How good is McLaren MP4
How good is McLaren MP4
Author
Discussion

reedman

Original Poster:

588 posts

225 months

Friday 12th July 2013
quotequote all

Jonty355

4,423 posts

244 months

Friday 12th July 2013
quotequote all
I'd buy a 458 instead.

belleair302

7,015 posts

238 months

Friday 12th July 2013
quotequote all
Possibly the best car you will drive in the next two years from a technical and chassis point of view. However if you want character, a few unusual quirks, have a good specialist relationship and the urge to follow many others then look elsewhere. Hugely fast, seriously fast, very capable, good dealer network, very well built cars and still somewhat rare.....however for some a work in progress and lacking in driver input. Go out and drive one, hard.

andrew

10,368 posts

223 months

Friday 12th July 2013
quotequote all
fast but boring
hth

jackal

11,251 posts

313 months

Friday 12th July 2013
quotequote all
I was looking round the p1 today. Mclaren seem to be manufacturing cars in a completely different way to anyone else. Its as if you are looking at the future.

isaldiri

25,281 posts

199 months

Friday 12th July 2013
quotequote all
In answer to your subject: Very.

propaganda

407 posts

278 months

Friday 12th July 2013
quotequote all
Not sure you will get totally even handed responses here. Have a look on mclarenlife.com. Most of the people there own or have driven them.

AndrewD

7,659 posts

315 months

Saturday 13th July 2013
quotequote all
andrew said:
fast but boring
hth
+1

Isn't the facelift due soon too? More fun burning £20 notes imo

propaganda

407 posts

278 months

Saturday 13th July 2013
quotequote all
I rest my case...

AndrewD

7,659 posts

315 months

Saturday 13th July 2013
quotequote all
propaganda said:
I rest my case...
  • shrug*
I can't speak for anybody else. I've driven a McL. If I'd found it exciting I'd have bought one. I'm not sure what your "case" is

isaldiri

25,281 posts

199 months

Saturday 13th July 2013
quotequote all
Well...as with any car, go for a proper extended test drive. Some think the car is boring...all i can say is that all the owners of the 12c I know could have bought a 458 and in some cases had/have one but chose the 12c. Read what you will into that.

BoxerF50

1,603 posts

222 months

Saturday 13th July 2013
quotequote all
12C is a great car. Had one for several months now.

pb1695

390 posts

207 months

Saturday 13th July 2013
quotequote all
The approach taken by McLaren with the MP4 is very different from Ferrari. When you drive the two cars back to back, this is very evident.

McLaren have designed and built a car that is probably as technically near perfect as is currently possible. There is no roll in corners, and the speed that can be carried through a corner is immense. Acceleration is simply staggering - the 458 cannot hold a candle to it. Braking is magnificent, almost as much fun as accelerating, I have never been in a road car that can stop as quickly or in a perfectly controlled way.

Power delivery is a little lumpy, even since the upgrades. In a typical turbocharged manner, there is a hesitancy and flat area up to around 3k revs. Sometime after slowing and allowing the revs to drop and then trying to pick up speed again, the car hesitates before suddenly picking up and firing forwards. Matching revs and speed, especially for tighter corners is important as it can be easy to get caught out and end up with a large amount of unexpected oversteer as the power suddenly hits the rear. Delivery seems much better if the setting for power is left in Track mode.

Steering is extraordinarily sharp, lacking in feedback but quick to turn in and well weighted. The feel through the chassis is good although it does not give you the "fizz" as it feels slightly aloof with the sense that the car is controlling events as much as the driver. In terms of settings, I normally leave ours in Sport mode with active aero on. Track mode is not necessary on the road!

With a near perfect seating position, well placed pedals and simple ergonomics, the driving environment is great. The interior looks fantastic, however the electronics - in ours at least - are somewhat frustrating! The sat nav - now working, is as good as useless, the touch screen interface is laggy and sometimes freezes, and we have ongoing issues with error messages - electronic handbrake being a regular. Also, the amount of creaking and groaning from the dash is annoying (currently being investigated).

Reliability wise, ours started as a nightmare but is improving. We are on first name terms with the service team at the dealer and McLaren assist! Hopefully, after the visit next week, it will come back and not have to return until the next service.

Comparisons to the 458 to determine which is best are to some extent pointless. The character of each is very different and it is probably more down to personal taste.

In my opinion, the 458, although slower, has a much better power delivery - very smooth, linear and easy to modulate. The sound of the V8 at 7 to 9k revs is simply intoxicating. The steering is exceptional, not only is turn is sharp, the feel is simply perfect - with every bit of information about the road being fed back, but not so much that you are overloaded.

Chassis balance is also exceptional, whilst it cannot corner as quickly as the McLaren, the feeling of loading of each tyre is well judged, and you feel a greater sense of achievement when you string together a great section of road and do it well.

