RANT: Why can't people be honest when selling a car!
RANT: Why can't people be honest when selling a car!
Author
Discussion

Marc p

Original Poster:

1,124 posts

173 months

Sunday 28th April 2013
quotequote all
Ok, so I have been after a nice 944 for a while now, ideally in Guards Red and ideally a bridge spoiler model, so when the below came up for sale, I thought it could be worth the 700 mile/13 hour trip:

http://www.pistonheads.com/classifieds/used-cars/p...

After talking it over with the owner on the phone and him being fully aware of how far I was traveling, the car had the below faults:

Slight rust on sill, bottom of front wings and small spot below rear Porsche sticker and a rear wheel bearing hum, after a few photos of the rust, I was happy that it wasn't catastrophic and you would be looking at around £500 for a repair. So I left him a deposit of £150 and said I would make the trip the next weekend and asked him to confirm that the above were the only faults he knew of, other than that, the car was in very good condition mechanically, bodywork and interior and he confirmed this.

So imagine my surprise after an epic drive to arrive to a car that had the below faults visibly evident:

- Filler around the rear arch which was cracking and actually falling out(this was on the bodywork itself, you didn't have to look inside the arch to see this).

- Poor respray that was flaking around the door rubbing strips and front washer jets.

- Filler above the rear sills.

- Twisted rear bumper which didn't fit properly at one side and left a large gap.

- The rust on the rear below the Porsche sticker was not a small spot, the rust was all the way along the whole panel and had risen well into the Porsche sticker(the photo in the advert must be old as you would easily see it in a photo).

- Spoiler bracket wasn't attached as didn't fit properly(really raised at the front on one side).

- The leatherette on the drivers bolster was in terrible condition and missing large chunks.

- The glove box was broken as was the passenger window switch(fallen into doorcard).

- Needed a new engine mount.

- Sunroof was rusting.

- Clutch thrust bearing was excessively loud (He tried to tell me it was normal, however, after having been around a few 944's I could tell him it was not, far from it).

- Rear window was also bodged in.

So after asking for my deposit back, he started accusing ME of being a time waster, I had been there for 10 minutes after a hell of a drive and this was what I found in 10 minutes, god knows what it would be like if I dug deeper, but I was hardly going to spend a whole day driving just to waste 10 minutes of someones time he then started saying that I should of known what to expect(must of assumed I had a crystal ball) and saying it was worth more than £4500, if I were to sort the rust it would be worth £10k, no, the filler and crash damage has it in shed territory I think you will find. So anyway he refunded my deposit but wouldn't give me back £25 that he spent on day insurance as this was my F***ING fault somehow!!! I agreed to this as I just couldn't be bothered at that point, but thought others should be aware that if they are off to look at this Porsche 944, please be aware of the above and don't spend all your day traveling to find that the car is considerably worse than what is made out.

Oh and I believe the photo's taken of the car are not current as some parts really don't tie in with the condition of the car.

Rant over

Marc



Edited by Marc p on Sunday 28th April 21:15

Nigel Worc's

8,121 posts

219 months

Sunday 28th April 2013
quotequote all
I feel your pain mate, have a look in the BMW section at the fun I had trying to find a decent E39 5 series for my daughters boyfriend.

Even the dealers can be pathetic regarding condition description, let alone what actually works.

Welshbeef

49,633 posts

229 months

Sunday 28th April 2013
quotequote all
What an absolute moron I've had a similar experience though only 50 miles round trip. The Mk3 Golf GTI16v was described in really good condition a mere 50k miles fresh MOT and he said when you see it in the flesh you will want to buy it.

We arrived MOT had run out not passed last week, Ariel was ripped off, rear wiper had been bent and twisted off it had evidently been standing for a long time all discs were totally rusted up, from memory 3 or all 4 wheels were flat and frankly needed to be binned, opened the bonnet I checked the oil (none on the dipstick which I pointed out) then opened up the expansion tank it was bone dry to the point it had dust on the inside.... Again I pointed this out). Inside the car kilometre showed 185k miles not the 50k he and the advert told me, radio missing drivers seat was broken it wouldn't move turned on ignition (he had to jump start) all the lights stayed on. I asked him are you sure your happy for me to try to start this car with no oil and no coolant? Yes he was

Oh forgot rear box exhaust missing rusted off.

