Whew!! It's hot in here!!
Author
Discussion

computamedic

Original Poster:

312 posts

264 months

Friday 12th July 2013
quotequote all
'56 plate Golf GT 170 TDi with non-working aircon. I've had a couple of places check and refill the gas and everything checks out fine with no leaks and good pressures - but still no chill!! Apparently the clutch on the compressor isn't engaging (so Kwik Fit tell me) but they can't figure out why.

I know there's a lot to it with pressure sensors, relays and fuses but can anyone offer a suggestion where to look for the more obvious culprits?? Could a VAGCOM scan help??

Maracus

4,553 posts

199 months

Friday 12th July 2013
quotequote all
I had an issue with my MK5 Golf GTi, the aircon wasn't cold frown

I needed a new compressor. I bought one from ECP and had it fitted at APS in Brackley - who had diagnosed the faulty compressor originally. Total cost of diagnosis, new compressor, fitting and regas was around £550.

If you're near to APS in Brackley, then I can highly recommend them, speak with Ed. ECP have a discount code at the moment.

cuprabob

19,913 posts

245 months

Friday 12th July 2013
quotequote all
If the clutch is not engaging, could be the pressure sensor, common problem.

computamedic

Original Poster:

312 posts

264 months

Friday 12th July 2013
quotequote all
Maracus said:
I had an issue with my MK5 Golf GTi, the aircon wasn't cold frown

I needed a new compressor. I bought one from ECP and had it fitted at APS in Brackley - who had diagnosed the faulty compressor originally. Total cost of diagnosis, new compressor, fitting and regas was around £550.

If you're near to APS in Brackley, then I can highly recommend them, speak with Ed. ECP have a discount code at the moment.
Thanks for the suggestion, but I had all this done only 3 years ago for much the same cost. I sincerely hope the new compressor hasn't packed up already. With the weather this country gets the aircon compressor isn't exactly over-worked. I'm hoping Curpabob is nearer the mark.

Farmerpalmer

277 posts

195 months

Friday 12th July 2013
quotequote all
I had a similar problem with my 2007 gti. Turns out it was a leaking pressure switch. Took a while for them to see the dye leaking. Total cost was £ 180 including regas. Now aircon is v cool, and a leave it on all the time to prevent seals drying out.

Hub

7,170 posts

229 months

Friday 12th July 2013
quotequote all
Mine seems to only kick out a bit of cold air when thrashed and not when idle or gentle cruising - could just need a re-gas or something else?

computamedic

Original Poster:

312 posts

264 months

Monday 15th July 2013
quotequote all
If the problem is caused by the sensor is it possible that shorting the sensor terminals would prove the point. Does anyone have any idea where the sensor is and if the sensor is literally a switch - or is it more complicated that that??

Regards

Dave

computamedic

Original Poster:

312 posts

264 months

Friday 19th July 2013
quotequote all
Just to bring the story up to date it turns out that it IS the compressor - again!!! Having had it replaced only 3 years ago for a "better" design, I'm less than thrilled that the thing has seized again exactly duplicating the problem suffered by the original. Added to the other small problems with a leaking shock and a torn CV boot I'm looking at another £1000+ bill!!!! I'm thinking I might grow accustomed to the heat!!

Dr G

16,006 posts

273 months

Friday 19th July 2013
quotequote all
Possibly a stupid question - do you use your AC all year round?

Under use is a common cause of failed components.

computamedic

Original Poster:

312 posts

264 months

Saturday 20th July 2013
quotequote all
Dr G said:
Possibly a stupid question - do you use your AC all year round?

Under use is a common cause of failed components.
Not a stupid question at all. The answer is yes - unless it's turned off via the "Econ" switch (which it never is) I'm assuming the a/c is on all the time.

A quick phone call with the guy who fitted the last replacement compressor suggested there might be a problem with a blocked condenser causing the compressor to seize. Impossible to verify of course without some major dismantling but the addition of the suggested replacement condenser as well as another new compressor is just adding to the cost. Given the current hot weather being unlikely to continue for more than a few weeks at best I think I'm going to leave it over the next winter and get it sorted for next summer.

nick heppinstall

9,106 posts

311 months

Saturday 20th July 2013
quotequote all
Dr G said:
Possibly a stupid question - do you use your AC all year round?

Under use is a common cause of failed components.
Not sure if its the same design on your year but my 2010 Octavia Compressor is always on no matter if its turned on or not. Good because you don't have to worry about seals etc but bad because they don't seem to last long no matter how you use them.....

warmfuzzies

4,379 posts

284 months

Sunday 21st July 2013
quotequote all
Hello Dave.

