A super-barge-snotter what car
A super-barge-snotter what car
Author
Discussion

benjj

Original Poster:

6,787 posts

194 months

Tuesday 30th April 2013
quotequote all
I'm struggling to decide between:

Audi S8
Jag XJR
BMW E39 540i Sport

Budget of 3-4k, not expecting a minter but wants to be immediately pressed into daily duties of short commute and hooning.

Am I missing any other obvious options in this sector? Only essentials would be in budget, 4 seats, petrol, more than 4 cyl, fast as hell.

PHmember

2,487 posts

202 months

Tuesday 30th April 2013
quotequote all
BMW E38 750il. Problem solved.

chris182

4,240 posts

184 months

Tuesday 30th April 2013
quotequote all
That list is missing a Mercedes of some kind, S600 springs to mind. Alternatively there'll be a nice 560SEC going up for sale whenever I get round to writing the advert..... wink

Of the options already presented I would pick the XJR 4.0 supercharged.

benjj

Original Poster:

6,787 posts

194 months

Tuesday 30th April 2013
quotequote all
I quite like the E38, good point. Would go for an 'i' over an 'il' though as, like most dudes, I don't need the extra inches wink

hedges88

690 posts

176 months

Tuesday 30th April 2013
quotequote all
benjj said:
I'm struggling to decide between:

Audi S8
Jag XJR
BMW E39 540i Sport

Budget of 3-4k, not expecting a minter but wants to be immediately pressed into daily duties of short commute and hooning.

Am I missing any other obvious options in this sector? Only essentials would be in budget, 4 seats, petrol, more than 4 cyl, fast as hell.
Problem with The E39 540 is that the V8 models 535 and 540 then switch to a steel sub frame and recirculating ball steering. I was hopping between my own 520i Touring Sport and a 540i Touring SE every day and the 6 cylinder E39 seems infinitely more dynamic in terms of steering/braking/overall handling than the V8 models

benjj

Original Poster:

6,787 posts

194 months

Tuesday 30th April 2013
quotequote all
chris182 said:
That list is missing a Mercedes of some kind, S600 springs to mind. Alternatively there'll be a nice 560SEC going up for sale whenever I get round to writing the advert..... wink

Of the options already presented I would pick the XJR 4.0 supercharged.
Agreed re missing Merc. The S Class does nothing for me though and as much as I'd like to smoke around in an SEC I think something slightly more modern will fit the bill.

The XJR is currently favourite. Black. Black leather. Nasty.

Edited by benjj on Tuesday 30th April 19:07

Slow

6,973 posts

168 months

Tuesday 30th April 2013
quotequote all
benjj said:
I quite like the E38, good point. Would go for an 'i' over an 'il' though as, like most dudes, I don't need the extra inches wink
The longer one is cooler tongue out

Better for when you have ladies in the backseat too i guess.

PHmember

2,487 posts

202 months

Tuesday 30th April 2013
quotequote all
Il comes with ALL the toys though. Stunning car.

benjj

Original Poster:

6,787 posts

194 months

Tuesday 30th April 2013
quotequote all
hedges88 said:
Problem with The E39 540 is that the V8 models 535 and 540 then switch to a steel sub frame and recirculating ball steering. I was hopping between my own 520i Touring Sport and a 540i Touring SE every day and the 6 cylinder E39 seems infinitely more dynamic in terms of steering/braking/overall handling than the V8 models
Oh yes, I remember reading about that. I've had 3 E39s over the years but never a boggo V8 (had 528, 530 and M5).

gradeA

651 posts

232 months

Tuesday 30th April 2013
quotequote all
This, then have a bit left over to make it perfect smile


benjj

Original Poster:

6,787 posts

194 months

Tuesday 30th April 2013
quotequote all
Right, thanks, let's go XJR shopping then smile

If anyone knows of a good car under 4k in black with black leather give me a shout. I don't muck about when buying cars, hopefully will have this sorted before the weekend.

benjj

Original Poster:

6,787 posts

194 months

Tuesday 30th April 2013
quotequote all
gradeA said:
This, then have a bit left over to make it perfect smile

Quite like the E34 but don't think it can hold a candle to the big cat.

Anyway, decision reached!

PHmember

2,487 posts

202 months

Tuesday 30th April 2013
quotequote all

MX7

7,902 posts

205 months

Tuesday 30th April 2013
quotequote all
PHmember said:
That's a very optimistic price, isn't it?

benjj

Original Poster:

6,787 posts

194 months

Tuesday 30th April 2013
quotequote all
MX7 said:
That's a very optimistic price, isn't it?
Looks about 12k over priced to me.

PHmember

2,487 posts

202 months

Tuesday 30th April 2013
quotequote all
MX7 said:
That's a very optimistic price, isn't it?
I'd say so, the car is very rare, & stunning - but can't see it going for that price.

scrubchub

1,844 posts

171 months

Tuesday 30th April 2013
quotequote all
Early CL500's are in that price bracket now, and fits the criteria you set out. Sexier and more exclusive than an S Class as those don't float your boat.

I brought mine for £4200 18 months ago. It has been fantastic in that time, except for the irritating and well documented plastic lever in the gear box snapping. Found out it was a cat c a few months ago unfortunately so will lose money when I come to sell. Never thought I'd sell to We Buy Any Car but I don't think I can be arsed to try to sell it as a cat c.

Edited by scrubchub on Tuesday 30th April 19:44

treetops

1,189 posts

189 months

Tuesday 30th April 2013
quotequote all
benjj said:
I'm struggling to decide between:

Audi S8
Jag XJR
BMW E39 540i Sport

Budget of 3-4k, not expecting a minter but wants to be immediately pressed into daily duties of short commute and hooning.

Am I missing any other obvious options in this sector? Only essentials would be in budget, 4 seats, petrol, more than 4 cyl, fast as hell.
A short commute will kill all those engines....

mad4amanda

2,410 posts

195 months

Tuesday 30th April 2013
quotequote all
e34 540i touring better built than the e39

clarkey540i

2,220 posts

205 months

Tuesday 30th April 2013
quotequote all
hedges88 said:
benjj said:
I'm struggling to decide between:

Audi S8
Jag XJR
BMW E39 540i Sport

Budget of 3-4k, not expecting a minter but wants to be immediately pressed into daily duties of short commute and hooning.

Am I missing any other obvious options in this sector? Only essentials would be in budget, 4 seats, petrol, more than 4 cyl, fast as hell.
Problem with The E39 540 is that the V8 models 535 and 540 then switch to a steel sub frame and recirculating ball steering. I was hopping between my own 520i Touring Sport and a 540i Touring SE every day and the 6 cylinder E39 seems infinitely more dynamic in terms of steering/braking/overall handling than the V8 models
I haven't found it much of a problem coming from an E36, itself a very fine handling car. OP, you said you used to have an M5, so it's worth noting that both the M5 and 540i have a steering box, although the M5 has quicker ratios.
I bought mine for 2K in January and I love it.