What car - £2-3k, practical, ecnomical and fun
What car - £2-3k, practical, ecnomical and fun
Author
Discussion

wilbo83

Original Poster:

1,552 posts

196 months

Thursday 6th June 2013
quotequote all
This is probably my third ‘which car’ thread recently so I apologise for that however I am pondering another direction at the moment. My current garage consists of a 2005 Impreza WRX and a Mazda Eunos weekend toy. I am saving for a wedding and would like to change the WRX for something more economical (i.e averaging mid 30s mpg and upwards).

My original plan was to sell the WRX and spend the whole lot on another car, however my latest thought is to just buy something for £2-3k and save the extra cash. Which brings me to this thread, what would you buy for £2-3k for a daily driver which will cover approximately 16k per year and need to be practical, 4 seats and decent boot space. Ideally want something that is fun too, like a Clio 182 which is what started this though

Silverbullet767

11,385 posts

237 months

Thursday 6th June 2013
quotequote all
Honda Accord Type R?

Chris71

21,549 posts

273 months

Thursday 6th June 2013
quotequote all
Clio of some description is probably about the best combination of mpg, space and genuine dynamic ability you're going to get.

But if you wanted something well within the budget and a bit cheaper to run, what about a 1.7 Puma? Not in the same league as the Clio, but usefully cheaper I'd imagine.

V8RX7

28,982 posts

294 months

Thursday 6th June 2013
quotequote all
16k / year would put me off hot hatches and be looking at a 330 BMW Coupe

big_boz

1,685 posts

238 months

Thursday 6th June 2013
quotequote all
can you get mid 30s on an MPS mazda 6?

chevy-stu

5,392 posts

259 months

Thursday 6th June 2013
quotequote all
Remapped VAG diesel ?

wilbo83

Original Poster:

1,552 posts

196 months

Thursday 6th June 2013
quotequote all
V8RX7 said:
16k / year would put me off hot hatches and be looking at a 330 BMW Coupe
Would that realistically achieve mid 30s average mpg though? It claims a combined of 31. (don't want this thread to turn into an mpg debate!)

big_boz

1,685 posts

238 months

Thursday 6th June 2013
quotequote all
wilbo83 said:
Would that realistically achieve mid 30s average mpg though? It claims a combined of 31. (don't want this thread to turn into an mpg debate!)
Plenty of PH 330 owners says its very possible, plenty don't believe this.

wilbo83

Original Poster:

1,552 posts

196 months

Thursday 6th June 2013
quotequote all
big_boz said:
can you get mid 30s on an MPS mazda 6?
No chance. I was considering a 6 MPS before I bought the WRX so that would be like changing it for a very similar car.

big_boz

1,685 posts

238 months

Thursday 6th June 2013
quotequote all
wilbo83 said:
No chance. I was considering a 6 MPS before I bought the WRX so that would be like changing it for a very similar car.
I figured similar car, better on fuel, i bow to your superior knowledge, still they seem like cracking value, VED and fuel costs not withstanding. At 16k you must be well into the realms of Diesel making more financial sense than petrol. Something of a 2.5TDI VAG flavor perhaps?

Decent noise, reasonable on fuel and pull like a train.

big_boz

1,685 posts

238 months

Thursday 6th June 2013
quotequote all
actually reading back on your OP, i know of a mint low mileage clio 172 cup that is in your budget....it gets mid 30's as standard and can see 40's on a run. available in about am month.....PM me if interested.


kambites

71,748 posts

252 months

Thursday 6th June 2013
quotequote all
A mk1 Octavia VRS might do the job if your "mid 30s mpg" isn't too enthusiastic, although the chassis isn't the best.

V8RX7

28,982 posts

294 months

Thursday 6th June 2013
quotequote all
Sorry I missed the "mid" a 330 will realistically average 30 (depending upon use)




rumple

15,461 posts

182 months

Thursday 6th June 2013
quotequote all
big_boz said:
Plenty of PH 330 owners says its very possible, plenty don't believe this.
Im one, my 330 will do 23 0n my commute, 28 if driven gently, by that I mean driving it so slow its mind numbing, it will do late thirties on a run but 30 mpg commuting, no way, neither will the 328 I owned previously, also the fuel computers are never accurate on these either, they are a great car but do not meet the OP's brief.

Marc p

1,124 posts

173 months

Thursday 6th June 2013
quotequote all
MX.....oh, no need you already have one biggrin

I would recommend a Fabia VRS, they are fun, practical, economical and quite cheap now.

big_boz

1,685 posts

238 months

Thursday 6th June 2013
quotequote all
rumple said:
Im one, my 330 will do 23 0n my commute, 28 if driven gently, by that I mean driving it so slow its mind numbing, it will do late thirties on a run but 30 mpg commuting, no way, neither will the 328 I owned previously, also the fuel computers are never accurate on these either, they are a great car but do not meet the OP's brief.
This would have been my opinion, i wouldn't want to buy a car with an economy figure in mind (especially a performance orientated car) and then have to pussy foot around the loud pedal to hit the number. School friend of mine had one (his in laws now own it) think its a 56 plate and he didn't exactly rave about the economy.

big_boz

1,685 posts

238 months

Thursday 6th June 2013
quotequote all
Marc p said:
I would recommend a Fabia VRS, they are fun, practical, economical and quite cheap now.
Will run on Bio too so double savings available

wilbo83

Original Poster:

1,552 posts

196 months

Thursday 6th June 2013
quotequote all
Marc p said:
MX.....oh, no need you already have one biggrin

I would recommend a Fabia VRS, they are fun, practical, economical and quite cheap now.
biggrin

I just don't like the looks of the Skodas, either interior or exterior.

Marc p

1,124 posts

173 months

Thursday 6th June 2013
quotequote all
wilbo83 said:
biggrin

I just don't like the looks of the Skodas, either interior or exterior.
Leon Cupra?

Same car but much nicer looking inside and out(but there is a premium to pay for the better looks, but still cheaper than the Golf and not as bland).

I agree on the looks of the Skoda though, not exactly a pretty thing.

300bhp/ton

41,030 posts

221 months

Thursday 6th June 2013
quotequote all
wilbo83 said:
decent boot space
Can you define this please. Is there anything specific you need to carry or a size requirement?

wilbo83 said:
Would that realistically achieve mid 30s average mpg though? It claims a combined of 31. (don't want this thread to turn into an mpg debate!)
This very much depends on how and where you drive. I've seen claims of auto 330's doing as low as 17mpg for town work. Although I suspect more like 22-24 should be expected.

A manual driven gently on a long run however can attain good mpg.


But what you need to do is look at the Mode average you might get for your use. I can vary my of my cars mpg by up to 40% depending on how and where they are used.



If you want to save money and still meet all the requirements how about looking at cars such as:


e36 323i still enough poke but has the potential to be good on fuel.

MG ZS180. Huge value for money, saloon or hatch options and low/mid 30's possible. But you'll need to be considerate with the throttle pedal.


If you want to spend a little more money then maybe look at a Brabus smart ForFour. 45mpg+ ability and pretty quick too. The big bonus is strong residuals, so run it for a year and you'll only lose a small amount on it.