously over 911s, in fact I can't remember the last issue without a 911 featured of some sort.. Just a bunch of very lucky people who seem to rub the readers noses in the fact 99% of readers will never get the opportunity to do what they do.
at least they didn't put a 911 in against the R8, 458 and 12C

markcoopers

794 posts

224 months

Friday 26th April 2013
quotequote all
4 or 4.5 out of 5 looks pretty consistent to me.

If you are interested in either car, then perhaps driving them for yourself would be best?

Evo I like as it covers not only the cars but also the roads, scenery, places etc..... Makes me feel closer to the experience

LaurasOtherHalf

21,429 posts

227 months

Friday 26th April 2013
quotequote all
I'm really enjoying Evo again but I'm always puzzled by their star rating- it's got to be a real st box to get 3 stars, can be still pretty naff & get 4 stars & have glaring faults & get 4.5 stars.

Everything else gets 5.

Fantuzzi

3,297 posts

177 months

Friday 26th April 2013
quotequote all
Ive always found its rather a bit of pot luck with mags, even within the mags, take EVO Maserati GT never a bad word against it, then the sport came out suddenly this model was what the car should have been all along, as if the models were flawed from 2007 onwards. Then the XKR, was 90 something in there 100 greatest cars, then slated it in their 991 group test, really wouldnt touch the thing if you had used that to base your opinion.

Its annoying.

On the matter of different mags you do get rather crazy stuff take the Alfa 8C, some seemed to hate the thing (Autocar steve) then other reviews were more measured (evo). To a certain extent most mags tend to agree mainly, but the opinions will differ slightly.

Then you get some people who go against the grain, take Harris on the MX-5, there might be loads of journos who agree yet didnt get remembered for it, or perhaps got pushed aside by more senior members of a team.

Best thing is to let the mags get rid of the really crap cars, then drive them yourself, youll know if you can live with the steering feel or if the rides too hard.

r11co

6,244 posts

261 months

Friday 26th April 2013
quotequote all
LaurasOtherHalf said:
I'm really enjoying Evo again but I'm always puzzled by their star rating- it's got to be a real st box to get 3 stars, can be still pretty naff & get 4 stars & have glaring faults & get 4.5 stars.

Everything else gets 5.
Otherwise the manufacturers won't give them any more cars to play with.

Vested interests are everywhere!

Neil O

76 posts

262 months

Friday 26th April 2013
quotequote all
Not being a regular pistonheads type (ie not a CEO of a powerful thrusting co. and driving god) I think we need the opinion of a wild tame monkey to spill the beans.

Welshbeef

49,633 posts

229 months

Friday 26th April 2013
quotequote all
Doesn't sound like a huge difference to me 4 or 4.5 out of 5....

End of the day this is someone's perspective admittedly an educated perspective.

If your in the market for a GTI then your certainly not in the market for a Gayman they would never be competitors unless used and similar price.

Is the new GTI 250bhp?

Fantuzzi

3,297 posts

177 months

Saturday 27th April 2013
quotequote all
Welshbeef said:
Gayman
What? How is the Cayman 'gay'?

By that Im guessing you mean limp wristed and infeminate by the way.

Gruber

6,313 posts

245 months

Saturday 27th April 2013
quotequote all
Evo gave my car 5 stars, so I like them best. So there. tongue out

philmots

4,666 posts

291 months

Saturday 27th April 2013
quotequote all
I don't bother buying any anymore.. Read reviews of cars online for nothing.

With the star rating I couldn't give a st what someone else thinks. I make my own mind up and buy what I want.

Dusty964

7,396 posts

221 months

Saturday 27th April 2013
quotequote all
Why would anyone even care?
If you were in the market for either, you would go and drive them? The views of a journalist wouldn't influence the purchase.
Whilst prepared to be outcast for my views, i cannot stand Evo. I bought it for a couple of years, and got bored of the overly flowery prose and the fact that the writers see themselves as some kind of industry celebrity.
When they reported about the McLaren and how their suggestions led to detail changes, I stopped buying it, or even reading it.


nixon1

216 posts

191 months

Saturday 27th April 2013
quotequote all
Fantuzzi said:
Welshbeef said:
Gayman
What? How is the Cayman 'gay'?

By that Im guessing you mean limp wristed and infeminate by the way.
Maybe the in-car siri equiv is asking for a banana in the rear, the interior to be pink and that all this plastic is ruining the zen. Or maybe we could ignore this fellow smile

That aside- autoexpress are giving it 5 out of 5. So maybe we can take an average and say 5/5, EVO is right? Either way its a fantastic car.


Edited by nixon1 on Saturday 27th April 08:47

laingy

676 posts

272 months

Saturday 27th April 2013
quotequote all
Advertising revenue?