Watch advice for a relative noob
Watch advice for a relative noob
Author
Discussion

Chunk49

Original Poster:

353 posts

181 months

Tuesday 2nd July 2013
quotequote all
Hi all

Background is: worn a watch (the same watch) pretty much every day since I was 18 - my Dad bought me a Seiko kinetic watch that looked a lot like this one:

http://www.amazon.co.uk/Seiko-Mens-Solar-Watch-SNE...

Except it is a kinetic, has a dark blue background, showed date only and was £189 in 2002. Shows how much the price of certain consumer goods have decreased! After 10 years of brilliant service it recently died (or so I thought) - since perusing this area of the forum I've now realised that the capacitor is dead. I've seen a thread saying £100 cost to have replaced + service with an independent or £30 as a DIY. Given that the watch has taken 10 years of battering, I think it's probably better of that I simply replace it (and keepy the watch obviously as it has massive sentimental value).

Am currently buying my first property and so money is tight (and I always like a good deal too if I can get one). So, I have snapped up one of these:

http://www.christopherward.co.uk/review/product/li...

which, while I knew nothing of the brand before perusing this forum last few days, I assume I can't go far wrong for £107 (I'm hoping at least that's the general consensus and I haven't just bought a lemon??) So hopefully that's a 'going out' watch sorted. My wrists aren't massive so am slightly concerned about the 40mm diameter but will hopefully be OK as it will be used as a dress watch and not as a watch for work.

So, I need a watch for every day (i.e. work) to replace the outgoing Seiko. As noted above, this watch lookd almost identical to my previous watch but with a black screen and looks great value at £88 delivered as against list of £125. It is also completely work appropriate and in no way flash. This is good.

http://www.amazon.co.uk/Seiko-Mens-Solar-Watch-SNE...

Can anyone point me to this or a similar watch with a dark blue background? Or would any of you wise people recommend a different watch? I really like blue - it's my favourite colour. But no matter if not.

Are Seikos generally well rated for build quality, value and reliability? Those are the things I'd be looking for in a work watch, and hopefully I'll get another 10 years good service out of it. Again, am thinking that for £88 delivered I can't go far wrong - but happy to be told otherwise if others have better ideas :-)

So if I can get a 'going out' watch and a work watch at those prices that's inside £200 - I like the sound of that.

This then leaves me funds (whether now or in a few months following my flat purchase) if I find the right metal watch which I could say use equally for work or for going out. Along those lines I think this is really nice (I'm really picky and find most watches (even expensive ones) pretty ugly):

http://www.christopherward.co.uk/men/dress/c3mk2/c...

This would be either a joint work/extra play watch to give the leather strap £107 a rest, or an additional 'going out' watch in its own right (if I can part with the cash).

Does anyone think there is sense in leaving it at just the CW and the cheap Seiko work watch for now, in order to pile into a more expensive watch say £400-£500 in a few months i.e. avoid a 'stop-gap' watch at around £250-£300?

Thoughts in this watch? As I said, I think it's really nice. Can anyone point me to a similar watch but with a dark blue background? Again, no worries if not. Or for that money is there another watch which would be a better choice for that money 'all day long'?

In respect of metal watches (whether a work one or an additiona 'going out one') - my requirements (aside from price are):

- dark face (either black/dark grey or dark blue)
- chunky links on the strap (not the little chain mail style links)
- silver
- not with a big bezel (preferably no bezel)
- not massive as I have fairly small wrists - the work one must be smallish like the 37mm one I posted above, although any more dressy metal watch can be a bit bigger


Thanks for reading and for your help. I hope the above ramblings are clear enough to someo of you at least!




Edited by Chunk49 on Tuesday 2nd July 08:07


Edited by Chunk49 on Tuesday 2nd July 08:09


Edited by Chunk49 on Tuesday 2nd July 08:11


Edited by Chunk49 on Tuesday 2nd July 08:12


Edited by Chunk49 on Tuesday 2nd July 08:20


Edited by Chunk49 on Tuesday 2nd July 08:49

chris.mapey

4,778 posts

298 months

Tuesday 2nd July 2013
quotequote all
I'd suggest a look at "Parnis Watches" on ebay...

Something like this http://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/Parnis-Luxury-White-Powe...

could be the ideal solution for the 'third' watch...

Also, could this work for the Seiko with a blue face?

http://www.creationwatches.com/products/seiko-kine...

Hope that helps

Chunk49

Original Poster:

353 posts

181 months

Tuesday 2nd July 2013
quotequote all
chris.mapey said:
I'd suggest a look at "Parnis Watches" on ebay...

