Cheap, reliable, go anywhere?
Cheap, reliable, go anywhere?
Author
Discussion

Dazed & Confused

Original Poster:

209 posts

235 months

Friday 9th August 2013
quotequote all
Hi,

I'm going to have to go all 'What Car' on you.

A close friend has had a sudden change of circumstances and needs to get a do everything vehicle. They've asked me to help find one this weekend, but I'm not really knowledgeable on 4x4s. I don't have time to do loads of research, and I know that you guys know your stuff.

They have some pretty specific requirements:

Genuine off-road ability (farm).
£6k budget (flexible, depending on running costs).
Low running costs - both fuel and servicing/reliability.
Big/safe enough for family and luggage, but without being too massive.
Okay in city and on motorway commute.

Basically I need to find them one car to do everything!rolleyes

The ones that have come to mind:

Fiat Panda 4x4 - too small and probably tiring on motorway.

Subaru Forester - petrol only - to pricey to run/tax.

Landrover Defender - to agricultural for everyday?

Mitsubishi Shogun - too pricey on fuel/tax/servicing?

Landrover Discovey - too unreliable.


I think that I'm looking for a larger, more refined Panda! Any ideas?

Thanks!

speed_monkey

3,503 posts

220 months

Friday 9th August 2013
quotequote all
Range rover?

Tophatron

484 posts

252 months

Friday 9th August 2013
quotequote all
I'd spend 3-4k on a Grand Cherokee CRD or V8 with LPG.

Krikkit

27,943 posts

212 months

Friday 9th August 2013
quotequote all
Ugh, tricky. Subaru Forester would be a good bet, they're not the last word in refinement, but the non-turbo is especially hardy. All those requirements, something's got to give for the budget.

Dazed & Confused

Original Poster:

209 posts

235 months

Friday 9th August 2013
quotequote all
speed_monkey said:
Range rover?
I was under the impression that the older ones broke down a lot?

AmitG

3,572 posts

191 months

Friday 9th August 2013
quotequote all
How about a Jeep Grand Cherokee? Ticks the boxes above and you probably get more for your money compared to a Range Rover.


Dazed & Confused

Original Poster:

209 posts

235 months

Friday 9th August 2013
quotequote all
Tophatron said:
I'd spend 3-4k on a Grand Cherokee CRD or V8 with LPG.
LPG - good thought. That could be an option.

dirty_dog

676 posts

207 months

Friday 9th August 2013
quotequote all
Something like a 3rd gen Hilux Surf ? Not the best on fuel but good everywhere else.

Dazed & Confused

Original Poster:

209 posts

235 months

Friday 9th August 2013
quotequote all
AmitG said:
How about a Jeep Grand Cherokee? Ticks the boxes above and you probably get more for your money compared to a Range Rover.
2 votes for Grand Cherokee! I'll definitely put it forward.

dave7692

683 posts

160 months

Friday 9th August 2013
quotequote all
I'd be careful with the Shogun, my parents has the 2.5l TDI and they ending up having to refurbish the turbo and replace the injectors.

Apparently its a common problem with those engines.

Dazed & Confused

Original Poster:

209 posts

235 months

Friday 9th August 2013
quotequote all
Krikkit said:
Ugh, tricky. Subaru Forester would be a good bet, they're not the last word in refinement, but the non-turbo is especially hardy. All those requirements, something's got to give for the budget.
I think they'll be refined enough. They had an Impreza Wagon once, so they'll know what to expect.

It's the running costs of one that concern me - drinking fuel?

As you say, though - something has to give.

Edited by Dazed & Confused on Friday 9th August 12:43

ewenm

28,506 posts

276 months

Friday 9th August 2013
quotequote all
I thought a Landcruiser was the standard option for this sort of requirement. Is it too big though?

Dazed & Confused

Original Poster:

209 posts

235 months

Friday 9th August 2013
quotequote all
ewenm said:
I thought a Landcruiser was the standard option for this sort of requirement. Is it too big though?
Yeah, the size is my main concern for when they take it on the school run.

Hilux Surf - a possibility.

Grand Cherokee - a lot of car for the money, it seems! £3.5k seems to bring up quite a few, leaving plenty left for fuel and tax. Reliable? If so, I think that's the frontrunner.

Thanks everyone - would never have thought to go American!

Edited by Dazed & Confused on Friday 9th August 12:43

dave7692

683 posts

160 months

Friday 9th August 2013
quotequote all
[quote=Dazed & Confused]

Yeah, the size is my main concern for when they take it on the school run.

Hilux Surf - a possibility.

Grand Cherokee - a lot of car for the money, it seems! Plenty left for fuel and tax. Reliable? If so, I think that's the frontrunner.
[/quote]
A guy that works for my Dad has a Grand Cherokee bought it second hand about 3 years ago and hasn't had any problems with it, it had been well looked after beforehand though with quite low mileage.

trashbat

6,318 posts

184 months

Friday 9th August 2013
quotequote all
Not driven one, but I've heard good things about the Panda for long distance travel - wind noise a complaint, but otherwise a comfortable ride. It's rated highly for its off-road capability, and it's put together well.

Dazed & Confused

Original Poster:

209 posts

235 months

Friday 9th August 2013
quotequote all
trashbat said:
Not driven one, but I've heard good things about the Panda for long distance travel - wind noise a complaint, but otherwise a comfortable ride. It's rated highly for its off-road capability, and it's put together well.
Yeah - if the boot was a foot longer that's what I'd recommend. I think they're great little cars. Just too litle in this cae....

Wigeon Incognito

3,274 posts

249 months

Friday 9th August 2013
quotequote all
ewenm said:
I thought a Landcruiser was the standard option for this sort of requirement. Is it too big though?
If the full fat Land Cruiser 80/Amazon is too big then that's what the smaller Colorado is for. You can even buy a short wheelbase version.

Dazed & Confused

Original Poster:

209 posts

235 months

Friday 9th August 2013
quotequote all
dave7692 said:
A guy that works for my Dad has a Grand Cherokee bought it second hand about 3 years ago and hasn't had any problems with it.
That's exactly what I wanted to hear.

There's some 100k-ish auto diesels near them for £3-4k, so I'll suggest they go see one of those first.

Look very promising, and I can imagine it in all the roles they'll need it for.

Thanks everyone for your help - really appreciated!

chippy17

3,740 posts

274 months

Friday 9th August 2013
quotequote all
[quote=Dazed & Confused]
Krikkit said:
Ugh, tricky. Subaru Forester would be a good bet, they're not the last word in refinement, but the non-turbo is especially hardy. All those requirements, something's got to give for the budget.
I think they'll be refined enough. They had an Impreza Wagon once, so they'll know what to expect.

It's the running costs of one that concern me - drinking fuel?

As you say, though - something has to give.

Edited by Dazed & Confused on Friday 9th August 12:43
I have a 2.0X 55 plate and it is a great car, yes not refined like a Merc etc but very comfy seats, good ride and with the Winter pack you get a fab sunroof, heated seats, mirrors, windscreen and most mod cons...

it is dog slow though but because of its personality it does not bother me and it is the family motor so not an issue, it does handle well though so you can keep momentun, used mainly on country and b road we are averaging over 30mpg, 35+ on a run and no probs other than servicing

make sure you check the self levelling rear suspension

Dazed & Confused

Original Poster:

209 posts

235 months

Friday 9th August 2013
quotequote all
Wigeon Incognito said:
If the full fat Land Cruiser 80/Amazon is too big then that's what the smaller Colorado is for.
Oh, thanks - I thought that was just trim levels. Is that also know as a Prado? I see lots of them around in 3.0 diesel form.