I listed off everything which was wrong with it and the cost of each hick added up to possibly twice the asking price so I said if you pay me £x ill take this shed off your hands. He thought I was joking.


carreauchompeur

18,334 posts

235 months

Sunday 28th April 2013
quotequote all
^^^ That Golf is the most hilariously extreme example I think I've heard.

TheLordJohn

5,746 posts

177 months

Sunday 28th April 2013
quotequote all
Welshbeef said:
What an absolute moron I've had a similar experience though only 50 miles round trip. The Mk3 Golf GTI16v was described in really good condition a mere 50k miles fresh MOT and he said when you see it in the flesh you will want to buy it.

We arrived MOT had run out not passed last week, Ariel was ripped off, rear wiper had been bent and twisted off it had evidently been standing for a long time all discs were totally rusted up, from memory 3 or all 4 wheels were flat and frankly needed to be binned, opened the bonnet I checked the oil (none on the dipstick which I pointed out) then opened up the expansion tank it was bone dry to the point it had dust on the inside.... Again I pointed this out). Inside the car kilometre showed 185k miles not the 50k he and the advert told me, radio missing drivers seat was broken it wouldn't move turned on ignition (he had to jump start) all the lights stayed on. I asked him are you sure your happy for me to try to start this car with no oil and no coolant? Yes he was

Oh forgot rear box exhaust missing rusted off.

I listed off everything which was wrong with it and the cost of each hick added up to possibly twice the asking price so I said if you pay me £x ill take this shed off your hands. He thought I was joking.
You should have ran it, and took it on a test drive until it seized.

james_gt3rs

4,816 posts

222 months

Sunday 28th April 2013
quotequote all
My rule of thumb is if the advert is typed in CAPS then the seller is generally a moron...

Welshbeef

49,633 posts

229 months

Sunday 28th April 2013
quotequote all
james_gt3rs said:
My rule of thumb is if the advert is typed in CAPS then the seller is generally a moron...
Thing is as OP says it can seriously waste a huge amount of time and money without reason.

gforceg

3,525 posts

210 months

Sunday 28th April 2013
quotequote all
TheLordJohn said:
Welshbeef said:
What an absolute moron I've had a similar experience though only 50 miles round trip. The Mk3 Golf GTI16v was described in really good condition a mere 50k miles fresh MOT and he said when you see it in the flesh you will want to buy it.

We arrived MOT had run out not passed last week, Ariel was ripped off, rear wiper had been bent and twisted off it had evidently been standing for a long time all discs were totally rusted up, from memory 3 or all 4 wheels were flat and frankly needed to be binned, opened the bonnet I checked the oil (none on the dipstick which I pointed out) then opened up the expansion tank it was bone dry to the point it had dust on the inside.... Again I pointed this out). Inside the car kilometre showed 185k miles not the 50k he and the advert told me, radio missing drivers seat was broken it wouldn't move turned on ignition (he had to jump start) all the lights stayed on. I asked him are you sure your happy for me to try to start this car with no oil and no coolant? Yes he was

Oh forgot rear box exhaust missing rusted off.

I listed off everything which was wrong with it and the cost of each hick added up to possibly twice the asking price so I said if you pay me £x ill take this shed off your hands. He thought I was joking.
You should have ran it, and took it on a test drive until it seized.
Did you ask him if it was actually the same car he'd advertised as a few small points didn't seem to match?

I went to look at an old Golf a few years ago. It was obvious it was a non-runner despite the wording in the ad. The guy hadn't arrived when I looked at it outside his dad's place and I was long gone by the time he arrived. He rang me and seemed pretty peeved I hadn't hung about waiting for him. It was as if he thought he could have persuaded me to buy it if only I'd waited!




