Tiered Licencing
Author
Discussion

Eski1991

Original Poster:

1,113 posts

164 months

Sunday 28th April 2013
quotequote all
After reading a few (numerous) articles lately about crashes/very near misses involving young and usually inexperienced drivers and being subject to an awful program on BBC3 called "Barely Legal Drivers" I have started to think that a driving test more akin to the tiered entry motorbike testing system is a logical solution.

Following the update to 2 wheel testing a 17 year old can at most receive an A1 granting use of a bike of no more than 33bhp. A 17 year old with a full B licence can drive ANYTHING up to 3.5 tonne and 8 seats. No power output limit, no bhp per tonne. Worrying more is that a 17 year old with only a provisional licence can drive a high powered car as long as they display "L" plates and have an appropriately aged and experienced companion in the passenger seat, regardless of the fact many of those doing the supervising are not wearing glasses, using their phone or having a nap - http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-10834271

A study regarding spare tyres (according to The Telegraph, I can't find actual findings) carried out by Continental found that many people lacked the knowledge required to change a flat tyre. Why is this not basic knowledge for all road users and something that is included as a part of the driving test?

Discuss.

Nigel Worc's

8,121 posts

219 months

Sunday 28th April 2013
quotequote all
Why do you think things are any worse now than they've ever been ?

Do you like complicated regulation ?

IF, and it is a big IF, we want to do anything, why not just raise the min age ?

Is it really as big an issue as people like to say ?

When was the last time you were involved in an accident caused by a young inexperienced person ?

If you just want to save lives, you'll save more by volunteering to clean your local hospital.

As the father of a 17 year old lad (and two older girls), I can assure you the biggest issue with young drivers these days is getting them insured, it is so bad I can understand why so many drive without insurance, and this isn't a good start to their driving lives.

I've worked (volunteered) with the IAM , (a few years back, I don't do it anymore), and as a result I've met, chatted with, the McDonalds car park youngsters, to name but one group, done events with them, taught some of them the full course, etc etc, it really isn't as bad as it is made out to be, and on the whole, most young people are completely "lovely", as their parents have brought them up to be.

Benbay001

5,895 posts

188 months

Sunday 28th April 2013
quotequote all
Funny that, OP.
Since i was 16 (im now 20) ive had a moped, a 1.8 liter Focus, a 650cc motorbike and now a 400bhp saloon.
I suspect, in your eyes id be as good as dead, having crashed multiple times?
Wrong. Most of those i know who are my age who have crashed/ written off cars are those that are absolutely petrified of going fast.

Edited to add: sorry if i came across a bit touchy, but i feel power has nothing to do with safety on the road, instead its got everything to do with inappropriate speed. And even a lowly 1.2 Clio can achieve inappropriate speeds on 99% of Britains roads.

Nigel Worc's

8,121 posts

219 months

Sunday 28th April 2013
quotequote all
I forgot to add, why do you want basic mechanical skills taught at test level ?

Have you seen the crap they have to learn these days, so much of it sod all to do with learning to control the vehicle, which is all they should be learning at that stage ?

Do motorcyclists have to learn basic mechanical skills, (it has been a long time since I took my test, but I don't think they do) ?

Eski1991

Original Poster:

1,113 posts

164 months

Sunday 28th April 2013
quotequote all
Didn't realise that regarding the decline in nee drivers. So where is the solution? Compulsory advanced training such as pass plus and more? I know from experience that telematics based insurance policies don't change much. Maybe limit passengers? I no longer permit drunk passengers as they are such a nightmare.

Nigel Worc's

8,121 posts

219 months

Sunday 28th April 2013
quotequote all
Benbay001 said:
Funny that, OP.
sorry if i came across a bit touchy, but i feel power has nothing to do with safety on the road, instead its got everything to do with inappropriate speed. And even a lowly 1.2 Clio can achieve inappropriate speeds on 99% of Britains roads.
Make that 100% of British roads, apart from strange hybrid stuff, I've not come across anything mass produced for years that can't do 70 mph.

It is sort of true though, that a modern shopping car is faster than many saloon models from my younger days, but they also stop better, much much better, and have safety features that we only dreamt of, we didn't even wear seatbelts.

I just don't believe it is any worse now than when I learnt, and I'm unable to justify asking the youth of today to jump through hoops that weren't in place for my generation.

