02-04 MINI C/S or 05+ Fiesta ST or???
02-04 MINI C/S or 05+ Fiesta ST or???
Author
Discussion

Zippee

Original Poster:

14,159 posts

265 months

Sunday 28th April 2013
quotequote all
Budget circa 3.5-5k - I want an everyday small hot hatch that will be happy to use as an occasional track day car, so needs a balance of fun, handling, comfort, reliability and a reasonable turn of speed. Something I can also run to the shops in without worrying about door dinks, canm park easily in tight spaces (MY current TVR and propsed R8 once the TVR sells are not good for this category). I want to keep my good car as a decent weather toy - not something for everyday use in crap weather.
Looking in the classifieds I could get a 02-04 MINI Cooper S within budget but what are these like in terms of running costs and reliability.
Alternatively a Fiesta ST - 05-07 for a similar price as the MINI with similar mileage. Again - any comments on running/ownership?
Alternatively anything I may have overlooked?

kiethton

14,672 posts

211 months

Sunday 28th April 2013
quotequote all
Clio 197?

Zippee

Original Poster:

14,159 posts

265 months

Sunday 28th April 2013
quotequote all
kiethton said:
Clio 197?
Hmmm!!! http://www.pistonheads.com/classifieds/used-cars/r...

Isn't Renault build quality a bit on the pants side though? I want a balance of decent day to day comfort as well as hooning fun!

kiethton

14,672 posts

211 months

Sunday 28th April 2013
quotequote all
IIIRC it's ok on the Renalutsport models, its just the vanilla cars which are lacking.

I was considering one recently but settled on aCivic Type R as i needed a little more space.

daemon

40,169 posts

228 months

Sunday 28th April 2013
quotequote all
I would avoid older MINI's as they can be expensive to maintain - gearbox and steering rack problems abound.

I'd go for the ST or the 197. Probably the 197.

Ten Four

292 posts

182 months

Sunday 28th April 2013
quotequote all
Running a Nov 02 Cooper S atm with 140k km. I have to do a P/S pump and engine mounts (age).. Rest of the car is perfect and on really grippy bridgestones, its fantastic. Just got to get round to fitting that Dave F intake for the whine! Good MPG, fun to drive and comfy...

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UkU3JYaxW6k

Olly86

133 posts

170 months

Sunday 28th April 2013
quotequote all
I had an 03 Mini Cooper S with the JCW upgrade and its a cracking little car. Great fun on the twisties, had mine around 18 months with no issues.
I would say avoid the JCW kitted versions, there not worth the premium over the standard S. Spend the money on a reduced S/C pulley and manifold for the near enough the same power upgrade.

ArsE92

21,402 posts

218 months

Sunday 28th April 2013
quotequote all
Cooper S.

Then do thishehe

chrisw666

22,655 posts

230 months

Sunday 28th April 2013
quotequote all
Mitsibushi Colt CZT would be worth a look, in budget, tuneable turbo lump, practical little thing & pretty anonymous.


minipower

966 posts

250 months

Sunday 28th April 2013
quotequote all
You could get a Clio 182 or a 172 in fantastic condition for the lower end of your budget. That money should get you one with the belts done.
I'd then give it to Mark Fish motorsport with the rest of your budget to make it even more track ready.

Zippee

Original Poster:

14,159 posts

265 months

Monday 29th April 2013
quotequote all
Thanks all - so the 197 Clio is not as good as the older 172? I want something reasonably modern, it won't be a pure track toy (occasional only) and needs to be a fun but comfy everyday car (leaving my big toy as the special one).
The Fiesta ST kind of appeals in terms of reliability/running costs, the MINI in terms of fun but I've 'heard' horror stories with running costs - water pumps especially. How much truth is there in this?
I spend enough on the TVR each year so don't want a second car that's going to cost similar to run

minipower

966 posts

250 months

Monday 29th April 2013
quotequote all
The 197 got a luke warm reception when it was released. It needed to be revved hard to get anything out of it.
The 182 is comfy for everyday use although don't expect big car refinement on the motorway. I drove mine from the south of England up to the highlands and found it fine however. They also come with climate control, cruise control, xenon lights, isofix rear and automatic wipers so they are quite well equipped for a small car.
Parts are cheap although they do go through consumables at a high rate.
For more money you could get a 182 trophy. They are fantastic cars but can be slightly more expensive to run than the normal 182 due to the Sachs dampers.