Edited by gforceg on Sunday 28th April 17:11

paulcdb

83 posts

278 months

Sunday 28th April 2013
quotequote all
james_gt3rs said:
My rule of thumb is if the advert is typed in CAPS then the seller is generally a moron...
and typed in font size 72... and usually red! rolleyes

g3org3y

22,529 posts

222 months

Sunday 28th April 2013
quotequote all
TIMEWASTERS!!! Rage!

It's as though once you get there, you'll not notice all the issues and buy the car anyway out of obligation!

I remember seeing an E36 328i coupe in south Lonon a number of years back. Was described as "mint".

Issues:
1) Original boot spoiler had been removed and a new one fitted. Screw holes from original spoiler still on view and allowed you to see in the boot!
2) No paperwork. At all.
3) Bonnet would only half way up. (All the coupes are like that rolleyes).
4) Front of the engine had been patched up with goodness knows what
5) No stereo, just bare wires
6) I don't think there was a single panel on that car that wasn't scratched or dented.
7) Ran like ste

Apart from that, mint.

catman

2,504 posts

206 months

Sunday 28th April 2013
quotequote all
I think that in their mind, if you travel a long way, you're less likely to walk away from the car.

I had this when my Son was looking for a Celica 190. Described as "mint," every panel had scratches, the headlamps needed replacing, as did all of the discs and pads.

Also, all of the alloys were heavily kerbed. The seller completely mis-read my displeasure and thought that I had pointed the faults out as a bargaining ploy.

He then had the gall to say that if we were looking for a perfect car, that we should buy new!

Tim

Deva Link

26,934 posts

276 months

Sunday 28th April 2013
quotequote all
catman said:
I think that in their mind, if you travel a long way, you're less likely to walk away from the car.
On one of the Mercedes forums at the moment there's someone who got the train 2.5hrs to view an E Class. The engine management light was on so the car was in limp mode and the COMAND (integrated nav, radio etc) system had a blank screen. And it had a broken spring.

He still bought it and drove it home. Car is still broken.

curlie467

7,650 posts

232 months

Sunday 28th April 2013
quotequote all
Exactly why I won`t travel far any more, too much utter garbage out there sadly.

23rdian

387 posts

194 months

Sunday 28th April 2013
quotequote all
I can understand your annoyance but did you really expect the day insurance back?

rallycross

13,763 posts

268 months

Sunday 28th April 2013
quotequote all
Where are you located I have a very tidy late model 944 s2 3.0 available.

Dominic H

3,289 posts

263 months

Sunday 28th April 2013
quotequote all
rallycross said:
Where are you located I have a very tidy late model 944 s2 3.0 available.
350 miles from Inverness-Shire at a rough guess... whistle

wolves_wanderer

12,959 posts

268 months

Sunday 28th April 2013
quotequote all
23rdian said:
I can understand your annoyance but did you really expect the day insurance back?
It was the vendors day insurance that was chipped from his deposit, not his own.

Marc p

Original Poster:

1,124 posts

173 months

Sunday 28th April 2013
quotequote all
23rdian said:
I can understand your annoyance but did you really expect the day insurance back?
Well, yes, I didn't tell him to take out day insurance as I had already taken out the insurance on my own policy, he was probably lying about it anyway, it appeared to be in his nature.

rallycross

13,763 posts

268 months

Sunday 28th April 2013
quotequote all
Dominic H said:
rallycross said:
Where are you located I have a very tidy late model 944 s2 3.0 available.
350 miles from Inverness-Shire at a rough guess... whistle
Ah yes I just read the ad, that looks very nice in the photos no wonder you were not happy when you arrived at the north end of the country to find it was not as described.

Marc p

Original Poster:

1,124 posts

173 months

Sunday 28th April 2013
quotequote all
Dominic H said:
rallycross said:
Where are you located I have a very tidy late model 944 s2 3.0 available.
350 miles from Inverness-Shire at a rough guess... whistle
Good guess biggrin

I am located about 10 miles outside of Harrogate (in the middle of nowhere). I am actually going to see another 944 tomorrow, but if I don't have it I will give you a shout, thanks.