RE: Misguided performance cars
RE: Misguided performance cars
Friday 2nd August 2013

Misguided performance cars

News of a Honda Jazz Mugen got us wondering: which performance variants should never have made production?



Honda is apparently working on a performance Mugen version of the Jazz, according to a leaked brochure out of Japan. Now the Jazz is a very component car but trying to make a hot hatch out of it just seems bizarre. You can already buy an RS version in Japan, with a racy body kit and mighty 120hp from its 1.5-litre engine.

A VXR too far maybe?
A VXR too far maybe?
That got us thinking. Which other cars should have never have been thrust into the hands of the car maker's performance division?

Special editions created to celebrate race participation is always a good one. Cars that stand out in our eyes include the Chevrolet Lacetti WTCC R+. It was impressively lifted from mundanity by race prep specialists RML, but a supercharger and a new suspension couldn't save it.

The Fiat Seicento Schumacher on the other hand was almost a very good joke, particularly with just 55hp.

People carriers don't make good performance cars. Witness the Vauxhall Meriva VXR, even though 7.5 seconds to 62mph might sound like fun.

Both Abarth and Schumacher tarnished here!
Both Abarth and Schumacher tarnished here!
At the other extreme is the six-seat Mercedes R63 AMG. Nice that it exists with its 510hp V8, but that one must have sorely tested relations within the Mercedes divisions. It's so rare we couldn't find an example in the classifieds.

We're unsure about performance SUVs as well, but admit that cars like the BMW X5M do have a market and are genuinely amusing to drive.

So what performance versions should have remained a gleam in the eye of the marketing department in your view? Tell us below and we especially want to hear from those willing to defend them. Anyone brave enough to admit to owning that Seicento Schumacher?

Author
Discussion

dukebox9reg

Original Poster:

1,722 posts

179 months

Friday 2nd August 2013
quotequote all
Only the other week in the CTR story I was asking for the high performance FIT (JAZZ) to be brought here, somebody listened. Whoop

Daihatsu YRV turbo would get my vote. Turbo old peoples car with a 4 spd auto with huge TURBO graphics

DevonPaul

1,762 posts

168 months

Friday 2nd August 2013
quotequote all
I'm not sure what the target market is for a Mugen Jazz, unless Honda relxx their requirement for you to produce "proof of retirement" before selling you the tuned version.

RobM77

35,349 posts

265 months

Friday 2nd August 2013
quotequote all
Why's it odd to have a performance Jazz? Many other hatches like it have performance versions, and Honda have a very good reputation.

KaraK

13,892 posts

240 months

Friday 2nd August 2013
quotequote all
I've actually driven a Meriva VXR and whilst I fully agree it was a remarkably pointless thing to have in the product range it actually didn't drive that badly all things considered.

Accumul8

427 posts

194 months

Friday 2nd August 2013
quotequote all
RobM77 said:
Why's it odd to have a performance Jazz? Many other hatches like it have performance versions, and Honda have a very good reputation.
Because Honda Jazz's are generally driven by old people who drive at 40mph everywhere, be it in a 30, 40 or 60mph zone. But it's the old people bit that is the main reason.

ultrastapler

246 posts

186 months

Friday 2nd August 2013
quotequote all
"Now the Jazz is a very component car but trying to make a hot hatch out of it just seems bizarre"


really?

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=c-9-xhi_wZw
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Nbmb-m8JCMg

olderbutnotwiser

38 posts

160 months

Friday 2nd August 2013
quotequote all
Toyota corolla T Sport in pensioner gold ?



moskvich427

227 posts

206 months

Friday 2nd August 2013
quotequote all

Similarly, I always thought the Mercedes A210 Evo was odd... and I've only seen 2 ever, so others clearly agree!







Mastodon2

14,346 posts

196 months

Friday 2nd August 2013
quotequote all
Making a fast Jazz makes perfect sense. No one thought the Twingo RS was a bad idea. Small cars make great bases for hot hatch fun.

mp3manager

4,254 posts

227 months

Friday 2nd August 2013
quotequote all
ultrastapler said:
"Now the Jazz is a very component car but trying to make a hot hatch out of it just seems bizarre"


really?
Wonder what they would have made of a Logo hot hatch then, if Honda had only made one?





Strange article is strange.



300bhp/ton

41,030 posts

221 months

Friday 2nd August 2013
quotequote all
Piston Heads said:
Honda is apparently working on a performance Mugen version of the Jazz, according to a leaked brochure out of Japan. Now the Jazz is a very component car but trying to make a hot hatch out of it just seems bizarre. You can already buy an RS version in Japan, with a racy body kit and mighty 120hp from its 1.5-litre engine.
Surely though, this is because we are used to the Jazz (silly name too), just being a boring non performance car. But wouldn't the same have been true of the Civic and indeed Integra? Even the mighty Golf. Did it really deserve the honoured "GT" tag?


e.g.

If someone said they wanted to make a "hot" performance version of this:


Would you have believed it would turn out to a FWD legend and a supremely iconic performance car?

Whiters

364 posts

270 months

Friday 2nd August 2013
quotequote all
The Allegro Equipe. Surely the lowest point of any so-called performance variant.


Stinkfoot

2,245 posts

223 months

Friday 2nd August 2013
quotequote all
Whiters said:
The Allegro Equipe. Surely the lowest point of any so-called performance variant.

I think that should be saved especially since I have never seen one smile

Ozzie Osmond

21,189 posts

277 months

Friday 2nd August 2013
quotequote all
Lotus Europa (2006)

Nobody knew what it was trying to be.

....apart from expensive, that is.

trashbat

6,318 posts

184 months

Friday 2nd August 2013
quotequote all
Honda Jazz Mugen: World's Fastest 19mph

Flashmurder

38 posts

176 months

Friday 2nd August 2013
quotequote all
I had no idea that Schumacher Seicento existed. 55 bhp? That is absolute gold. Some group of incredibly well paid people must have actually at one point in time decided that it was a really good idea rotate

mikesalt

108 posts

164 months

Friday 2nd August 2013
quotequote all
"Now the Jazz is a very component car but trying to make a hot hatch out of it just seems bizarre."

Now is this one of those obscure uses of the word 'component' that is rarely seen, or is the author not very competent with a keyboard?

treetops

1,189 posts

189 months

Friday 2nd August 2013
quotequote all
The horrid Sierra becomes a Cosworth

The horrid Lancia Delta becomes an Intergrale

There's nothing wrong with a performance version or warmed over version of anything to be honest.

Its helps the manufacturer with the evolution of their performance line.

I reckon almost all petrol heads would take the warm version of a model over the bog basic.

V8 FOU

3,023 posts

178 months

Friday 2nd August 2013
quotequote all
Whiters said:
The Allegro Equipe. Surely the lowest point of any so-called performance variant.

Jeez I remember when those were new.
The local BL salesman insisted on calling them the "eqippee" oh dear.....

samoht

7,325 posts

177 months

Friday 2nd August 2013
quotequote all
Agree with the general sentiment that this article seems to come from a strange point of view.

Any car has the capacity to be made more responsive to the driver's command, and more communicative back to the driver of what is happening at the tyre/tarmac interface. More response and communication to the throttle, the steering, and brakes. More 'PH-ness', in other words.

I genuinely can't imagine any car where this would be a bad thing.