Since when was buying oil so hard?
Since when was buying oil so hard?
Author
Discussion

mnkiboy

Original Poster:

4,409 posts

197 months

Friday 3rd May 2013
quotequote all
Mnkigirl needed to top up the oil in her MINI Cooper, and the manual states it requires 5W30. Popped in to Halfords to pick some up only to find you can't just buy 5W30 any more, there's 5W30 for Fords, 5W30 for BMW's, 5W30 for VAG cars, 5W30 for Mercedes...

Is it not all the same stuff? How different can one 5W30 be from the other, apart from mineral, part and fully synth?

In the end I chose the Ford stuff as it was cheapest. The BMW oil was an extra £5.

FreeLitres

6,128 posts

208 months

Friday 3rd May 2013
quotequote all
Hmmm if I were you I would be trying to figure out who made my MINI.

read

mnkiboy

Original Poster:

4,409 posts

197 months

Friday 3rd May 2013
quotequote all
I'm betting it really doesn't matter, and Halfords are using it as an excuse to stick £5 on the BMW oil.

James_N

3,305 posts

265 months

Friday 3rd May 2013
quotequote all
I just buy all my oil from Wilkinsons or Asda! I do run a banger though!

Liquid Tuna

1,403 posts

187 months

Friday 3rd May 2013
quotequote all
I bet it doesn't make a toss of difference to the "expected" life of the engine (or at least the length of time you'll probably keep it) as long as it's 5w30. If it was a highly strung engine it probably still wouldn't, but just might. So unless you've had it tuned and are pushing the envelope a bit, just put whichever 5w30 in you want to.

As an aside, I used Halfords boggo standard 10w40 in an old Mondeo and got almost 250k miles out of it and at the end the engine was still running sweet, didn't really use any oil between services etc, and I should really have been using 5w30.

Defcon5

6,479 posts

222 months

Friday 3rd May 2013
quotequote all
The Ford stuff will be A1/B1 for the Zetec engines, wrong stuff for the MINI. Look for the specs on the back of the bottle, LL04 or whatever it needs

toxgobbler

2,903 posts

222 months

Friday 3rd May 2013
quotequote all
Buy here: http://www.opieoils.co.uk/ simples.

Bluebarge

4,519 posts

209 months

Friday 3rd May 2013
quotequote all
RTFHandbook - it will set out the specs for the oil you need A3/B3 or A5/B5 etc.

Opie oils are much, much cheaper than Halfords

cspan

13 posts

166 months

Friday 3rd May 2013
quotequote all
And there's me thinking we were about to get into that staple of every car owners forum on the Internet: arguments over which oil to use... biggrin

Captain Muppet

8,540 posts

296 months

Friday 3rd May 2013
quotequote all
Is buying oil hard? The OP went to the oil shop, looked at the oil and bought some oil.

Sounds pretty easy.

Much easier than licking your elbow, to pick a trivial example at random.

Much easier than changing the oil has always been, to pick a relevant example.

DanielJames

7,543 posts

199 months

Friday 3rd May 2013
quotequote all
It's never been so fking easy with Opie Oils sending me daily emails offering extended deals hehe

AndySpecD

436 posts

218 months

Friday 3rd May 2013
quotequote all
Even with the discount offers, I still find ebay, camskill or the like quite often a fair bit cheaper than Opie these days.

bp1000

873 posts

210 months

Friday 3rd May 2013
quotequote all
If you think that's bad jaguar put a dye in the oil for my xfr so in the event of a problem they can tell if you have used "unapproved" oil. Essentially you can only use the correct jaguar branded castrol magnatec. They can't wriggle out of warranty claims afaik because I don't think using a different oil can't void warranty but I'm sure they would try it on. I think the dye helps them trace leaks.

mnkiboy

Original Poster:

4,409 posts

197 months

Friday 3rd May 2013
quotequote all
Bluebarge said:
RTFHandbook - it will set out the specs for the oil you need A3/B3 or A5/B5 etc.

Opie oils are much, much cheaper than Halfords
t what is all this a3 a5 rubbish? Surely a 5W30 oil is a 5W30 oil. Tiny difference. Can't make a significant difference between oils?

Magic919

14,596 posts

232 months

Friday 3rd May 2013
quotequote all
Asking for advice before buying is the better suggestion.

Deva Link

26,934 posts

276 months

Friday 3rd May 2013
quotequote all
bp1000 said:
If you think that's bad jaguar put a dye in the oil for my xfr so in the event of a problem they can tell if you have used "unapproved" oil. Essentially you can only use the correct jaguar branded castrol magnatec. They can't wriggle out of warranty claims afaik because I don't think using a different oil can't void warranty but I'm sure they would try it on. I think the dye helps them trace leaks.
VW approved oil has a chemical marker in it which varies according to which VW spec oil it is.

I think on the PD engines it's quite important to use the right stuff.

Apart from that, the rest of it is largely bks. I have a Merc and people on the MB forums agonise over oil - yet if you look in the handbook it says you can use just about anything. It became apparent a few years ago that MB dealers weren't using Low Ash oil in the DPF equipped cars.

Steff

1,421 posts

294 months

Friday 3rd May 2013
quotequote all
toxgobbler said:
Buy here: http://www.opieoils.co.uk/ simples.
Exactly.

xreyuk

665 posts

176 months

Friday 3rd May 2013
quotequote all
Deva Link said:
VW approved oil has a chemical marker in it which varies according to which VW spec oil it is.

I think on the PD engines it's quite important to use the right stuff.

Apart from that, the rest of it is largely bks. I have a Merc and people on the MB forums agonise over oil - yet if you look in the handbook it says you can use just about anything. It became apparent a few years ago that MB dealers weren't using Low Ash oil in the DPF equipped cars.
It's important on any VAG car with a DPF as you need a low ash content oil (VW 507.00 spec) apparently (apparently being the key word based on your MB experience!)

To the OP, the manufacturers have a specific specs to meet, and they all have their own specs, for their own engines. No idea how much it would matter though, but to keep warranty intact you need to use the right spec oil

Mr2Mike

20,143 posts

286 months

Friday 3rd May 2013
quotequote all
So OP goes into Halfords, finds the correct specification oil for his MINI, then buys some oil specified for Fords?

Clearly he has a good point; buying oil is terribly difficult for some people.

spaximus

4,365 posts

284 months

Friday 3rd May 2013
quotequote all
It is all about the specific addatives that each engine needs. So there is a specific one for each manufacturer who has something special.

So long as you look in the handbook, or go onto the Castrol or Comma website and type in your reg it will tell you what you need.

As for voiding a warranty, a manufacturer would need to prove the oil was responsible directly for the failure. Under block exemption rules so long as you use the oil spec recommended from which ever supplier they cannot refuse the warrantys.