Secondhand car purchase priorities
Poll: Secondhand car purchase priorities
Total Members Polled: 85
Discussion
When buying a secondhand car for daily driver duties, what is usually your biggest priority from the list above?
For the avoidance of doubt, I'm not asking about purchasing brand new cars, or specialist cars/weekend cars etc.
If two criteria are closely tied, what was the second place?
Ta
For the avoidance of doubt, I'm not asking about purchasing brand new cars, or specialist cars/weekend cars etc.
If two criteria are closely tied, what was the second place?
Ta

moebiusuk said:
It's a mixture of stuff isn't it? But essentially, we're buying a used car because it's cheaper.
kambites said:
Impossible question to answer really, because some of the above are absolutely vital to a certain point and hence of equal importance.
You're both right, of course we use multiple decisions to buy a car, and I acknowledge your comments entirely.But, just for me
, try and put your finger on the deal breaker.I guess price and body style are the two most likely to be deal breakers, although there's no way I'd buy a car that did 1mpg either.
It also depends on who I'm buying for. When buying for me, I test drive a huge selection of models and decide on exactly what I want, before saving up enough money and then hunting down the actual car - last time I bought a car control feel was the absolute top priority followed by handling. For the wife, we tend to just drive a few of the right body-style and price bracket and buy the one that she likes best as long as it's economical enough to justify (and not silver, grey or diesel
).
We ended up with an Elise and an Octavia VRS, which I think is about the best we could achieve with the criteria we had.
It also depends on who I'm buying for. When buying for me, I test drive a huge selection of models and decide on exactly what I want, before saving up enough money and then hunting down the actual car - last time I bought a car control feel was the absolute top priority followed by handling. For the wife, we tend to just drive a few of the right body-style and price bracket and buy the one that she likes best as long as it's economical enough to justify (and not silver, grey or diesel
). We ended up with an Elise and an Octavia VRS, which I think is about the best we could achieve with the criteria we had.
Edited by kambites on Tuesday 30th April 09:31
Strange question really, unless you're a serial and frequent used car buyer. I have criteria at the time, but the next time those criteria may be different. I try to avoid changing cars often as it's a load of hassle and I'm generally pretty happy with my choices anyway, so why change?
Price and body are things that I'll set. I might limit manufacturers depending on those criteria.
But once those things are set condition and then service history would be deal breakers. i.e. If the car was mint with no SH I might but it anyway, if the car was tatty with a good SH I might buy it, but if both were negative I'd walk.
But once those things are set condition and then service history would be deal breakers. i.e. If the car was mint with no SH I might but it anyway, if the car was tatty with a good SH I might buy it, but if both were negative I'd walk.
chrisw666 said:
Price and body are things that I'll set. I might limit manufacturers depending on those criteria.
But once those things are set condition and then service history would be deal breakers. i.e. If the car was mint with no SH I might but it anyway, if the car was tatty with a good SH I might buy it, but if both were negative I'd walk.
Which did you vote for of body and price?But once those things are set condition and then service history would be deal breakers. i.e. If the car was mint with no SH I might but it anyway, if the car was tatty with a good SH I might buy it, but if both were negative I'd walk.
It's easy to point out the ones that don't matter at all.
Competing with colleagues/neighbours - I can't so I don't
Colour - Unless it's horrible colour just isn't an issue
Resale value - I expect a car to be worth nothing when I sell it on.
Everything else is an important consideration and I couldn't narrow it down to one.
For example, I always have a price limit to this is a big priority, however I also wouldn't buy a coupe/convertible at the moment as I have kids. I would also never buy a car with no service history and that wasn't in good condition. These priorities all carry equal weight.
I'm not too worried about milage though as long as it's not intergalactic and the car has been looked after.
Competing with colleagues/neighbours - I can't so I don't
Colour - Unless it's horrible colour just isn't an issue
Resale value - I expect a car to be worth nothing when I sell it on.
Everything else is an important consideration and I couldn't narrow it down to one.
For example, I always have a price limit to this is a big priority, however I also wouldn't buy a coupe/convertible at the moment as I have kids. I would also never buy a car with no service history and that wasn't in good condition. These priorities all carry equal weight.
I'm not too worried about milage though as long as it's not intergalactic and the car has been looked after.
Strange questions.
Whether I was buying new or used, the first thing would be body shape - the case has to be fit for purpose, so if I was buying a new estate car, it's vanishingly unlikely that I'd buy a convertible just because it was secondhand. Unless it was a 458 for £50, I suppose.
I bought a GL420 the other week, In order of priority, the buying priorities went like this:
Cast iron service history and great condition (without this I’d go no further)
7 seater needed (family plus in-laws)
Lots of space (dogs and lugging stuff about)
Respectable pace (4.0 twin turbo V8 – tick!)
Nice to do big distances in (quiet, refined, decent kit)
Build quality and reliability (after a Disco 3 where nothing broke but everything wore out, this was understandably important)
The others were neutral – colour doesn’t bother me within reason, mileage would be reflected in price, fuel consumption isn’t an issue so long as it can average 25ish
Cost? Always important once you’ve chosen the car you’re after, but I’ve never started with a set budget and then worked backwards to find what I can for that price.
Whether I was buying new or used, the first thing would be body shape - the case has to be fit for purpose, so if I was buying a new estate car, it's vanishingly unlikely that I'd buy a convertible just because it was secondhand. Unless it was a 458 for £50, I suppose.
I bought a GL420 the other week, In order of priority, the buying priorities went like this:
Cast iron service history and great condition (without this I’d go no further)
7 seater needed (family plus in-laws)
Lots of space (dogs and lugging stuff about)
Respectable pace (4.0 twin turbo V8 – tick!)
Nice to do big distances in (quiet, refined, decent kit)
Build quality and reliability (after a Disco 3 where nothing broke but everything wore out, this was understandably important)
The others were neutral – colour doesn’t bother me within reason, mileage would be reflected in price, fuel consumption isn’t an issue so long as it can average 25ish
Cost? Always important once you’ve chosen the car you’re after, but I’ve never started with a set budget and then worked backwards to find what I can for that price.
chrisw666 said:
V8mate said:
Which did you vote for of body and price?
I didn't, I voted for condition. The other two wouldn't influence a decision between car A or car B, they'd be things I'd set before even going out to look if I was serious about buying a car. Gassing Station | General Gassing | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