Eski1991

Original Poster:

1,113 posts

164 months

Sunday 28th April 2013
quotequote all
Just like to add in that I'm 21 and drive a Saxo VTR so I'm on the side of the young drivers. Just thought it could be an interesting discussion. Basic mechanics should be demonstrated on test as they could well be needed at any given time. Hell on my first test which I failed I panicked and couldn't work the screen wash on the showmetellme segment

Eski1991

Original Poster:

1,113 posts

164 months

Sunday 28th April 2013
quotequote all
Nigel Worc's said:
I forgot to add, why do you want basic mechanical skills taught at test level ?

Have you seen the crap they have to learn these days, so much of it sod all to do with learning to control the vehicle, which is all they should be learning at that stage ?

Do motorcyclists have to learn basic mechanical skills, (it has been a long time since I took my test, but I don't think they do) ?
Took my DAS Bike test last year and yes mechanical knowledge - chain tension and lubrication oil checks tyre condition and others are expected.

scarble

5,277 posts

188 months

Sunday 28th April 2013
quotequote all
Eski1991 said:
After reading a few (numerous) articles lately about crashes/very near misses involving young and usually inexperienced drivers and being subject to an awful program on BBC3 called "Barely Legal Drivers"
But the majority of crashes involving young drivers involve s**tty little 1 litre hatches anyway.
Watching BLD (porn influenced title much?) the worst near misses involve same 1 litre hatches and would have happened regardless of the vehicle being driven. An inexperienced driver will panic and stop at the end of a slip road regardless of the car they're in.

It's not about power it's about confidence, competence and concentration.

Not sure where you read articles on very near misses, although there does seem to be a growing anti-young-driver agenda in the media, it's almost enough to make one believe that there is some conspiracy to build public support for the recently suggested restriction to silly little quadricycles that would hold up traffic and bring our already chocka roads grinding to a halt. One could almost believe that someone might stand to make a lot of money out of this because young drivers can't afford proper new cars but they'll go out and buy a proper old car over a proper new car unless they're forced by high premiums and even legislation to buy un-proper new cars.

Edited by scarble on Sunday 28th April 23:47

Shaw Tarse

31,904 posts

234 months

Sunday 28th April 2013
quotequote all
Eski1991 said:
the showmetellme segment
confused
I can't remember that when I took my test?

JREwing

17,551 posts

210 months

Sunday 28th April 2013
quotequote all
Reckless drivers will drive any car too recklessly. Many of us passed our driving tests at the earliest time possible and have gone on to have no accidents.

Others have been unlucky. Others have admittedly caused accidents, however to the best of my knowledge (no citations as I have no data at hand) they are in the minority of drivers. I don't believe that the situation now is any worse than it ever has been. Accidents have always occurred.

Maybe you should focus your despair on cases other than driving. I feel that the prevention of another Piper Alpha disaster or another Bhopal Disaster would be a better use of time and energy. Neither were meant to occur and as such each were terrible accidents.

Eski1991

Original Poster:

1,113 posts

164 months

Sunday 28th April 2013
quotequote all
Shaw Tarse said:
confused
I can't remember that when I took my test?
After the reading plates and before you drive. Ask you how to check fluids or other silly questions. I tried every lever in the dash to no avail and felt a right tit when my instructor demonstrated.

alangla

6,853 posts

212 months

Sunday 28th April 2013
quotequote all
Eski1991 said:
Took my DAS Bike test last year and yes mechanical knowledge - chain tension and lubrication oil checks tyre condition and others are expected.
Yep, also a guaranteed question on carrying a passenger, often involving having to point out & explain how to adjust the rear suspension. In the 2 attempts (ahem) it took me to pass mod 2, I got questions on checking & refilling engine oil, front & rear brake fluid (twice), demoing the kill switch and had to explain how I'd brief a passenger on sitting on the bike correctly and the adjustments I'd have to make to suspension, tyre pressures & headlamp alignment to carry a passenger. All of these were machine specific.
I expect the car test is pretty much the same - any time I was near the test centre, there was always a learner pointing things out to the examiner under the bonnet of their driving school car.

McSam

6,753 posts

206 months

Sunday 28th April 2013
quotequote all
Gaz. said:
Kids have been killing themselves (and others) with low powered superminis for decades. It isn't the potency of the vehicle that is the problem but the inexperience of the newly qualified driver.
Well, quite. I've driven cars with over 600bhp, ones with slicks and wings, ones with over 500bhp/ton, and also a heavy old 4WD saloon with 136bhp.

I think you can guess which one I crashed.

I drove an Atom 300 for some hard laps without binning it at the age of 16, but give me my own Mondeo on the road and it only took three weeks for me to screw up.

How big or small, powerful or gutless, well-cared-for or hopelessly neglected the car is has absolutely nothing to do with it.

