What would you pick?
Discussion
A bit of a "What Car" really....
I'm *finally* at an age when insurance is becoming more "affordable". Licence held for 5 years, no accidents, 1 year no claims, almost 23 years old, no points on licence.
I'm in the market for a "hot hatch" of some kind, but it's difficult to know which to pick.
My budget would be around £5500 - ideally wouldn't like to exceed this.
Would be nice to get something on 07 plate or newer.
Mileage - not too much of an issue, but the lower the better, around the 60k mark ideally, not much higher.
Clio 197 - approx £5500 (top of my list)
Fiesta ST - approx £4500 (might be a little too tame and I'll get bored quickly)
Meganne 225 - approx £4500
Astra VXR - approx £6000
Of the list above, obviously the Fiesta ST is the cheapest option to insure, run, etc etc.
But how do the rest fare up? Are some considerably more expensive to run than others?
I need something that's going to need not too much work, is reliable, generally won't cause me much hassle or cost the earth to maintain and run. My daily commute is 5 miles each way, with occasional longer trips away every now and again, so fuel isn't of much concern.
What would you do? Are there any that I have missed?
I've considered a Focus ST, and a Civic Type-R - however insurance isn't so friendly on these so I've discounted them.
My current daily drive is a very boring 1.6 Ford Focus. Although a nice comfortable drive, it's just not everything I want it to be
I'm *finally* at an age when insurance is becoming more "affordable". Licence held for 5 years, no accidents, 1 year no claims, almost 23 years old, no points on licence.
I'm in the market for a "hot hatch" of some kind, but it's difficult to know which to pick.
My budget would be around £5500 - ideally wouldn't like to exceed this.
Would be nice to get something on 07 plate or newer.
Mileage - not too much of an issue, but the lower the better, around the 60k mark ideally, not much higher.
Clio 197 - approx £5500 (top of my list)
Fiesta ST - approx £4500 (might be a little too tame and I'll get bored quickly)
Meganne 225 - approx £4500
Astra VXR - approx £6000
Of the list above, obviously the Fiesta ST is the cheapest option to insure, run, etc etc.
But how do the rest fare up? Are some considerably more expensive to run than others?
I need something that's going to need not too much work, is reliable, generally won't cause me much hassle or cost the earth to maintain and run. My daily commute is 5 miles each way, with occasional longer trips away every now and again, so fuel isn't of much concern.
What would you do? Are there any that I have missed?
I've considered a Focus ST, and a Civic Type-R - however insurance isn't so friendly on these so I've discounted them.
My current daily drive is a very boring 1.6 Ford Focus. Although a nice comfortable drive, it's just not everything I want it to be

