Closing a road because we can Harrow Way Stonehenge
Closing a road because we can Harrow Way Stonehenge
Author
Discussion

saaby93

Original Poster:

32,038 posts

209 months

Monday 24th June 2013
quotequote all
Interesting piece on the Beeb about the road closure next to Stonehenge
http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-wiltshire-230...
The road has been there long before Stonehenge and probably one of the reasons Stonehenge is where it is.
Today English Heritage (what is their purpose?) aim to grass over the road so as to reconnect Stonehenge with its heritage.
Surely they're missing the point that the road is part of the heritage.

More here
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Harrow_Way

velocemitch

4,019 posts

251 months

Monday 24th June 2013
quotequote all
Can't believe you are serious about this?.

The road ruins the visitor experiance at Stonehenge, the new scheme is far more sensible and should open up the site to make it much more peaceful and meaningful experience. The new visitor centre can only be better than the collection of huts they currently have on site too.

Perhaps the road has been there for centuries, but as far as I am aware they didn't have 40 tonne Trucks in neolithic times. In any case it's a widely held belief that the approach to the Henge was from the river up the wide 'Avenue' which you can just about see if look, but the road currently cuts it right in half, removing the road will help them reinstate that.

Or as 'Petrolheads' are we supposed to object to every road which is closed for good reasons?. confused

Pablo68

910 posts

166 months

Monday 24th June 2013
quotequote all
velocemitch said:
Can't believe you are serious about this?.

The road ruins the visitor experiance at Stonehenge, the new scheme is far more sensible and should open up the site to make it much more peaceful and meaningful experience. The new visitor centre can only be better than the collection of huts they currently have on site too.

Perhaps the road has been there for centuries, but as far as I am aware they didn't have 40 tonne Trucks in neolithic times. In any case it's a widely held belief that the approach to the Henge was from the river up the wide 'Avenue' which you can just about see if look, but the road currently cuts it right in half, removing the road will help them reinstate that.

Or as 'Petrolheads' are we supposed to object to every road which is closed for good reasons?. confused
I think the objection is that the road they are obliterating is actually an older and more relevant monument to human history over the ages in this country than Stonehenge is.

Arj256

82 posts

218 months

Monday 24th June 2013
quotequote all
Wouldn't it be far more sensible to just build some tunnels there and be done with it?

velocemitch

4,019 posts

251 months

Monday 24th June 2013
quotequote all
I think we should get a bit of perspective here, the road being closed is a short stretch of the A344 about 2 miles long with an eminantly sensible diversion up the A303 then A360 about two miles away. The A344 will be converted into a paved path to run from the new visitors centre about 1 Mile NEE of the site, with visitors riding down on a system of shuttles..... or walking, bit like they did in Neolithic times...

Just have a look at a map and you will see it's pretty sensible really.

saaby93

Original Poster:

32,038 posts

209 months

Monday 24th June 2013
quotequote all
Pablo68 said:
I think the objection is that the road they are obliterating is actually an older and more relevant monument to human history over the ages in this country than Stonehenge is.
yes yes
It's one of the oldest roads in the world.

If we had a heritage trust that protected roads, one of the highest on the list would be this road.

Removing it just because in someone's opinion stonehenge looks nicer without it, doesn't really cut the mustard.

If they're going to return it to status of an ancient track open to all of us as it used to be at the time of stonehenge that's another matter.

ETA I'm not convinced a vistor centre has a greater historical claim to the area than the road



Edited by saaby93 on Monday 24th June 19:09

V8 Fettler

7,019 posts

163 months

Monday 24th June 2013
quotequote all
I look at Stonehenge and think "Would it be possible to bunny-hop a trials bike from one stone to the next?"

cptsideways

13,905 posts

283 months

Monday 24th June 2013
quotequote all
The recent roundabout roadworks on the A303 lasting nearly 4 months were so they could move the roundabout 6m, yes six meters to the south!!!!!! I kid you not. Its in the middle of fricking nowhere!!! At least they did'nt put traffic lights on it.

So now the roundabout will be even more jammed with numpties than it was before turning north to the new visitor centre


bmcws

1 posts

161 months

Monday 24th June 2013
quotequote all
Probably just trying to make Stonehenge more Disney-fied, subscribing to the 'romantic' imagination of the 'movie' generation - It's likely that the vision of Stonehenge being a isolated moument in a massive field with no civilisation in sight is a complete fantasy.

The true motivation is probably attracting tourists that more likely to waste money in a massively commercial gift shop. Let hope that they don't add fog machines and pipe in Celine Dion sing some pseudo-Gaelic romantic song.

I would imagine that the Harrow Way not only is one of the most ancient roads, it was probably one of the most busy - huge amounts of commerce would have gone that way - as it does today. That would have been the character of Stonehenge. Taking away the A344/Harrow Way will remove that character.

toppstuff

13,698 posts

278 months

Monday 24th June 2013
quotequote all
I think its a great idea.

I think a road that seems perpetually stuffed with Tesco and B&Q lorries together with legions of dreary people with their caravans, long lost touch with its roots or any romantic sense of where it came from.

