Replacing my car.. what do you suggest?
Replacing my car.. what do you suggest?
Author
Discussion

4PPLEP1E

Original Poster:

153 posts

161 months

Thursday 8th August 2013
quotequote all
Hi all.

Firstly I would like to say I have been lurking on PH for a while, and even joined a while back but really, this is my first post. smile
And I must apologise that it is invariably a "what shall i get" thread.

Now I've currently got an RX-8 which I think is great. I've had it for about 7 or 8 months now. Normally had another car for daily commuting but due to a change of circumstances that has now gone, and I am left with the RX. As I'm currently a student (on a lowish wage job) you can imagine I don't have much to spare, and I get about 14mpg around town and 26 on the motorway if I drive super carefully. I'm therefore unable to run this every day as I would be spending too much money on fuel so it is time to get something else.

Looking at RWDs only, that are at least ok on fuel, and relatively well equipped. I will be using this as an everyday car for at least 6 months I imagine. Having considered everything, I'm so far leaning towards a mk3 MX-5. I've got a budget of around £4500 +/- a few hundred quid. I've seen a few 2.0 Sport models hovering around that price so it seems ideal. S2000 is very tempting, as I thought it was fantastic when I drove one but barely much better on fuel than the RX-8. Similarly story for a 350Z.

Is there anything you guys think could be an alternative to the MX-5? Sorry for the long post, and thanks. smile

DervVW

2,223 posts

170 months

Thursday 8th August 2013
quotequote all
mx5
mr2
s2000

usual suspects covered?

whp1983

1,415 posts

170 months

Thursday 8th August 2013
quotequote all
E46 330 coupe

4PPLEP1E

Original Poster:

153 posts

161 months

Saturday 10th August 2013
quotequote all
whp1983 said:
E46 330 coupe
It is something to consider but the E46 never really appealed to me visually. Still, I've seen a nice one and I may go look at it in a couple of days. What else is there? Seems like not much to me. Or perhaps I'm just narrowing down my options too much. R33 GTS-T is another option, but what is the fuel economy on that like? Not too good either I take it.

ILoveMondeo

9,617 posts

257 months

Saturday 10th August 2013
quotequote all
If you drive the S2000 sedately you'll get 35mpg.

Use VTEC lots and it'll nosedive to early 20's.

The GF does 300 miles a week for a tank and a bit.

I get to the shops and back and use half a tank. smile

Get an S2k... they really are a hoot. Drive carefully for the daily grind and flog the little bd on the weekend for fun! smile

4PPLEP1E

Original Poster:

153 posts

161 months

Saturday 10th August 2013
quotequote all
ILoveMondeo said:
If you drive the S2000 sedately you'll get 35mpg.

Use VTEC lots and it'll nosedive to early 20's.

The GF does 300 miles a week for a tank and a bit.

I get to the shops and back and use half a tank. smile

Get an S2k... they really are a hoot. Drive carefully for the daily grind and flog the little bd on the weekend for fun! smile
35mpg? wow.. might look into mpg a bit more, possibly the owners club? 350Zs are tempting though. Sound quite nice I think. frown

DanielSan

20,118 posts

198 months

Saturday 10th August 2013
quotequote all
A 350 will be a tiny bit better at best than the RX8 on fuel. My s2000 is easily doing low 30's and I don't do that many long journeys other than if I'm going for a hoon. Biggest issue with the s2000 will be insurance. I'm 27, 5 yrs NCB in a good post code and I'm paying £670 with all mods declared (insurance charges no extra for mods aslong as its kept below 350bhp)

But to put that into perspective I can insure a 400bhp Evo for a touch less.

Raize

1,476 posts

210 months

Saturday 10th August 2013
quotequote all
944

ILoveMondeo

9,617 posts

257 months

Saturday 10th August 2013
quotequote all
4PPLEP1E said:
35mpg? wow.. might look into mpg a bit more, possibly the owners club? 350Zs are tempting though. Sound quite nice I think. frown
You'll need to drive like a saint to average that though! But that's roughly what the GF gets doing a 60 mile a day round trip to work. 20mpg is far easier to achieve because that vtec is very addictive.

350z is probably a fair bit quicker if you've got the need for speed though. A proper performance bargain by all accounts.

I just love the convertible thing too much, wouldn't want to be without one.


Axionknight

8,505 posts

166 months

Saturday 10th August 2013
quotequote all
You'd have to drive like a proper saint to get 35mpg average from an S2000, lol. I had one for six months as a weekend toy (diesel clio as a daily commuter), on a good blast it'd return 20mpg...... Then I got cocky in the wet and crashed it, be warned biggrin

HaloGen8

1,413 posts

160 months

Saturday 10th August 2013
quotequote all
300ZX?

Supra?

ILoveMondeo

9,617 posts

257 months

Saturday 10th August 2013
quotequote all
HaloGen8 said:
300ZX?

Supra?
Can't speak for the supra but the zx gets early 20a at best.

Loved mine though. Cost a small fortune to run.

4PPLEP1E

Original Poster:

153 posts

161 months

Saturday 10th August 2013
quotequote all
Thanks for the input guys. Supra seems tempting, some are hovering around the 5k mark, although I'm not too sure on their condition, but I doubt it is that much better on fuel. 300ZX the same. frown

I'm only 21 with 2yr NCB and S2000 is about 1500 to insure, which i don't think is too bad considering my age and all. The 350Z seems to come up at about 1700 though :/ I've tried both and prefered the S2000 too. Sort of want a convertible anyway. I already drive like an old lady and barely get 20-21 mpg combined frown

330 does seem tempting but how good is it for sideways silliness without an LSD? Never really had a chance to do that stuff with one, can't drive like that on public roads during a test drive after all. I'm sure the S2000 is still a better track car though, I've been a couple of times and would be going again.

Edited by 4PPLEP1E on Saturday 10th August 23:02


Edited by 4PPLEP1E on Saturday 10th August 23:04

ILoveMondeo

9,617 posts

257 months

Saturday 10th August 2013
quotequote all
S2k would be fairly inexpensive for track day duties, pads and disks are reasonably priced and the tyres aren't hugely expensive.

Budget for a litre of decent oil every 1000-1500 miles. They like to drink a bit!