Kevin.

the-photographer

5,209 posts

207 months

Sunday 21st July 2013
quotequote all
computamedic said:
Just to bring the story up to date it turns out that it IS the compressor - again!!! Having had it replaced only 3 years ago for a "better" design, I'm less than thrilled that the thing has seized again exactly duplicating the problem suffered by the original. Added to the other small problems with a leaking shock and a torn CV boot I'm looking at another £1000+ bill!!!! I'm thinking I might grow accustomed to the heat!!
Can you find out if you fitted a Sanden compressor three year ago?

These shouldn't go wrong (assuming the other parts of the system remain OK).

the-photographer

5,209 posts

207 months

Sunday 21st July 2013
quotequote all
nick heppinstall said:
Dr G said:
Possibly a stupid question - do you use your AC all year round?

Under use is a common cause of failed components.
Not sure if its the same design on your year but my 2010 Octavia Compressor is always on no matter if its turned on or not. Good because you don't have to worry about seals etc but bad because they don't seem to last long no matter how you use them.....
Yep, the Sanden unit runs all the time

http://www.my-gti.com/2465/sanden-pxe16-air-condit...

Dr G

16,006 posts

273 months

Sunday 21st July 2013
quotequote all
Interesting, did not know that.

computamedic

Original Poster:

312 posts

264 months

Wednesday 24th July 2013
quotequote all
As I find out more about this story I think it worth repeating here as a warning to others.

As I had mentioned previously, my compressor failed 3 years ago. At that time it was initially taken to a VW dealer who had recommended a compressor replacement and a system flush. The warranty company wouldn't stump up for the system flush, the VW dealer wouldn't do the job without, so I took it to an independent who just replaced the compressor.

Now that the compressor has failed again 3 years later it transpires that the system flush was an essential part of the repair - as well as the recommended replacement of the condenser/dryer too - to remove the debris left from the initial compressor failure. If not flushed the debris ultimately collects in the new compressor - and, guess what?? It seizes!!

The moral of the story is obvious. Don't be inclined to scrimp on the repair if your compressor fails as you'll be paying for it again in a while. A lesson too if buying a vehicle secondhand - beware the cheap fix before the sale.

It's a lesson well learned from my viewpoint.

the-photographer

5,209 posts

207 months

Wednesday 24th July 2013
quotequote all
Ah yes, there are a couple of failure modes, one where the input shaft snaps and the other total internal meltdown requiring a flush (the other mode may also need a flush just to be safe).

Too late now, but specialist forums like http://www.golfgtiforum.co.uk would have known more. The Sanden replacement with a flush should last the lifetime of the car.

computamedic

Original Poster:

312 posts

264 months

Monday 23rd June 2014
quotequote all
An interesting follow-up to this story. After only three and half months with the new compressor IT HAS FAILED AGAIN!!!

Fortunately got the same guy to look at the problem and found the three little plastic links driving the centre spindle had, again, broken. Despite all sorts of theories - such as failed condenser cooling fan - a replacement compressor was fitted and all systems checked (including the condenser fan) and the conclusion reached that the compressor fitted 3 months ago must have been faulty. A result for me since I wasn't charged for the fix but worrying in a way.

The tech who fixed it was frustrated that the pump manufacturer won't sell the parts to replace the plastic links in an otherwise perfectly serviceable pump, so for the sake of a few pennies worth of plastic the whole pump is deemed useless. I wonder how many other people get caught in this trap of paying £00's for the sake of a few pence worth of plastic. I guess it's what they call "progress"!!

I'm relieved I got away with a warranty call this time.

Kell

1,708 posts

239 months

Monday 23rd June 2014
quotequote all
Pleased you got it sorted this time around and hope it's fixed for good.

On that last point, about a few pennies worth of prevention.

The Air con know on our old TT developed a strees crack. Everything worked OK, it just didn't look that great. Turned out that, back then, you couldn't buy the know without replacing the whole unit. £650 later and a new one was fitted. Thankfully that was under warranty or I'd have driven it as it was.

SuperchargedVR6

3,138 posts

251 months

Monday 23rd June 2014
quotequote all
Hub said:
Mine seems to only kick out a bit of cold air when thrashed and not when idle or gentle cruising - could just need a re-gas or something else?
Check the radiator fans are working when the A/C is switched on.