Stowa Marine Original or Longines Master Collection?
Stowa Marine Original or Longines Master Collection?
Author
Discussion

costsmonkey

Original Poster:

195 posts

187 months

Sunday 16th June 2013
quotequote all
Several recent threads on here have been of particular interest, notably those concerning plain faced watches and Stowa and Longines watches.

Ideally, like a number of others, I would like a Dornbluth 99 series but they are way above budget and so are out of the question, certainly for the time being.

In the absence of a Dornbluth, I had more or less decided on a Stowa Marine Original, or possibily Marine Automatic, and I am still keen.

However, I have recently had a look at the Longines Master collection and some of the plainer faced models also look appealing.

I realise that even at the lower end, the Longines Master Collection is noticably more expensive that the Stowa but the budget may stretch that far if I am persuaded that the watch itself is also noticably better.

Any information and views on the fundamental difference between the two and the pros and cons of each would be much appreciated. Essentially, which is the better watch and if the Longines is considered to be better, is it sufficiently better to justify the extra cost?

Ideally I would prefer to buy used by neither seem to come up very often. If anybody knows of any that are or might be available, the relevant details would also be appreciated.

DKL

4,996 posts

253 months

Sunday 16th June 2013
quotequote all
Ultimately you must buy what you prefer but I'd imagine the Longines would suffer quite dramatic depreciation especially at that cost. Stowa less so but a resale audience may be smaller.
Personally I like the Stowa range and they are just that little bit different.

Spice_Weasel

2,369 posts

284 months

Monday 17th June 2013
quotequote all
Stowa for me.

jgtv

2,130 posts

228 months

Monday 17th June 2013
quotequote all
I have a marine Auto, I am a big fan, little bit different without being over the top budget wise.

Picked mine up 2nd hand with a croc strap and deployment and its a very comfortable watch, so I would say Stowa

TSE

55 posts

232 months

Monday 17th June 2013
quotequote all
Hi,

Well I'm going to be slightly biased, as I acquired a Stowa Marine Original only last week! It's a lovely watch and the finish is equal to those at much higher prices. The waiting time for a new one is approximately 4 months, so I decided to look at second hand options - after drawing a blank, I then posted up a request on here and was lucky enough to find someone who was looking to sell theirs.

I'd budget around £500 for second hand and you certainly won't be dissapointed. I've already worn it with a suit and just jeans and a t-shirt and it looks great with both smart and casual. Here's a few images for you...

https://skydrive.live.com/redir?resid=5CA0470A765B...

https://skydrive.live.com/redir?resid=5CA0470A765B...

Paul S4

1,313 posts

241 months

Thursday 20th June 2013
quotequote all
I recently bought a year old Longines Master Collection automatic, from a well established Sheffield jeweller. The quality of the finish is superb, the bracelet is a work of art compared to some other supposedly 'high end' watches. I can compare it to previous watches ( eg my Oris F1) and the finish is on another level.
As far as depreciation is concerned, I would have thought that the Stowa would depreciate faster, although as has been said, it does appeal to 'serious' watch people, but it is a niche market. I expressed an interest in Stowa before I bought my Longines, and mentioned the brand to several AD retailers who deal in Omega/Rolex/IWC etc, and none of them had ever heard of Stowa.
However the Stowa Marine Original is a lovely looking watch and is that bit more 'individual'; you would certainly never see another one anyway!

At the end of the day it is all about personal preference; I chose the Longines mainly on the history of the brand, and therefore on the more secure resale potential.

costsmonkey

Original Poster:

195 posts

187 months

Sunday 30th June 2013
quotequote all
Interesting - four in favour the Stowa Marine Original and one well balanced and eloquent argument in favour of the Longines Master collection. That is very useful, thanks chaps.

It is clear that they are both good watches and I am pretty sure that I would be happy with either. I would prefer to buy pre owned but neither seem to come up used very often. I suspect it will come down to which one comes up first.

If anybody else has any views or knows of any used examples that might be available, it would be good to hear from you too.


James_N

3,305 posts

265 months

Monday 1st July 2013
quotequote all
I've had my Stowa Marine Original for nearly 5 years now. Customer service has been amazing, especially when the watch stopped unexpectedly after about 8 months. They took it back, paid my shipping, fixed it and had it back with me quick sharp.

Back in May I purchased a Steinhart Ocean One, but I think I'm going to sell it as it hasn't touched my wrist yet. My Marine original has been glued to my wrist since day one (unless i'm doing something where its going to get damaged) and I wouldn't have it any other way.

Its not the most expensive watch on here by far, but was a big purchase for me when I decided to go for it, and I have no regrets at all.

costsmonkey

Original Poster:

195 posts

187 months

Saturday 6th July 2013
quotequote all
Interesting, another preference for the Stowa.

James N, we appear to have similar tastes - I bought a Steinhart Ocean One late last year and am now looking to buy a Stowa Marine Original, or possibly one of the Longines Master Collection, to complement it.

I see there is another recent thread on here from somebody else looking for a pre owned Stowa Marine Original - seems they are popular and hard to find.

JRewing

17,551 posts

210 months

Saturday 6th July 2013
quotequote all
I personally prefer the Longines, but each are lovely. It seems from your comments that you prefer the Stowa too.

Bungleaio

6,595 posts

233 months

Saturday 6th July 2013
quotequote all
I love the clarity of the Stowa. The longines looks quite fussy but there seems to be a few models, I don't know much about longines which model are you considering.

costsmonkey

Original Poster:

195 posts

187 months

Saturday 6th July 2013
quotequote all
Ah, at last another preference for the Longines!

I had more or less decided that I wanted a Stowa Marine Original and I still like them very much.

However, I subsequently came across the Longines Master Collection, and in particular the model show in the link below, and like that very much too.

http://www.longines.com/watches/the-longines-maste...

I am currently finding it difficult to choose between the two, hence my original post.

On balance, I am currently leaning towards the Longines but would really prefer to buy pre owned so it may come down to which one comes up first.

Any further views or input would be much appreciated.