Considering the move to the dark side...
Considering the move to the dark side...
Author
Discussion

ruta87

Original Poster:

261 posts

219 months

Tuesday 7th May 2013
quotequote all
Currently own a TVR Tuscan 4.0... its my only car, however i am starting to use it more for work which is not the ideal situation to be in (its my only car...)

Budget is an absolute max of 30k. Open to all options or 911 (coupe or convertable) or a Cayman S

Considerations thus Far:

996 Turbo
Carrera S or 4S 996 and 997
Cayman S

My Question to you all is what kind of running costs can i expect to have on something like the 996 turbo to a carrera? The Tvr is currently around 1200 per year and is quite light on the tires which are around 200 a corner. Servicing is every year or 6k which ever comes first.

i understand porsche are every 20k or 2years?! is this correct? Any advise will be welcome!

Thanks,
Christian

davek_964

11,300 posts

205 months

Tuesday 7th May 2013
quotequote all
Later cars are very 2 years / 20k miles but 996 turbo is annual.

My annual running costs over 3.5 years have probably been roughly double your annual TVR costs (I've done about 34k in 3.5 years).

I don't think turbo costs are much more than NA 911s.

LightningMat

206 posts

229 months

Tuesday 7th May 2013
quotequote all
General servicing costs on Porsche tend to be very reasonable - basic servicing is fixed-price at OPC's, so no real surprises. Turbo servicing cost is higher than NA.

Cars tend to be pretty reliable, but when things do go wrong, you can expect to pay a fair amount for parts and associated labour. There are a few reliable independent garages out there, if you want to save on OPC costs too. Rear tyres do wear out relatively quickly, and can cost around £200 each (can get cheaper, but that would be for the cheaper brands).

LightningMat

206 posts

229 months

Tuesday 7th May 2013
quotequote all
Depending on how you drive, you can see 30+ mpg in a C2 or C4, probably closer to 25-30 mpg in a Turbo.

dank

1,160 posts

282 months

Tuesday 7th May 2013
quotequote all
Get yourself into a very nice 996 Turbo, maybe X50 for that budget,


IMI A

9,997 posts

231 months

Tuesday 7th May 2013
quotequote all
dank said:
Get yourself into a very nice 996 Turbo, maybe X50 for that budget,
+1 no brainer if you enjoy power

Crimp a Length!

5,697 posts

253 months

Tuesday 7th May 2013
quotequote all
996 turbo
I'm on my second..........

type-r

19,482 posts

243 months

Tuesday 7th May 2013
quotequote all
LightningMat said:
Depending on how you drive, you can see 30+ mpg in a C2 or C4, probably closer to 25-30 mpg in a Turbo.
I drive a mixture of city traffic / A roads driving, maybe a 50/50 split, weekend use only, in a 997 C2S.

I am averaging 19.4 mpg and unless your commute is almost all on a clear motorway and you drive like a saint, I just cannot see how 30mpg+ can realistically be obtained.

Beety

211 posts

230 months

Tuesday 7th May 2013
quotequote all
Don't do it your miss the TVR !
Send us your spec maybe we can swap lol

adam5

11 posts

215 months

Tuesday 7th May 2013
quotequote all
type-r said:
LightningMat said:
Depending on how you drive, you can see 30+ mpg in a C2 or C4, probably closer to 25-30 mpg in a Turbo.
I drive a mixture of city traffic / A roads driving, maybe a 50/50 split, weekend use only, in a 997 C2S.

I am averaging 19.4 mpg and unless your commute is almost all on a clear motorway and you drive like a saint, I just cannot see how 30mpg+ can realistically be obtained.
I concur with the above and I'm in a Boxster S where the combination of A roads and town results in about 21 mpg.

FarQue

2,339 posts

228 months

Tuesday 7th May 2013
quotequote all
Low 20s fuel consumption generally in our 997 Carrera S, less in our old 986S. You'd need to be saintly to achieve much more in the real world I reckon.

johnycarrera

1,935 posts

260 months

Tuesday 7th May 2013
quotequote all
I'd buy the newest 997 C2 I could, C2S if decent spec.
Don't think you'd average more than 20 mpg in any Porsche.
They can cost a fortune if they break but you can have the affordable dealer warranty up to 10 years old smile

mollytherocker

14,465 posts

239 months

Tuesday 7th May 2013
quotequote all
This is a question that comes up almost weekly now!

Maybe we need a sticky or something?

steve singh

3,995 posts

203 months

Tuesday 7th May 2013
quotequote all
Keep the tuscan and buy a daily driver...

ellroy

7,835 posts

255 months

Tuesday 7th May 2013
quotequote all
OP i feel your pain.

4 trev's in and I've succumbed to the 'others'.

It's easier once you've made the move and accept you're morally and ethically bankrupt.

I hate that fking Russian for putting me through this.

6C4GTS

5,186 posts

208 months

Tuesday 7th May 2013
quotequote all
johnycarrera said:
I'd buy the newest 997 C2 if I could afford it, C2S if ladyboy spec.
I smell chocolate!!

mollytherocker

14,465 posts

239 months

Tuesday 7th May 2013
quotequote all
FarQue said:
Low 20s fuel consumption generally in our 997 Carrera S, less in our old 986S. You'd need to be saintly to achieve much more in the real world I reckon.
Those saying that they achieve an average of circa 30 mpg need to ask themselves why they have a 911!

thegoose

8,077 posts

240 months

Tuesday 7th May 2013
quotequote all
mollytherocker said:
Those saying that they achieve an average of circa 30 mpg need to ask themselves why they have a 911!
yes My 996 Carrera does 14-15mpg drivingbiggrin

Hilux2400

231 posts

166 months

Tuesday 7th May 2013
quotequote all
OK here's my two penneth as a relatively new owner of a 2003 996 Carrara 2 Tip at 48K.

This is my first Porsche so I went for the simplest version with the smallest number of options: Leather, Tiptronic, Computer, 18" wheels realising that as it was secondhand I would have to spend a further £2k at least to get it right.

It had a full service on handover including new spark plugs, brake fluid, front pads and discs and serpentine belt.

It does anything between 18mpg and 30mpg. Last weekend from a cold start and a 120 mile run it returned 28.6 mpg.

Having now looked at this car in some detail I would say that most service items are easy to do such as oil, filters, brake fluid, pads and discs, battery change and serpentine belt. Most garages would be able to do this work. New plugs are a bit harder and really a lift would make a change a lot easier. Certainly a specialist would do the work in a few hours.

Other repair work is harder as components are buried. I have changed the coolant reservoir, AOS and oil filler which are all items that seem to fail at about 10 years. The alternator was overhauled at the same time. This work cost about £1k at my local garage. The main problem was changing the coolant as the vehicle takes about 20 litres and bleeding the system takes some time and there are connections everywhere. I have also cleaned out the rads which were full of leaves and other road debris.

At this stage I am glad I did not get a turbo or a 4S as these are more complicated and a bit more crammed with technology. Perhaps with confidence I might move up, but I don't think these cars have the ruggedness of Japanese vehicles. They are a little more tender. However, they are great fun to drive and I love it. I'm glad I bought one. I smile every time I get out of it.

FalconWood

1,373 posts

227 months

Tuesday 7th May 2013
quotequote all
mollytherocker said:
Those saying that they achieve an average of circa 30 mpg need to ask themselves why they have a 911!
Your right. I get about 24 in my 997 Turbo and am told tgat is better than was achieved in the 996 Turbo. So I amazed if 30mpg is achieved ans as Molly says. ?....why have you got one if your eaking out 30mpg.