Something like this http://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/Parnis-Luxury-White-Powe...

could be the ideal solution for the 'third' watch...

Also, could this work for the Seiko with a blue face?

http://www.creationwatches.com/products/seiko-kine...

Hope that helps
Thanks Chris :-)

Never heard of Parnis (unsurprisingly) but that looks like a very cool watch! Especially for £60! However, I fear both watches would be too big for me at 43mm. I reckon 40mm would probably be the max - on that note - I guess I should get myself down to Ernest Jones and try some different sizes on so I know what fits and what doesn't. The 37mm definitely does, although I could take a watch a little bigger, which is why am thinking 40mm would be my max.

chris.mapey

4,778 posts

298 months

Tuesday 2nd July 2013
quotequote all
I wouldn't worry too much over the sizes, I have a couple of Parnis watches and they wear quite 'small' compared to others (I have a Breitling and a Fortis, and they wear 'big' if that makes sense!)

It's something to do with the way the lugs come off the case & attach to the bracelet that changes the way the watch sits on your wrist...

Chunk49

Original Poster:

353 posts

181 months

Tuesday 2nd July 2013
quotequote all
chris.mapey said:
I wouldn't worry too much over the sizes, I have a couple of Parnis watches and they wear quite 'small' compared to others (I have a Breitling and a Fortis, and they wear 'big' if that makes sense!)

It's something to do with the way the lugs come off the case & attach to the bracelet that changes the way the watch sits on your wrist...
Yes the Breitlings I have seen and they are WAY too big for my liking.

So do Parnis have a decent repuation then? For a pretty cool looking watch they seem pretty cheap. Any reason why?

chris.mapey

4,778 posts

298 months

Tuesday 2nd July 2013
quotequote all
Parnis have a 'mixed' reputation on the online watch forums - they are a Chinese 'cooperative' of watch makers using 'pattern' parts and can be a mixed bag, but lots of watches are shipped each year, and there's only a handful of vocal complainers on the forums...

I have two Parnise, a moonphase dress watch and an IWC Big Pilot 'homage' (unbranded) one, both of which are great quality, and have been in regular service for a while (The Big Pilot is nearly two years old) with no problems.

As with many things, bear in mind 'you get what you pay for' - so don't expect Patek Philippe build quality for less than £70, but you will end up with a smart, useable watch for not much cash.

Again, hope that makes sense

JRewing

17,551 posts

210 months

Tuesday 2nd July 2013
quotequote all
To answer one of your questions, yes Seiko IS renowned for quality, value and reliability.

I don't know what has been posted already, but have a look at the Seiko 5 range of watches online.

Chunk49

Original Poster:

353 posts

181 months

Tuesday 2nd July 2013
quotequote all
chris.mapey said:
Parnis have a 'mixed' reputation on the online watch forums - they are a Chinese 'cooperative' of watch makers using 'pattern' parts and can be a mixed bag, but lots of watches are shipped each year, and there's only a handful of vocal complainers on the forums...

I have two Parnise, a moonphase dress watch and an IWC Big Pilot 'homage' (unbranded) one, both of which are great quality, and have been in regular service for a while (The Big Pilot is nearly two years old) with no problems.

As with many things, bear in mind 'you get what you pay for' - so don't expect Patek Philippe build quality for less than £70, but you will end up with a smart, useable watch for not much cash.

Again, hope that makes sense
Chris - understood - thanks for your help :-) You judged me correctly in that at this stage of my life (I'm 28) I don't have the money for expensive luxuries, so inexpensive but still stylish and cool luxeries, are definitely the way forward :-) Thanks :-) As you say, for £70 you can't really go too far wrong - am very tempted to get one ordered!

Chunk49

Original Poster:

353 posts

181 months

Tuesday 2nd July 2013
quotequote all
JRewing said:
To answer one of your questions, yes Seiko IS renowned for quality, value and reliability.

I don't know what has been posted already, but have a look at the Seiko 5 range of watches online.
Nice one! This is perfect for the daily work watch and it's only £60 delivered - bargain! And it even has a dark blue screen which I like :-) Is this the kind of watch you were referring to?

http://www.watchshop.com/mens-seiko-5-automatic-wa...

Chunk49

Original Poster:

353 posts

181 months

Tuesday 2nd July 2013
quotequote all
Any more for any more before I start pulling a couple of triggers? :-)

mikeveal

5,141 posts

281 months

Tuesday 2nd July 2013
quotequote all
I was going to suggest a look at Parnis. But do not use ebay.
As has been hinted at, Parnis watches are assembled by the seller. That means quality varies wildly as does the willingness to refund.