Braking is very good, not as good as the McLaren - sometimes there is a lack of bite even when the brakes are warmed, and stopping power is ultimately much lower than the MP4. Pedal feel is very good though.

Interior wise, with race seats and a helping of carbon, it feels special. The indicators on the steering are initially frustrating, but, as with lights and wiper controls, you soon get used to them. Other controls are typically italian, with no thoughts as to ergonomics etc. The sat nag, although fiddly, does however work!

In terms of reliability, our first 458 (early car) had numerous issues. Our new one however is significantly better built and so far has not had any issues.

The McLaren is the car I would take on the days when I want to have the ultimate guided missile, but also have a long drive to complete. It is better, but takes itself a bit too seriously. The 458 is the one I would choose for the early Sunday morning blast as it is more fun and gives a greater sense of achievement.

Before you decide, also try the SLS - excellent build, reliability, amazing noise, ridiculously fast and FUN in a wayward kind of way!



Edited by pb1695 on Saturday 13th July 09:03

LukeyLikey

855 posts

178 months

Saturday 13th July 2013
quotequote all
jackal said:
I was looking round the p1 today. Mclaren seem to be manufacturing cars in a completely different way to anyone else. Its as if you are looking at the future.
Ahhh, something I agree with you about!

I haven't driven one yet but I have read up and have spoken to owners a fair bit (two I have spoken to loved it). I think this might be a case like the 964RS. The press and public disliked the car at launch but eventually the market moved towards it. Now, every supercar manufacturer does lightweight road/track specials.

Perhaps the MP4's will be a story like this. The 964RS is not the best of the breed but it is a 'great'. The MP4's carbon tech, chassis layout (no LSD, wheels only connected by computer etc.), composure and all-situations effectiveness plus a turbo engine designed to be appropriate for a supercar is the blueprint for the future?

The only question for me is how much the MP4 seems to divide opinion, even among journalists. Everyone admires it but many say it is boring. The Spider fares better and with the carbon chassis there seems to be no reason not to choose the Spider IMO.

Perhaps in the end it comes down to what you want it for - to add to other cars, definite 'tick', to try for a while, also 'tick', to run as an only supercar/toy over a long period, big 'question mark'.

LukeyLikey

855 posts

178 months

Saturday 13th July 2013
quotequote all
reedman said:
Just out of interest, since there has been a lot of Stradale discussion recently, care to elaborate on your sale? (Reasons? Did you sell to a dealer or privately? You may be reluctant to mention price but an indication, high or low?)

Btw, out of the Lambo and the MP4, the MP4 definitely has it in my book.

pb1695

390 posts

207 months

Saturday 13th July 2013
quotequote all
LukeyLikey said:
Just out of interest, since there has been a lot of Stradale discussion recently, care to elaborate on your sale? (Reasons? Did you sell to a dealer or privately? You may be reluctant to mention price but an indication, high or low?)

Btw, out of the Lambo and the MP4, the MP4 definitely has it in my book.
I agree, as much as I enjoy our Superleggera, it feels dated - wooden steering, lumpy chassis and dated interior (I get cramp every time I drive it due to pedal position - maybe it is an age thing). Still fun for a short time but not a car I could live with.

footsoldier

2,298 posts

223 months

Saturday 13th July 2013
quotequote all
pb1695 said:
Before you decide, also try the SLS - excellent build, reliability, amazing noise, ridiculously fast and FUN in a wayward kind of way!
This is where I ended up, after having a McLaren on order, but never quite convincing myself I really wanted one. (Stories of constant fixes, satnav, and mainly lack of a good noise...)

The SLS is the one which calls the bluff of everyone who says that super cars are too perfect now. It might not look as flash as a Ferrari or its ilk, (until you open the doors!), but this is a good thing as far as I'm concerned.

Drive one hard, especially on closed roads, and find out what your car control is like! It's no doubt far from the fastest round corners, but it has enjoyment on tap. And s relative bargain at the moment if you buy slightly-used.

R11ysf

1,968 posts

213 months

Saturday 13th July 2013
quotequote all
pb1695 said:
best comparison of 458 vs McLaren I've read
Thank you so much for this post. A properly thought out, articulate review from and experienced owner. Very helpful indeed

ETA: Bllody iphone! Just seen this had an angry face instead of a smiley!

Edited by R11ysf on Monday 15th July 08:21

magnum555

473 posts

190 months

Saturday 13th July 2013
quotequote all
Excellent post pb1695 thumbup

LongLiveTazio

2,714 posts

228 months

Saturday 13th July 2013
quotequote all
Really good, balanced post.

Surely the V12 Vantage S is worthy of consideration too, special looking/feeling car and has been significantly enhanced.