Changed my gearbox and now my clutch slips
Changed my gearbox and now my clutch slips
Author
Discussion

StottyZr

Original Poster:

6,860 posts

194 months

Monday 1st July 2013
quotequote all
The diff in my gearbox broke so I spent Sunday, hungover fitting a VTR box to my 106GTi. Now when I floor it after 3 or so times the clutch begins to slip confused

I thought the clutch may need adjusting but it seems to be adjusted fine, the bite point is decent and there's an inch or so of slack at the top of the clutch pedal travel. It also seems to go spongy after driving it hard.

Any ideas because I'm well and truly stumped.

nipsips

1,167 posts

166 months

Monday 1st July 2013
quotequote all
Did you refit the old clutch and if so did you contaminate it with oil? Was there any wear to the plates?

MGJohn

10,203 posts

214 months

Monday 1st July 2013
quotequote all
What you describe indicates a worn clutch.

Did you reuse the old clutch on reassembly? How much 'meat' was on the old friction plate? False economy not to renew clutch with gearbox removed.

Oil on the clutch interfaces ~ easily done.

Hard to say otherwise without examining the car.

StottyZr

Original Poster:

6,860 posts

194 months

Monday 1st July 2013
quotequote all
The clutch wasn't touched as it was only changed about 6000miles ago (by the previous owner) but come to think of it the friend helping me used lots of wd40 to clean the box up and put quite a lot of grease on the clutch shaft. Could this have contaminated the clutch?

motorhole

692 posts

251 months

Monday 1st July 2013
quotequote all
Not sure if this is correct but I wouldn't have greased the shaft at all except perhaps a small blob at the end where it goes into the pilot bearing at the end of the crank. Shouldn't need greasing and risks spraying it everywhere at upteenth rpm...

HustleRussell

26,715 posts

191 months

Monday 1st July 2013
quotequote all
Was the plate installed the right way 'round? Was the pressure plate replaced 6000 miles ago along with the friction plate?
It's normal to lightly grease the input shaft splines and pilot bearing, but inadvisable to spray WD-40 anywhere near the flywheel/clutch assembly.

Do it again with a brand new, decent quality 3 piece clutch kit.

GavinPearson

5,715 posts

282 months

Tuesday 2nd July 2013
quotequote all
StottyZr said:
The clutch wasn't touched as it was only changed about 6000miles ago (by the previous owner) but come to think of it the friend helping me used lots of wd40 to clean the box up and put quite a lot of grease on the clutch shaft. Could this have contaminated the clutch?
Without question, yes.

The correct amount of grease is the amount needed so as to be barely visible yet tacky when you touch it.

Any more than that and it will stop the damper working on non DMF clutches and cause slip, on DMF clutches they will just slip.

WD40 is a de-watering fluid and not a lubricant, spray it in, wipe it all off and you are good to go.

The Black Flash

13,735 posts

229 months

Tuesday 2nd July 2013
quotequote all
GavinPearson said:
StottyZr said:
The clutch wasn't touched as it was only changed about 6000miles ago (by the previous owner) but come to think of it the friend helping me used lots of wd40 to clean the box up and put quite a lot of grease on the clutch shaft. Could this have contaminated the clutch?
Without question, yes.

The correct amount of grease is the amount needed so as to be barely visible yet tacky when you touch it.

Any more than that and it will stop the damper working on non DMF clutches and cause slip, on DMF clutches they will just slip.

WD40 is a de-watering fluid and not a lubricant, spray it in, wipe it all off and you are good to go.
That'd be my guess too, you've oiled it.
Might be able to clean it if you take it apart and get busy with the cutch or brake cleaning fluid.

StottyZr

Original Poster:

6,860 posts

194 months

Tuesday 2nd July 2013
quotequote all
The Black Flash said:
GavinPearson said:
StottyZr said:
The clutch wasn't touched as it was only changed about 6000miles ago (by the previous owner) but come to think of it the friend helping me used lots of wd40 to clean the box up and put quite a lot of grease on the clutch shaft. Could this have contaminated the clutch?
Without question, yes.

The correct amount of grease is the amount needed so as to be barely visible yet tacky when you touch it.

Any more than that and it will stop the damper working on non DMF clutches and cause slip, on DMF clutches they will just slip.

WD40 is a de-watering fluid and not a lubricant, spray it in, wipe it all off and you are good to go.
That'd be my guess too, you've oiled it.
Might be able to clean it if you take it apart and get busy with the cutch or brake cleaning fluid.
This makes sense. I take it there's no chance it will clear itself?

Is it a case of disconnecting the gearbox and removing all the grease I can then covering everything in WD40 to displace the grease?

inman999

34,954 posts

204 months

Tuesday 2nd July 2013
quotequote all
StottyZr said:
This makes sense. I take it there's no chance it will clear itself?

Is it a case of disconnecting the gearbox and removing all the grease I can then covering everything in WD40 to displace the grease?
No. Better to use brake and clutch cleaner, better still to bite the bullet and fit a new clutch as you're going to have to access the old one anyway.

