I want to treat myself but with what watch?
I want to treat myself but with what watch?
Author
Discussion

JP78

Original Poster:

69 posts

175 months

Saturday 27th July 2013
quotequote all
OK so I have been working on a big work project for the last few years and it will all be revealed on YouTube live on Monday and I now think after all the late nights and long weekends I deserve a treat!

Problem is I am struggling to decide between two or three watches so I would appreciate any thoughts.

I was deciding between a Rolex Seadweller 16600 or a Rolex Submariner 116610LN both pre owned and both around the 5k mark? I had convinced myself that although these might seem obvious choices I liked the versatility and quality and although I am not looking for investment pieces it is nice to know I shouldn't lose too much money if I need to liquidate in the future.

I thought i was dead set on one of the Rolexes but i have been offered a Panerai 359 at circa £3500 and I am slightly tempted as the Panerai offers something a bit different. I am slightly concerned that the 359 is not the one to have though as it has a different face from the more traditional Panerai faces as well as the polished case.

Any thoughts?


SVS

3,824 posts

302 months

Sunday 28th July 2013
quotequote all
You aren't into discrete watches, are you? smile


Bayleaf

2,339 posts

196 months

Sunday 28th July 2013
quotequote all
It's all personal taste etc..... But my hard earned would probably go on an Omega of some sort - planet ocean perhaps.

Rolex will definitely offer the best returns if you choose the right model. 5K will get youa lovely watch.

Happy hunting

Zigster

2,005 posts

175 months

Sunday 28th July 2013
quotequote all
A Panerai 359 at £3.5k sounds like a good deal (assuming it has all box and papers, etc). I wouldn't have thought you would have problems moving it on in the future if you didn't like it.

I know some of the hard-core Paneristi aren't fans of the numbers on the dials but I'm not sure it would put off most watch buyers. I almost bought one - looked at the 312, 359, 351 and eventually bought the 352 as I wanted the option of a bracelet as well as leather straps (rather than because I didn't like the numbers on the 359).

A Rolex is a more obvious choice - I prefer the relatively unusual Panerai.

Debaser

8,698 posts

292 months

Sunday 28th July 2013
quotequote all
I'd get the 16600, but I'm not a fan of Panerai or anything with a cyclops.

JP78

Original Poster:

69 posts

175 months

Sunday 28th July 2013
quotequote all
SVS said:
You aren't into discrete watches, are you? smile
Ah and i thought that with these choices i would be flying under the radar! I work in the motor industry and in that world these are discrete!

JP78

Original Poster:

69 posts

175 months

Sunday 28th July 2013
quotequote all
Zigster said:
A Panerai 359 at £3.5k sounds like a good deal (assuming it has all box and papers, etc). I wouldn't have thought you would have problems moving it on in the future if you didn't like it.

I know some of the hard-core Paneristi aren't fans of the numbers on the dials but I'm not sure it would put off most watch buyers. I almost bought one - looked at the 312, 359, 351 and eventually bought the 352 as I wanted the option of a bracelet as well as leather straps (rather than because I didn't like the numbers on the 359).

A Rolex is a more obvious choice - I prefer the relatively unusual Panerai.
Thanks for your thoughts. Yes the watch has the box and papers so it is a good deal but I am slightly put off by it not being a "proper" Panerai in that the face isn't the traditional face. It is a lovely looking thing although I am not sure it is a watch I could wear every day due to the size.


Voldemort

7,690 posts

309 months

Sunday 28th July 2013
quotequote all
If

JP78 said:
I am not looking for investment pieces it is nice to know I shouldn't lose too much money if I need to liquidate in the future.
is really true, get the Panerai.

chris56

1,410 posts

210 months

Sunday 28th July 2013
quotequote all
Have you tried the 359 on?
I keep trying on various version of the 1950 series Panerai as i like the look but they have all felt unbalanced on the wrist and tend to sit on it. The other problem i have found with all the 1950 leather strapped ones is that the standard strap is a bit on the short side for my wrist which 7 3/8.
The 16600 would therefore be my choice. Classic looks very comfortable on the wrist, very well made and you can wear it for any occasion with anything. As a side benefit it is also appeciating in value and will probably continue to do so. Somehwat academic as most who own one don't sell them.

JP78

Original Poster:

69 posts

175 months

Sunday 28th July 2013
quotequote all
Voldemort said:
is really true, get the Panerai.
Panerai purchased!

Can't wait to get it now, should be with me soon!

JP78

Original Poster:

69 posts

175 months

Sunday 28th July 2013
quotequote all
chris56 said:
Have you tried the 359 on?
I keep trying on various version of the 1950 series Panerai as i like the look but they have all felt unbalanced on the wrist and tend to sit on it. The other problem i have found with all the 1950 leather strapped ones is that the standard strap is a bit on the short side for my wrist which 7 3/8.
The 16600 would therefore be my choice. Classic looks very comfortable on the wrist, very well made and you can wear it for any occasion with anything. As a side benefit it is also appeciating in value and will probably continue to do so. Somehwat academic as most who own one don't sell them.
I have jus purchased without trying it on, oops!

It looks fantastic in the pictures though and I can't wait to get it.

I don't have massive wrists so there is a danger that it will look too big but I figure if I really don't get on with it I could move it on relatively easily.

I do see a 16600 in my life at some point though. I had better start saving again!!