Krikkit said:
For 5 miles/day I'd think about a Clio Cup and a decent bicycle. Or a really cheap shed to potter to work and back in.
Cycling to work isn't an option, I'm too comfortable in my car with heater, aircon, radio to even want to consider a bicycle :P Girlfriends house is just over 7 miles each way too, regularly make this trip up to 2-3 times per week. Average annual mileage approx 8k
5 miles?
Why oh why are you getting a hatchback?!
Get some comfortable walking shoes and a sportscar. I wish I lived within 5 miles of my workplace!
Serious answer, I'd love a Fiesta ST. I've had faster cars, but this seems 'well rounded'. A turbocharged car might throw up bigger bills once it starts getting a bit leggy, and you can't really beat a hoon in a NA car.
But seriously, you should be walking...
Why oh why are you getting a hatchback?!
Get some comfortable walking shoes and a sportscar. I wish I lived within 5 miles of my workplace!
Serious answer, I'd love a Fiesta ST. I've had faster cars, but this seems 'well rounded'. A turbocharged car might throw up bigger bills once it starts getting a bit leggy, and you can't really beat a hoon in a NA car.
But seriously, you should be walking...
I always liked the Meganne 225 (real world performance, similar to my old DC2 ITR as once proven). However at those prices, what’s the mileage and history like?
Anything relatively oldish now, French and remotely performance is slightly off-putting.
Speaking of Honda’s – how much can you pick DC5’s up for now? They must be close to being within budget and would be more fun, different and reliable than the ones you’ve mentioned.
Anything relatively oldish now, French and remotely performance is slightly off-putting.
Speaking of Honda’s – how much can you pick DC5’s up for now? They must be close to being within budget and would be more fun, different and reliable than the ones you’ve mentioned.
Not an 07 plate but maybe still worth a look at these.
http://www.pistonheads.com/classifieds/used-cars/s...
http://www.pistonheads.com/classifieds/used-cars/s...
C.A.R. said:
But seriously, you should be walking...
Well, if I elaborate a little more on the mileage...The trip to work is 5 miles, at lunch I generally pop to the nearest supermarket to grab some lunch with work colleagues, we usually take turns driving and that's a couple of miles each way too.
After work I go to the gym on my way home, this is another 5 miles to the gym, plus another few to get back home after.
I make regular 7 mile trips to the GF's each week and we're often out and about at weekends.
Walking/public transport isn't an available option for work, it's just not viable.
boobles said:
Not an 07 plate but maybe still worth a look at these.
http://www.pistonheads.com/classifieds/used-cars/s...
I had actually taken a look at the Leon 2.0T FSi FR - not quite a Cupra, but I don't think I could afford the extra costs of the Cupra. The FR seem's like it could be a good buy though. 200bhp as standard. http://www.pistonheads.com/classifieds/used-cars/s...
C.A.R. said:
5 miles?
Why oh why are you getting a hatchback?!
Get some comfortable walking shoes and a sportscar. I wish I lived within 5 miles of my workplace!
Serious answer, I'd love a Fiesta ST. I've had faster cars, but this seems 'well rounded'. A turbocharged car might throw up bigger bills once it starts getting a bit leggy, and you can't really beat a hoon in a NA car.
But seriously, you should be walking...
This.Why oh why are you getting a hatchback?!
Get some comfortable walking shoes and a sportscar. I wish I lived within 5 miles of my workplace!
Serious answer, I'd love a Fiesta ST. I've had faster cars, but this seems 'well rounded'. A turbocharged car might throw up bigger bills once it starts getting a bit leggy, and you can't really beat a hoon in a NA car.
But seriously, you should be walking...
Get something more interesting.
All of the cars you've suggested will depreciate like mad, and while I'm sure I'll be flamed for saying it, but if you want something that doesn't require constant repairs or maintenance, forget the Renaults in my experience, they are not well made cars - mine were a constant source of hassle.
I'd be looking at a sports car that has done most of its depreciation.
If you have to have some practicality, then I'd be looking at a modern classic like a DC2 Integra Type-R, a Ford Racing Puma or a Focus Mk1 RS, all will be better to drive than any of the cars you have listed and you won't lose much (if any) money on them when you eventually decide to move them on.
TameRacingDriver said:
All of the cars you've suggested will depreciate like mad
I'd be looking at a sports car that has done most of its depreciation.
If you have to have some practicality, then I'd be looking at a modern classic like a DC2 Integra Type-R, a Ford Racing Puma or a Focus Mk1 RS
Surely the depreciation won't be any more than what my Ford Focus is already depreciating though? At least that's how I worked it out.I'd be looking at a sports car that has done most of its depreciation.
If you have to have some practicality, then I'd be looking at a modern classic like a DC2 Integra Type-R, a Ford Racing Puma or a Focus Mk1 RS
I'm confident insurance on these will still be an issue. The list i mentioned in my OP was already rocking between the £700-900 mark, and i flat out refuse to spend more than £1000 on insurance.
CallorFold said:
I had actually taken a look at the Leon 2.0T FSi FR - not quite a Cupra, but I don't think I could afford the extra costs of the Cupra. The FR seem's like it could be a good buy though. 200bhp as standard.
I had the standard 180bhp cupra & it was great. Very cheap to buy compared to the cupra R.This was mine.
http://i88.photobucket.com/albums/k174/boobles30/2...
Edited by boobles on Friday 9th August 11:43
Out of what you've whittled it down to I'd personally have the Ford, although on all the ST's I looked at they all had the really tacky looking dash that "matched" the colour of the car. Also a mate has one and he says it guzzles fuel but given your limited mileage this might not be such an issue.
However if I was at the 5.5k mark I'd be looking to either wait and save up or take out finance for a year or so and get a decent Golf/ A3.
Also out of the list the Ford will probably cost less to maintain and depreciate less.
However if I was at the 5.5k mark I'd be looking to either wait and save up or take out finance for a year or so and get a decent Golf/ A3.
Also out of the list the Ford will probably cost less to maintain and depreciate less.
Edited by dave7692 on Friday 9th August 11:39
doogz said:
Really, you'd walk 5 miles each way, every day?
f
k that. That's an hour and a half, more or less, each way at average walking speed. 3 hours of your day, every day?
Maybe I just value my time a lot more than you do?
Someone who talks sense f
k that. That's an hour and a half, more or less, each way at average walking speed. 3 hours of your day, every day? Maybe I just value my time a lot more than you do?

Cycling would be an option, but with the added hassle of cycling to the gym, carrying a laptop and gym gear etc....it just wouldn't work. I'm more than happy to drive and certainly wouldn't consider anything other than a car

RobM77 said:
Clio for me, although I'd have more fun in an mk3 MR2 for that money. Years ago I had a similar choice between a 106 GTi and an MR2, and as good as the 106 was, FWD felt very two dimensional compared to the RWD MR2. I never regretted the decision.
I need the boot space and 4+ seats unfortunately. Practicality of a 2 seater would be an issue 
Gassing Station | General Gassing | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