The Black Flash

13,735 posts

229 months

Tuesday 2nd July 2013
quotequote all
inman999 said:
StottyZr said:
This makes sense. I take it there's no chance it will clear itself?

Is it a case of disconnecting the gearbox and removing all the grease I can then covering everything in WD40 to displace the grease?
No. Better to use brake and clutch cleaner, better still to bite the bullet and fit a new clutch as you're going to have to access the old one anyway.
This, but cleaner is cheaper than a new clutch. Don't put any more WD40 on it for gawd's sake!

Slightly OT - my old man used to tell tales of removing oil from the clutch of an Austin 7 by wedging it up against the wall of the blacksmith's shop and revving it with the clutch slipping until the oil burnt off it. Probably not recommended!

john2443

6,554 posts

242 months

Tuesday 2nd July 2013
quotequote all
Before you take it all apart, is it possible to check that the clutch linkage isn't sticking in some way?

If you can access the release arm, make sure it is returning all the way.

Krikkit

27,943 posts

212 months

Tuesday 2nd July 2013
quotequote all
The release arm is easy to access and trouble-free in this application.

I'd get a couple of tins of clutch/brake cleaner and go mad - you can get quite decent access from underneath as the bell-housing is quite exposed. Another way in is the crank position sensor - take it off and you've got another good access point to straw in some cleaner.

StottyZr

Original Poster:

6,860 posts

194 months

Tuesday 2nd July 2013
quotequote all
I fit a VTR box as one was readily available and I had two days to get the box changed! The ratio's aren't too terrible, looking on the bright side it should save a bit of fuel hehe

Changing the entire clutch seems a bit overkill, but if it needs to be done then...

For now I'll try the other suggestions and blast something in to remove the grease and hope for the best. I do not fancy spending another day fighting with a gearbox mad

DanielJames

7,543 posts

199 months

Tuesday 2nd July 2013
quotequote all
Hey bud, I did the exact same thing on my 106 GTi

Gearbox blew up, changed the gearbox, then the clutch slipped.

Turns out the clutch must have been contaminated with oil so I had to buy a new clutch.

So you're probably taking the box off again.

That said, when my diff went on my Saxo VTS box, I was able to just change the box and it was okay. Perhaps you were not so lucky.

Trying to find the pic of my box but it seems I've lost it frown

GavinPearson

5,715 posts

282 months

Wednesday 3rd July 2013
quotequote all
Once the clutch slips the only sensible course of action is to:
1) remove the gearbox,
2) clean the gearbox bellhousing,
3) grease the splines and then wipe off the excess grease until it is barely visible yet tacky to the touch,
4) Remove the pressure plate and clean with brake clean, lightly abrade with a scotchbrite pad and then clean with brake clean. If it looks OK, it'll be fine to reuse it.
5) Fit a new driven plate - cleaning it simply won't work.
6) Clean all excess grease off the release bearing and clutch release mechanism, anything that needs greasing should be greased to the barely visible level and no more.
7) Reassemble.


V8RX7

28,982 posts

294 months

Wednesday 3rd July 2013
quotequote all
Krikkit said:
I'd get a couple of tins of clutch/brake cleaner and go mad - you can get quite decent access from underneath as the bell-housing is quite exposed.

Another way in is the crank position sensor - take it off and you've got another good access point to straw in some cleaner.
^^^^THIS

You have nothing to lose.

Superhoop

4,919 posts

224 months

Wednesday 3rd July 2013
quotequote all
V8RX7 said:
Krikkit said:
I'd get a couple of tins of clutch/brake cleaner and go mad - you can get quite decent access from underneath as the bell-housing is quite exposed.

Another way in is the crank position sensor - take it off and you've got another good access point to straw in some cleaner.
^^^^THIS

You have nothing to lose.
Or, rather than using brake cleaner, try a bottle of full fat coke - Google it, it works wonders at removing grease/oil from a slipping clutch plate

StottyZr

Original Poster:

6,860 posts

194 months

Wednesday 3rd July 2013
quotequote all
GavinPearson said:
Once the clutch slips the only sensible course of action is to:
1) remove the gearbox,
2) clean the gearbox bellhousing,
3) grease the splines and then wipe off the excess grease until it is barely visible yet tacky to the touch,
4) Remove the pressure plate and clean with brake clean, lightly abrade with a scotchbrite pad and then clean with brake clean. If it looks OK, it'll be fine to reuse it.
5) Fit a new driven plate - cleaning it simply won't work.
6) Clean all excess grease off the release bearing and clutch release mechanism, anything that needs greasing should be greased to the barely visible level and no more.
7) Reassemble.
This looks like the correct answer and the best way to ensure the job is done correctly.

Although bearing in mind the car is worth ~£750 it seems like a helluvalot of work. The car does drive fine under normal circumstances, it only slips after multiple hard accelerations (with no clutch smell from the slipping) and tbh I'd rather drive it around until it borks than go to all this trouble. I'm not a mechanic and I'm not exactly the fastest with a spanner.

StottyZr

Original Poster:

6,860 posts

194 months

Wednesday 14th August 2013
quotequote all
Just to update. The problem has solved itself, I did nothing except continue to drive the car and the grease has seemingly dispersed entirely.