Nigel Worc's

8,121 posts

219 months

Sunday 28th April 2013
quotequote all
Eski1991 said:
Took my DAS Bike test last year and yes mechanical knowledge - chain tension and lubrication oil checks tyre condition and others are expected.
The car equivalent of that is already in place, not that my daughters do it anyway, that is what daddy and boyfriends are for !

And to the chap who says mechanical skills could be needed anytime, why ?

I assume you're talking about changing a tyre or something similar, I could, if I really really had to, strip my engine and rebuild it, but I'm old and have lots of experience, I couldn't do it when I gained a licence.

A lot of cars don't even have spare wheels anymore, times change, things move on, in the 70's and 80's you'd see people maintaining their cars on the drive every weekend, it doesn't happen anymore.

A lot of modern cars just tell you when you need screenwash, oil, coolant,brakepads, even air in the tyres.

I learnt the other week that some modern cars don't even have dipsticks for checking the oil anymore.

Eski1991

Original Poster:

1,113 posts

164 months

Sunday 28th April 2013
quotequote all
Ok so my original argument has now been shot down in flames. Is there really a solution or are young drivers receiving high insurance quotes for a reason? JREwing I don't have an answer for avoiding industrial incidents from the mid to late 80s. Sorry.

Spanna

3,737 posts

207 months

Monday 29th April 2013
quotequote all
Shaw Tarse said:
Eski1991 said:
the showmetellme segment
confused
I can't remember that when I took my test?
Just before going out for Module 2 on road test the examiner asks a couple of questions. Mine were about chain maintenance, checking oil level and about carrying a pillion. I did this last year.

Also, 17-19 are restricted to 125s on the the new rules, no more 33bhp licence. A2 is available at 19 for 46.6bhp and 2 years after passing this you can become unrestricted with retesting.

I don't think a tiered licence for cars would make any difference whatsoever to the way young people drive. Most of us young'uns only have access to little hatchbacks anyway. The ones that put more money into it and care about cars and driving are generally better because it's a hobby, something we take pride in.

Nigel Worc's

8,121 posts

219 months

Monday 29th April 2013
quotequote all
alangla said:
Eski1991 said:
Took my DAS Bike test last year and yes mechanical knowledge - chain tension and lubrication oil checks tyre condition and others are expected.
Yep, also a guaranteed question on carrying a passenger, often involving having to point out & explain how to adjust the rear suspension. In the 2 attempts (ahem) it took me to pass mod 2, I got questions on checking & refilling engine oil, front & rear brake fluid (twice), demoing the kill switch and had to explain how I'd brief a passenger on sitting on the bike correctly and the adjustments I'd have to make to suspension, tyre pressures & headlamp alignment to carry a passenger. All of these were machine specific.
I expect the car test is pretty much the same - any time I was near the test centre, there was always a learner pointing things out to the examiner under the bonnet of their driving school car.
Well as you've done it and passed, and I didn't, I just rode my 250 around the block etc, do you think it makes you a safer rider, and if so how ?

I feel it is just pointless hoops for you to jump through in an attempt to satisfy 21st century health and safety thinking.

Benbay001

5,895 posts

188 months

Monday 29th April 2013
quotequote all
Eski1991 said:
Ok so my original argument has now been shot down in flames. Is there really a solution or are young drivers receiving high insurance quotes for a reason?
Young drivers are recieving high premiums because they dont have the experience and natural instinct to deal with situations as they happen. Be that having to overtake a tractor along a windy B road, or to drive on snow and ice.

No ammount of legislation will be able to get around the fact that every driver will have only been driving for a week at some point in their career.

scarble

5,277 posts

188 months

Monday 29th April 2013
quotequote all
Benbay001 said:
Eski1991 said:
Ok so my original argument has now been shot down in flames. Is there really a solution or are young drivers receiving high insurance quotes for a reason?
Young drivers are recieving high premiums because they dont have the experience and natural instinct to deal with situations as they happen. Be that having to overtake a tractor along a windy B road, or to drive on snow and ice.
Yes, it has nothing to do with the fact they artificially inflate the cost of an accident by paying over the odds for car hire so some director can get a little kickback from his brother in law who owns the hire firm.
Or that they just can charge that much and there's nothing you can do about it?

It's not like the very powerful insurance industry with friends in high places hasn't been under ineffectual investigation for some time now.

Oh no wait, that is exactly what is happening.
Here's the first one from google:
http://www.guardian.co.uk/money/2012/sep/28/car-in...

I especially like the bit where some guy from some industry lobbying organisation claims that investigating the industry will actually push up premiums laugh