Sudden surge in MPG?
Discussion
Not that i'm complaining, but could anyone have a go at explaining the following?
Bought a very low mileage E46 320d in November last year. It averages about 35mpg over Christmas. It was running cool so i replaced the EGR stat at the start of the year. MPG went to about 35.2 (obc)
Never bothered changing the main stat. During the period of Jan/Feb/March MPG dropped to 33.8mpg (on the obc). I was getting 500 miles to a tank, and measured this over 3 tanks. 500 miles spot on each time (although with a 63l tank according to Parkers, that would suggest i was actually getting 36mpg).
Anyway, i filled up again the other week, and with half a tank done, im already at 312 miles. This would suggest im going to get approx 620 miles out of the tank, which will be an awesome 44mpg! The obc is reading 39.3 MPG and seems to keep going up.
I've not changed the type of fuel, driving, journey, servicing or anything like that. Im driving a bit like a granny but no more than over winter. When i put even half pressure on the pedal it chucks f
king loads of crap out of the back, maybe this is normal, maybe this is due to being driving like miss daisy all the time? (It doesnt have a DPF).
Any explanations? I thought maybe the weather, going from -4 to the current dizzy heights of 13 degress might contribute, but to give me an extra 120+ miles from a tank, just because it's a bit warmer? That'd suggest that by august i'll be going at 90mpg
Anyone else experianced anything similar?
Bought a very low mileage E46 320d in November last year. It averages about 35mpg over Christmas. It was running cool so i replaced the EGR stat at the start of the year. MPG went to about 35.2 (obc)

Never bothered changing the main stat. During the period of Jan/Feb/March MPG dropped to 33.8mpg (on the obc). I was getting 500 miles to a tank, and measured this over 3 tanks. 500 miles spot on each time (although with a 63l tank according to Parkers, that would suggest i was actually getting 36mpg).
Anyway, i filled up again the other week, and with half a tank done, im already at 312 miles. This would suggest im going to get approx 620 miles out of the tank, which will be an awesome 44mpg! The obc is reading 39.3 MPG and seems to keep going up.
I've not changed the type of fuel, driving, journey, servicing or anything like that. Im driving a bit like a granny but no more than over winter. When i put even half pressure on the pedal it chucks f
king loads of crap out of the back, maybe this is normal, maybe this is due to being driving like miss daisy all the time? (It doesnt have a DPF).Any explanations? I thought maybe the weather, going from -4 to the current dizzy heights of 13 degress might contribute, but to give me an extra 120+ miles from a tank, just because it's a bit warmer? That'd suggest that by august i'll be going at 90mpg

Anyone else experianced anything similar?
Edited by fjord on Thursday 2nd May 18:46
In winter you tend to have the lights and heating (and air-con? this makes quite a difference) on when driving, not to mention longer warm-up cycles, so chances are you are now driving around in daylight with the lights and heating off, there is less electrical energy being used, which results in less fuel use. Also the grades of fuel vary across the seasons (more or less octane to avoid knocking or assist cold starting), it might be a factor.
fjord said:
Whats the difference between winter & (summer?) diesel?
And what would happen if they gave me none-winter diesel in winter?
If it was really cold your engine wouldn't start.And what would happen if they gave me none-winter diesel in winter?
Some light reading for you:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Winter_diesel_fuel
It's pretty normal, my diesel loses circa 4/5mpg in the cold weather - 2.0 CR 170ps unit I get circa 46mpg now (mixed mways/a roads/little traffic jams/WOT on every journey
). Depths of Winter I was getting 42mpg.
Took ages, i.e +10 miles to warm up (water coolent level) in the winter.
). Depths of Winter I was getting 42mpg.Took ages, i.e +10 miles to warm up (water coolent level) in the winter.
fjord said:
collateral said:
It does seem like the only thing which has changed.
Not sure if half throttle should chuck crap out all the time though - OP might want to get that looked at. Is it black or white smoke?
Lovely juicy black smoke.Not sure if half throttle should chuck crap out all the time though - OP might want to get that looked at. Is it black or white smoke?

collateral said:
I asked about the colour because my 306 had a leaking injector which made white smoke for a few seconds the first time you started it up, and did it constantly when the boost comp was set too high 
It chucks a bit of white out of the back when it starts, but after the initial cloud there's nothing else. I guess that isnt a problem.
Gassing Station | General Gassing | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff




