Second gear? Donnington park and others
Second gear? Donnington park and others
Author
Discussion

Jon999

Original Poster:

400 posts

171 months

Monday 3rd June 2013
quotequote all
Will I need second gear for the Donnington park national circuit. Car is a Mondeo ST220. As long as I can keep it above 50mph on the bends I won't need second as the gear tops out at 60mph anyway. I know it's only going to be a rough guide but what do people think? Am I going to be taking any corners much under 50? I've tried looking on YouTube at a few cars doing laps but can't make my mind up. Also any other circuits where 2nd isn't going to be required?

GreigM

6,740 posts

272 months

Monday 3rd June 2013
quotequote all
I'm assuming your gearbox is damaged. Would it not be sensible to avoid taking a car with a broken gearbox on track, given the large possibility of a breakdown and red-flag incident?

dapearson

4,456 posts

247 months

Monday 3rd June 2013
quotequote all
No, donington national is all 3rd and (mostly) 4th, 5th if you're topping out down the back straight.

Wh00sher

1,749 posts

241 months

Monday 3rd June 2013
quotequote all
2nd, at Donington ? Nah.

My gearbox had a worn Synchro from 3rd to 2nd for a few years. The only circuits I found it to be an issue were the hairpin at Cadwell, the complex before the start/ finish straight at Croft and Knockhill.

Even those can easily be taken in 3rd.

Jon999

Original Poster:

400 posts

171 months

Monday 3rd June 2013
quotequote all
GreigM said:
I'm assuming your gearbox is damaged. Would it not be sensible to avoid taking a car with a broken gearbox on track, given the large possibility of a breakdown and red-flag incident?
The synchro has gone but the total failure you describe is unlikely especially if second is avoided. Thanks to all for the input. Will probably get Donnington booked.

Clark3y

132 posts

161 months

Monday 3rd June 2013
quotequote all
As said, you won't need second on Donington. I do sometimes use it at the chicane though but I won't need to after I put the lower final gear in it.

Stephanie Plum

2,797 posts

234 months

Monday 3rd June 2013
quotequote all
It depends which layout surely? On the National no, but on the International you'll need it for the hairpin?

dapearson

4,456 posts

247 months

Monday 3rd June 2013
quotequote all
Stephanie Plum said:
It depends which layout surely? On the National no, but on the International you'll need it for the hairpin?
Even then i'd imagine 2nd would be a bit short for the hairpins. I could be wrong though, been a while since i've done the GP layout.

_Neal_

2,881 posts

242 months

Monday 3rd June 2013
quotequote all
3rd will almost definitely be too high for the hairpin at Donington - was 2nd in my Clio 172.

I must admit it seems a weird thing to do to book a trackday when you know there's a problem with your car - fair enough having already booked a (non-refundable) trackday before your car breaks, but that's not the case here. Would it not be best to put your trackday budget (which will be several hundred quid once fuel is taken into account) towards getting the 'box sorted?

Each to their own though.

Jon999

Original Poster:

400 posts

171 months

Monday 3rd June 2013
quotequote all
_Neal_ said:
3rd will almost definitely be too high for the hairpin at Donington - was 2nd in my Clio 172.

I must admit it seems a weird thing to do to book a trackday when you know there's a problem with your car - fair enough having already booked a (non-refundable) trackday before your car breaks, but that's not the case here. Would it not be best to put your trackday budget (which will be several hundred quid once fuel is taken into account) towards getting the 'box sorted?

Each to their own though.
I'm unsure what to do with the car to be honest. I want to take it on a proper track to see what it's like before fixing it or choosing to break it for parts and get myself something else. Only been round curborough so far which isn't really full circuit. Donnington is my local track so if 2nd isn't required on the national circuit I was going to do an evening session or two to get a proper feel for the car before spending money which I will never get back again. It isn't my daily driver.

Madgit

109 posts

176 months

Monday 3rd June 2013
quotequote all
National doesn't include the Melbourne Loop so, as correctly said above it's 3rd minimum (once out of pits). If you're in 2nd for the Esses, you're not going fast enough lol.

c_w

40 posts

257 months

Monday 3rd June 2013
quotequote all
_Neal_ said:
3rd will almost definitely be too high for the hairpin at Donington - was 2nd in my Clio 172.
There is no hairpin at Donington, the slowest point is the chicane before the start/finish straight but still an easy 3rd gear.

Clark3y

132 posts

161 months

Tuesday 4th June 2013
quotequote all
Didn't you see the bit about the GP circuit & Melbourne loop? I've never driven it and wouldn't be interested in doing so either, but the others are saying it's 2nd, seems fairly tight so makes sense.

Madgit

109 posts

176 months

Tuesday 4th June 2013
quotequote all
Yes Melbourne Loop (the hairpin on the GP circuit) would be 2nd for most cars.

_Neal_

2,881 posts

242 months

Tuesday 4th June 2013
quotequote all
c_w said:
There is no hairpin at Donington, the slowest point is the chicane before the start/finish straight but still an easy 3rd gear.
See above - there certainly can be smile

@OP - I see what you mean, and from the above (only driven the GP circuit myself) it sounds like you won't need 2nd. Give it a crack!


Edited by _Neal_ on Tuesday 4th June 11:40

Cobraman1

35 posts

163 months

Monday 10th June 2013
quotequote all
_Neal_ said:
See above - there certainly can be smile

@OP - I see what you mean, and from the above (only driven the GP circuit myself) it sounds like you won't need 2nd. Give it a crack!


Edited by _Neal_ on Tuesday 4th June 11:40
I really don't see why anyone, should take a car on track when they know it has a problem...if it breaks down, drivers loose track time, if it blows it's the same, if you went to a race meeting and the scrutinieers found it you would not be allowed on, so do yourself a favour and other drivers on the day..and don't run it buddy .

c_w

40 posts

257 months

Monday 10th June 2013
quotequote all
_Neal_ said:
See above - there certainly can be smile

@OP - I see what you mean, and from the above (only driven the GP circuit myself) it sounds like you won't need 2nd. Give it a crack!


Edited by _Neal_ on Tuesday 4th June 11:40
Sorry yes you're right, I assume by talking about trackdays that it'd be the national circuit which I think most of Donington car days are?

mattdaniels

7,362 posts

305 months

Wednesday 12th June 2013
quotequote all
Jon999 said:
I want to take it on a proper track to see what it's like before fixing it
As others are suggesting, I think your logic is a bit flawed.

It's also a touch unfair on ther other people on the day if you are knowingly turning up with a car that has mechanical fault that might make you the cause of a red flag.

Wh00sher

1,749 posts

241 months

Wednesday 12th June 2013
quotequote all
A worn synchro from 3rd to 2nd on a circuit where you won`t use 2nd isn`t exactly a major issue IMO...

Cobraman1

35 posts

163 months

Wednesday 12th June 2013
quotequote all
Wh00sher said:
A worn synchro from 3rd to 2nd on a circuit where you won`t use 2nd isn`t exactly a major issue IMO...
Hi Woosher, with all due respect, you can't tell from here, that's the problem, or this guys level of mechanical competence...trackdays are not test areas for vehicles with known faults, they are there for us to enjoy with our hard earned £'s....garages are there for this type of issue and that's what he should be booking into, not Donington Park !