Audi tt 3.2 vs 350z GT
Author
Discussion

Joel93

Original Poster:

46 posts

164 months

Wednesday 1st May 2013
quotequote all
I've been reading up on these car and have mixed views on them both. I've read in short, the TT is a hairdressers car and is not a proper sports car because there lots on understeer, but it has a really good dsg gearbox and is really well built/ reliable but has mostly a female following on the looks front. The 350z is a midlife crisis car, it is to heavy and has a cheap plastic interior , however sporty gear changes, RWD and its good looks compensate for this. They are both currently priced around the same 6-7k , I have actually drove both but on the test drive I couldn't hit corners hard etc. I've always hated the tt till I seen a 3.2 in a garage I drove it expecting a sluggish auto but was pleasantly surprised, I've always liked the 350z and it was just as expected nothing more, nothing less. Any help?

Triumph Man

9,657 posts

199 months

Wednesday 1st May 2013
quotequote all
Were you born in 1993 as your user name implies? If so, I'm afraid you wouldn't be able to afford to insure either!

TameRacingDriver

20,667 posts

303 months

Wednesday 1st May 2013
quotequote all
I'm perfectly positioned to answer this, I test drove my mates TT V6 DSG before finally getting my 350Z GT (Convertible).

The Audi looked nice, and was a nice place to be, and the gearbox was great. It was dull as dishwater to drive. And I was scared that DSG would give up landing me with a £2500 bill.

Then I had a go of the 350Z. Not even close. Handles really well for the weight (which is does a reasonable job of disguising), sounds much better, feels much faster, and was just more of an event, badge notwithstanding.

Go for the Z.

RemyMartin

6,759 posts

236 months

Wednesday 1st May 2013
quotequote all
I have a 3.2 TT with the DSG so the full Hairdresser spec.

Have to say I love mine, its everything I need it to be. Sounds nice, lovely place to sit. Did I say it sounds nice. Fairly well built. They have their issues and yes the 3.2 isn't the 'handling' model, not that either engine variant is renowned for its handling.

The DSG is fun I drive mine everywhere in 'manual'

I expect everyone to disagree with me on this but hey ho, its what I like and what I wanted and I'm certainly not peturbed by other opinions on me etc

Its not really that sluggish either.

ETA I certainly bought it knowing it wasnt the last word in handling. In day to day driving with the odd bit of spirited driving you certainly won't run off the road due to catastrophic understeer like the internet would have you believe.

TameRacingDriver

20,667 posts

303 months

Wednesday 1st May 2013
quotequote all
RemyMartin said:
ETA I certainly bought it knowing it wasnt the last word in handling. In day to day driving with the odd bit of spirited driving you certainly won't run off the road due to catastrophic understeer like the internet would have you believe.
Indeed... even though it was a tad under-steery it had masses of grip, traction and felt very safe. The 350Z requires more care, but is more rewarding.

duffy78

484 posts

170 months

Wednesday 1st May 2013
quotequote all
what about the 3.2 TT sport? is that in the same price range?

McClure

2,173 posts

177 months

Wednesday 1st May 2013
quotequote all
RemyMartin said:
I have a 3.2 TT with the DSG so the full Hairdresser spec.

Have to say I love mine, its everything I need it to be. Sounds nice, lovely place to sit. Did I say it sounds nice. Fairly well built. They have their issues and yes the 3.2 isn't the 'handling' model, not that either engine variant is renowned for its handling.

The DSG is fun I drive mine everywhere in 'manual'

I expect everyone to disagree with me on this but hey ho, its what I like and what I wanted and I'm certainly not peturbed by other opinions on me etc

Its not really that sluggish either.

ETA I certainly bought it knowing it wasnt the last word in handling. In day to day driving with the odd bit of spirited driving you certainly won't run off the road due to catastrophic understeer like the internet would have you believe.
+1, I love mine.

The TT is just a lovely place to be, and the 3.2 is more of a "baby GT" than a sports car, so it depends what type of car you want.

RemyMartin

6,759 posts

236 months

Wednesday 1st May 2013
quotequote all
TameRacingDriver said:
Indeed... even though it was a tad under-steery it had masses of grip, traction and felt very safe. The 350Z requires more care, but is more rewarding.
Oh absolutely.

In terms of chassis dynamics my old E36 328i Sport had it licked. However it was long in the tooth and I've always liked TTs (shoot me LOL)

Baby/Mini GT sums up the 3.2 TT perfectly.

There is no 3.2 sport certainly not in mk1 Guise.