Cut and paster from another thread.
There's a lot to be said for Parnis. All of these are from http://manbushijie.com.

You will need to budget an extra £30 for a strap and a clasp, the supplied straps are basically cardboard. This guy is good : http://www.watchworx.co.uk/pages/lwb/elite.html

When buying Parnis, it's important to know that the seller is the guy assembling the watches from a pile of parts supplied by Parnis. Therefore it's essential to pick a seller with a good reputation and one who accepts returns. Budget an exta £15 to send the watch back for an exchange.
These prices are USD, you'll need to log in to the site to see these.


44mm, hand winding $68 :



43mm, automatic, display case back. $77 :



43mm, automatic, display case back. $72 :



Lots more at similar prices.















I have this one:

All but one of those are 43 or 44mm.

I prefer the 43s as I too have tiny 7 1/4" wrists. Also the 47mm parnis watches encase exactly the same seagull movements. So when you look through the display case back, the movement is clearly waaay too small for the case. You can even see it on some of the 43mm watches.

My 43mm Parnis (Manbushije's pic):


A 43mm case that I wouldn't buy:


A 47mm caseback:



And yes, Parnis seem to have developed the worlds noisiest autowinding rotor. My wife refers to it as the cat's bell.

chris.mapey

4,778 posts

298 months

Tuesday 2nd July 2013
quotequote all
Just FYI this is the Parnis Moonphase dress watch I have - both mine are manual wind so I don't suffer from the noisy cat's bell syndrome ;-)


Chunk49

Original Poster:

353 posts

181 months

Tuesday 2nd July 2013
quotequote all
Certainly some great looking watches :-)

This migth be a daft question and no doubt my lack of anything remotely resembling technical skill would preclude me from doing so in any case, but is there anything stopping me getting the unassembled watch direct from Parnis?

sparkyhx

4,200 posts

235 months

Tuesday 2nd July 2013
quotequote all

mikeveal

5,141 posts

281 months

Tuesday 2nd July 2013
quotequote all
Chunk49 said:
Certainly some great looking watches :-)

This migth be a daft question and no doubt my lack of anything remotely resembling technical skill would preclude me from doing so in any case, but is there anything stopping me getting the unassembled watch direct from Parnis?
No idea, I suspect they're only set up to deal with bulk buyers. Why bother? Your learning experience will almost certainly involve knackering one of more of the internals. Pretty hard to beat these prices.

tertius

6,914 posts

261 months

Tuesday 2nd July 2013
quotequote all
Some of those Parnis are not bad looking, but god those movements look awful, they should really resist the temptation to put display backs on ... wink

mikeveal

5,141 posts

281 months

Tuesday 2nd July 2013
quotequote all
Not sure I agree. The movements are basic, yes.

What I really hate is where they put a display caseback on a movement that's too small for the case. They all appear to be the same basic movement, I think it looks OK through the back of the 43mm watch, but through the larger casebacks it just looks wrong.

Chunk49

Original Poster:

353 posts

181 months

Tuesday 2nd July 2013
quotequote all
They do look very nice those watches. Although from what I now know about them I'm not sure they're for me (as much as I love a bargain).

Seiko 5 with blue background arriving tomorrow :-)

What's generally accepted as constituting a "good movement"?

13aines

2,209 posts

180 months

Tuesday 2nd July 2013
quotequote all
I've just picked up one of these for £55 from manbushijie. The price dropped $30 when I registered. Had it sent EMS, shipped 26th, hit the UK on the 30th, and been waiting for customs clearance since frown - Just a quartz but I figure, less to go wrong!



Wanted a Toshi strap, which, while gorgeous, cost way more than the watch. None of mine, or any on the to-attain-one-day list take a 22mm strap, so I went for a black grain hand made Steveo Straps strap with red stitching... should look good. If I love the watch, i'll get a dark brown strap too I think.

If it turns out to be decent, as I have read, I will be ordering ASAP a few models to sell in the UK. Manbushijie is reputedly the best Parnis supplier.

If they sell easily for a small profit I will make a big varied order and get selling, for a small income while studying smile - I would be matching the ebay prices of the Chinese and Japanese sellers, but the watches would be in the UK. We all hate waiting!
0
If I could sell enough maybe I could get the real thing from IWC wink

Chunk49

Original Poster:

353 posts

181 months

Tuesday 2nd July 2013
quotequote all
Out of interest, what's the average cost from manbush vs what the Chinese and Japanese sellers are selling them for on ebay?