Or, to put it another way, I don't see closing or moving it removes the integrity of the overall region, given the advantages it confers on Stonehenge.

Don't have a problem with the closure personally

smile

sleep envy

62,260 posts

280 months

Monday 24th June 2013
quotequote all
Arj256 said:
Wouldn't it be far more sensible to just build some tunnels there and be done with it?
That was the idea about 15-20 years ago when I priced the scheme but the funding has dried up.


The Black Flash

13,735 posts

229 months

Monday 24th June 2013
quotequote all
saaby93 said:
Pablo68 said:
I think the objection is that the road they are obliterating is actually an older and more relevant monument to human history over the ages in this country than Stonehenge is.
yes yes
It's one of the oldest roads in the world.
And do you have aaaaaaany evidence, at all, for there being any sort of road there before, or even contemporary with, the henge?

You really think that the many generations of people who created the various incarnations of stonehenge built it right in the middle of a road? I mean, really? Have you actually been there?

The Black Flash

13,735 posts

229 months

Monday 24th June 2013
quotequote all
bmcws said:
Probably just trying to make Stonehenge more Disney-fied, subscribing to the 'romantic' imagination of the 'movie' generation - It's likely that the vision of Stonehenge being a isolated moument in a massive field with no civilisation in sight is a complete fantasy.

The true motivation is probably attracting tourists that more likely to waste money in a massively commercial gift shop. Let hope that they don't add fog machines and pipe in Celine Dion sing some pseudo-Gaelic romantic song.

I would imagine that the Harrow Way not only is one of the most ancient roads, it was probably one of the most busy - huge amounts of commerce would have gone that way - as it does today. That would have been the character of Stonehenge. Taking away the A344/Harrow Way will remove that character.
Or maybe, giving one of the world's most iconic monuments some facilities which aren't a national embarrassment, with some interpretation and museum on site, and letting you look at the thing without a busy road cutting through the middle of it? You think what it has now is character? Nope, it's st, and it's been st for decades. Finally they're doing something half decent about it. And still everybody moans.
Oh, and "huge amounts" of commerce going right through the monument, in 3000 BC? Yeah, sure rofl


digger the goat

2,868 posts

176 months

Monday 24th June 2013
quotequote all
Has anyone had a history lesson ???

'kin do gooders without a clue, causing a stir about ste all...
Ill educated twunts.

Go milk some moles or weasels or something else.
Or stop breathing and give my child a chance for cleaner air,,,

Piersman2

6,676 posts

230 months

Monday 24th June 2013
quotequote all
The cynical side of me wonders where the money is in this scheme.

Would it be cynical of me to suggest that the reason for closing the road that runs right next to Stonehenge is to make it impossible for anyone to see it without actually paying to go the visitor centre?

I accidentally drove passed it a few years back, had no idea I was approaching Stonehenge. Caught sight of it and thought... "Is that Stonehenge? It that IT? Woop-de-fecking-do. Won't be bothering with that".

And that was before being ripped £20 a head (or whatever it is now) for the pleasure.

It is owned by a private company now isn't it?

davepoth

29,395 posts

230 months

Tuesday 25th June 2013
quotequote all
The official reason for closing this bit of road is perfectly good - the junction with the A303 at Stonehenge was a nightmare if you wanted to turn right, and often caused a lot of traffic jams due to coaches from London trying to turn into Stonehenge.

Ozzie Osmond

21,189 posts

277 months

Tuesday 25th June 2013
quotequote all
Que? It's a stunning ancient monument and clearly visible from the main road.

Mind you, I think the best "millennium Project" for UK would have been to build a 10x size replica at Glastonbury in reinforced concrete. Something really big, long lasting and visible from space - also useful for the Festival to replace the pyramid stage. Much better than that flimsy Millennium Dome!

The Black Flash

13,735 posts

229 months

Tuesday 25th June 2013
quotequote all
Piersman2 said:
The cynical side of me wonders where the money is in this scheme.

Would it be cynical of me to suggest that the reason for closing the road that runs right next to Stonehenge is to make it impossible for anyone to see it without actually paying to go the visitor centre?

I accidentally drove passed it a few years back, had no idea I was approaching Stonehenge. Caught sight of it and thought... "Is that Stonehenge? It that IT? Woop-de-fecking-do. Won't be bothering with that".

And that was before being ripped £20 a head (or whatever it is now) for the pleasure.

It is owned by a private company now isn't it?
Wrong in almost every regard.

Skifledanabit

50 posts

222 months

Tuesday 25th June 2013
quotequote all
Personally, if the tarmac road could be diverted to avoid that particular stretch (as in it just loops around), and they turn that section into how it would of looked in the neolothic or time of stonehenge, i think that would be nice.

We do seem to be getting out of touch with our history imo. I was disappointed with stonehenge though. Paid a lot of money for not a lot of information about its place in our history.

Globs

13,847 posts

262 months

Tuesday 25th June 2013
quotequote all
The worst thing about stonehenge is the little money making scheme that operates on the common which restricts access completely unless you pay, and then still restricts access to a distant view.

Stonehenge sucks, a most unpleasant place of bloodsucking security.
Avebury on the other hand, lovely.