You have 1.8T (150 FWD, 180 AWD, 225 AWD, 240 Quattro Sport AWD ) and the 3.2 either manual or DSG, obviously and soft tops in all, except the Quattro Sport, which were coupe only and had Recaro Pole Position seats, revised suspension, staggered alloys, stripped out back seats, alcantara lined gear knob and steering wheel with the free option to have the regular seats.


vxr1

446 posts

164 months

Wednesday 1st May 2013
quotequote all
Triumph Man said:
Were you born in 1993 as your user name implies? If so, I'm afraid you wouldn't be able to afford to insure either!
I owned a 3.2 Audi TT as my last car but couldn't get insured on the 350z.
I was born in 1994

Edited by vxr1 on Wednesday 1st May 16:55

vxr1

446 posts

164 months

Wednesday 1st May 2013
quotequote all
I owned a 3.2 Audi TT (56 reg) from last August to March and it was a great sports car IMO.
It didn't feel sluggish, it felt fast and was reliable too. The only reason I sold it was because of the room in the back but for a sportscar it was great.

duffy78

484 posts

170 months

Wednesday 1st May 2013
quotequote all
RemyMartin said:
Quattro Sport, which were coupe only and had Recaro Pole Position seats, revised suspension, staggered alloys, stripped out back seats, alcantara lined gear knob and steering wheel with the free option to have the regular seats.
I stand corrected, dont know why I assumed the sport was a 3.2

RemyMartin

6,759 posts

236 months

Wednesday 1st May 2013
quotequote all
duffy78 said:
I stand corrected, dont know why I assumed the sport was a 3.2
No worries, for ages I used to think the MK2 TTS was a 3.2 v6, rather than just a tuned up 2.0TFSI engine.


jon-

16,534 posts

247 months

Wednesday 1st May 2013
quotequote all
If you want somewhere nice to sit, get the TT.

If you want something fun to drive, get the 350z.

Simple as that really.

Joel93

Original Poster:

46 posts

164 months

Wednesday 1st May 2013
quotequote all
My insurance is £1400 on any of them 2, I currently have a Clio 182 with cup packs that was £1500 last yr. I felt the tt was faster on a normal drive maybe it's the tourqe at low revs, I need to drive them again ,also I have read on other forums the 350z are losing value much faster than the TT , thanks guys

Pablo68

910 posts

166 months

Wednesday 1st May 2013
quotequote all
If you want to pull up at wine bars get the Z. If you want to pull up at gay bars the TT.

Actually the DSG box in the TT is very nice. Smooth creamy gear changes mostly and mostly in the right gears too. The Z is has more soul. All IMHO of course.

I've owned both by the way.

ewan221

1,219 posts

217 months

Wednesday 1st May 2013
quotequote all
350z all day for me smile

elementad

625 posts

181 months

Wednesday 1st May 2013
quotequote all
Joel93 said:
also I have read on other forums the 350z are losing value much faster than the TT , thanks guys
Must be true then...

Go have a look on autotrader for similar age/mileage TT 3.2 vs the 350z GT and make up your own mind. Coupled with the fact that the Audi cost more in the first place. Audi residual not as good. Fact.


You get this ALL the time with German car owners. Time and time again assuming and posting that the Nissan depreciates like a lead balloon. I had the same discussion last week with someone when they said the 350z hasn't held value like the BMW Z4 3.0. Guess what, once again the 350z had better residuals.

Don't let Internet hearsay on depreciation sway your opinion

Garvin

5,669 posts

208 months

Wednesday 1st May 2013
quotequote all
After two Mk1 TTs (225 manual & 3.2 V6 DSG) I was pretty much convinced that my next car was going to be a 350Z . . . . . . . . until I test drove one. There is no doubt it is huge fun and a real 'hairy chested' type of car with oversteer available on demand but it disappointed on a number of levels - cheap interior, not enough rearward seat travel, weak aircon but worst of all was the appalling NVH! The incessant whine from the gearbox and road roar/drone from the rear wheels was going to drive me to distraction on the long trips I needed the car to undertake. The cabin quality and relative silence of my 3 year old TT was a stark contrast to the crudeness of the brand new 350Z I had just driven. I went for a Mk2 3.2 V6 S-Tronic TT and never once regretted it.

elementad

625 posts

181 months

Thursday 2nd May 2013
quotequote all
Garvin said:
After two Mk1 TTs (225 manual & 3.2 V6 DSG) I was pretty much convinced that my next car was going to be a 350Z . . . . . . . . until I test drove one. There is no doubt it is huge fun and a real 'hairy chested' type of car with oversteer available on demand but it disappointed on a number of levels - cheap interior, not enough rearward seat travel, weak aircon but worst of all was the appalling NVH! The incessant whine from the gearbox and road roar/drone from the rear wheels was going to drive me to distraction on the long trips I needed the car to undertake. The cabin quality and relative silence of my 3 year old TT was a stark contrast to the crudeness of the brand new 350Z I had just driven. I went for a Mk2 3.2 V6 S-Tronic TT and never once regretted it.
It depends what you want from the car.

I think Top Gear mags summary of the 370z back in 2009 sums it up perfectly.

"The Audi TT will crush it in sales, but the 370z is the better drivers car".


V6Paul

171 posts

174 months

Thursday 2nd May 2013
quotequote all
Garvin said:
worst of all was the appalling NVH! The incessant whine from the gearbox and road roar/drone from the rear wheels was going to drive me to distraction on the long trips I needed the car to undertake.
The gearbox shouldn't whine really, the gearbox is pretty quiet in mine, other than clunking into gears when changing. Feels very solid though. But agreed the NVH is pretty bad, it doesn't bother me much personally but the longest drive I do in it is about 3 hours, and that's only once every few months.

350z for me, but then I am biased hehe