Clunk noise when "aggressively" changing direction
Clunk noise when "aggressively" changing direction
Author
Discussion

DanielJames

Original Poster:

7,543 posts

199 months

Thursday 8th August 2013
quotequote all
Morning all

I've recently fitted coilovers again on the Integra, but what I've noticed now is, when turning hard into a corner on less than perfect tarmac, I'll get hear a clunk from the front of the car, which usually then almost clunks back into place after going straight.

I got under the car last night, and all bushes seem fine, coilovers are fitted correctly, but what I noticed was that the springs weren't under any pre load whilst the car was in the air. I did have a theory that perhaps the springs were coming unseated, and that the noise I heard was the spring banging back into place (it is quite a loud clunk so plausible). I placed both front springs under some load by winding up the coilovers and went for a drive this morning.

Everything seemed fine, until I really went for it to test, and there the noise was again. Clunk... and bang back into place.

Obviously the integras have a pretty complicated suspension setup, but the only thing I've changed is the shockers, so its a bit lower now. Any ideas? Or could it still be the spring?

Dan

kambites

71,747 posts

252 months

Thursday 8th August 2013
quotequote all
Is it coming from the loaded or unloaded side of the suspension? Or can't you tell?

DanielJames

Original Poster:

7,543 posts

199 months

Thursday 8th August 2013
quotequote all
Its hard to tell

I want to say unloaded but can't say for certain, will find out on my drive home.

Can you give me the possible scenario for both?

motorhole

692 posts

251 months

Thursday 8th August 2013
quotequote all
I'd imagine if the spring isn't on the spring seat when the shock is unloaded, the ride height is set very low? This means that the CV joints may be operating outside of their design envelope with respect to maximum deflection at full compression and/or significant steering lock. This could be the source of the knock and if left unattended, could quickly result in excessively worn CV joints. Raise the ride height until the spring is under some tension when unloaded and see if it makes a difference.

Edit: apologies, just re-read your post and see you've already tried this.

The other potential source may be top mounts. Are this still standard top mounts? Did you replace them when the coilovers were fitted? Lowered and/or stiffer suspension can very quickly kill old top mounts. Ideally, rose-jointed solid mounts are the way forward, but ride quality will be compromised.

Edited by motorhole on Thursday 8th August 16:32

Liokault

2,837 posts

245 months

Thursday 8th August 2013
quotequote all
Had similar on my old MX5, turned out to be the exhaust hitting the body under cornering G forces.

Mermaid

21,492 posts

202 months

Thursday 8th August 2013
quotequote all
motorhole said:
The other potential source may be top mounts. Are this still standard top mounts? Did you replace them when the coilovers were fitted? Lowered and/or stiffer suspension can very quickly kill old top mounts.
I have experienced that before - noise comes in just as rear gets lighter, and disappears under load.

anonymous-user

85 months

Thursday 8th August 2013
quotequote all
If you now have ball joints instead of rubber compliance joints (i.e. like in the top mounts) any play what so ever will cause a knocking noise! Have you checked the road springs don't go coil bound before the bump stops operate, or that at full droop the "top out" stops operate correctly (if fitted). Also check ARB mounts and drop links too!

DanielJames

Original Poster:

7,543 posts

199 months

Friday 9th August 2013
quotequote all
Okay I had another check last night and I'm going to replace the drop links and track rod ends and see where that leaves me

I tried to slacken a drop link off for inspection and this is how it left the car



You're supposed to be able to stick a 5mm allen key into the thread and wind the nut off, this had seized good and proper.

Jimmyarm

1,962 posts

209 months

Friday 9th August 2013
quotequote all
They all do that when removing them if the links are a few years old smile

Play in the link would normally present itself as a knock everytime you went over a bump rather than what you are describing.

How friendly are you with your MOT guy ? It's probably worth bunging them £20 or so to get him to put it on the shaker plates and see if that shows anything up.

Edited by Jimmyarm on Friday 9th August 08:46

DanielJames

Original Poster:

7,543 posts

199 months

Friday 9th August 2013
quotequote all
Well I've just ordered some new track rod ends and drop links, there is no way i'm going to germany with a car that has nocking suspension

While its getting tracked on saturday we'll check for more knackered bushes

Krikkit

27,943 posts

212 months

Friday 9th August 2013
quotequote all
I was about to suggest ARB components, particularly when it only happens during aggressive cornering.

DanielJames

Original Poster:

7,543 posts

199 months

Friday 9th August 2013
quotequote all
Krikkit said:
I was about to suggest ARB components, particularly when it only happens during aggressive cornering.
Yeah most people I've spoken to suggest this

Was going to order some hardrace off ebay, but heard bad things about the quality of them, so gone for some patents from the local auto factor

Hope it cures it!

DanielJames

Original Poster:

7,543 posts

199 months

Monday 12th August 2013
quotequote all
It was the ARB droplinks smile

But now I've got to order new coilovers! Going for some racinglogic monotubes to replace the buddyclubs.


lescombes

968 posts

241 months

Monday 12th August 2013
quotequote all
Just seen this....yer I know.... I was going to suggest the Drop Links... seems to be the first start place for me these days when a car comes in with a clunk or knock... Had a C3 Citroen in last week with same symptoms... bottom joint of the link was sloppy. This way the roads are really really st and speed humps everywhere.. which both kill the Drop Links...