Contract question
Author
Discussion

Simpo Two

Original Poster:

93,123 posts

296 months

Friday 9th August 2013
quotequote all
On 12 June I placed an order with a fireplace company for a marble surround and paid a deposit of 50% by CC. The quoted leadtime was '4-5 weeks'.

The company subbed the work out to a stonemason who has somehow cocked up. He promised delivery by 4 August, but failed to do so. He said on 5 August that the work was complete and that 'someone would call about delivery', but nothing happened. When the fireplace company called him to offer to collect the goods instead, he suddenly got cross and told them that if they called him again he'd stop the delivery. WTF?

I suspect the work has not been done, but the fireplace company are afraid to call him again and whilst I have e-mailed the mason very politely, I had no reply.

The problem lies with the mason, who is either a liar or a sociopath, but my contract is with the fireplace company. Can I insist that they supply me the goods at the same price but from another mason? The problem is that the mad one quoted a very good price and I doubt anyone else can get near it. Can I force the fireplace company to supply regardless, and take a loss, or can they simply refuse and refund me instead?

rog007

5,832 posts

255 months

Saturday 10th August 2013
quotequote all
credit cards - equal liability under section 75 of the Consumer Credit Act 1974:

http://www.financial-ombudsman.org.uk/publications...

Good luck!

Simpo Two

Original Poster:

93,123 posts

296 months

Saturday 10th August 2013
quotequote all
Yep, there will be no problem getting the deposit back - but can I insist the fireplace company gets me an identical same fireplace made by another mason or not? Personally I suspect not. They are trying to find other masons but even if they can do it, the price is very likely to be higher.

therealpigdog

2,592 posts

228 months

Monday 12th August 2013
quotequote all
All depends on the wording of the contract - I'm presuming that they will seek to rely on some standard terms and conditions that limit their liability to the value of the contract (i.e. the price you paid) so all they have to do is offer a full refund.

If there aren't any terms, then the default position for breach of contract is that you can seek damages to put you in the position you would have been in had the contract been performed - therefore you could claim from the original supplier for the amount it costs to get the same product (subject always to you mitigating your losses).

Simpo Two

Original Poster:

93,123 posts

296 months

Monday 12th August 2013
quotequote all
therealpigdog said:
All depends on the wording of the contract - I'm presuming that they will seek to rely on some standard terms and conditions that limit their liability to the value of the contract (i.e. the price you paid) so all they have to do is offer a full refund.

If there aren't any terms, then the default position for breach of contract is that you can seek damages to put you in the position you would have been in had the contract been performed - therefore you could claim from the original supplier for the amount it costs to get the same product (subject always to you mitigating your losses).
Thanks - I have seen no official contract; they merely quoted a price and I accepted and paid 50% deposit. That would seem to be Part 2 of your answer, namely that I can try to find another mason who can do the work, and if they are more expensive, the fireplace company is liable for the difference. So if their quote was £1270, and can only find it for £2,000, they have to pay me £770...? Or they could buy it and deliver it but could only charge me the original quote of £1270?

therealpigdog

2,592 posts

228 months

Tuesday 13th August 2013
quotequote all
Simpo Two said:
Thanks - I have seen no official contract; they merely quoted a price and I accepted and paid 50% deposit. That would seem to be Part 2 of your answer, namely that I can try to find another mason who can do the work, and if they are more expensive, the fireplace company is liable for the difference. So if their quote was £1270, and can only find it for £2,000, they have to pay me £770...? Or they could buy it and deliver it but could only charge me the original quote of £1270?
In theory yes, but obviously getting money out of a stone mason ....

What have they said? Before you go about sorting out another mason they need to have the opportunity to sort it out for you. You may find that a set of terms and conditions suddenly materialise.

If they offer a full refund I'd probably be tempted to take it - whilst it may cost £770 more to get the job done properly it will be a lot less hassle than trying to get any money out of them. Whilst MCOL is cheap and easy, it's still time and uncertainty.

Simpo Two

Original Poster:

93,123 posts

296 months

Tuesday 13th August 2013
quotequote all
The chain is Me - Fireplace comapny - Stonemason.

My contract is with the fireplace company and there won't be any problem getting my deposit back. The problem is how to get the hearth and surround I ordered back in June. Even the mason, with whom I have swapped e-mails directly about details, accepted the delivery deadline of 4 August. Now he has stopped replying to anyone.

It wouldn't be so bad but his website and blog ramble on about how great he is and how clever and wonderful he is - and he can't even deliver a simple hearth!

I said to the fireplace company 'All you need to do is supply me with what I ordered. I don't care where it comes from' - hinting that there is a contract they need to fulfil.

Simpo Two

Original Poster:

93,123 posts

296 months

Wednesday 14th August 2013
quotequote all
Well time is marching on and things will have to be resolved one way or another. The fireplace company have sent two more e-mails to the mason but both have been ignored. However they did tell me that they have paid a depoit to the mason - so they are out of pocket and could start a small claims case. After all, the mason can have a fireplace or a deposit but not both!

The fireplace company have looked for other suppliers but they want more than twice as much - almost £3,000 instead of £1,270. They have offered me my deposit back if I wish.

The question that returns is: Can I insist that they supply me with the goods as ordered, even if they have to pay £3,000 and sell for £1,270? Or not? This is not a small claims issue, it's a breach of contract issue.

Any legal bods in?

johnfm

13,752 posts

281 months

Thursday 15th August 2013
quotequote all
The legal fees you might expend on this will be more than the value of your claim.

therealpigdog

2,592 posts

228 months

Thursday 15th August 2013
quotequote all
In the absence of any terms and conditions, legally you can insist that they either supply you with the fireplace, or pay the difference.

BUT as John says, you could spend more time and money than its worth proving your case.

Plus, the stone mason is really the guy at fault, and they are innocently stuck in the middle. They will fight it.

Is it really worth it? Ok, so you've missed out on a bargain, but sounds like £3k is the fair price to pay. If it were me I'd take the deposit back and be annoyed rather than pursue any legal action.

Simpo Two

Original Poster:

93,123 posts

296 months

Thursday 15th August 2013
quotequote all
Thanks folks; I'm certainly not going to spend money on the case; I just wondered whether it's a cut and dried thing where I can say 'Deliver me a fireplace regardless' and they would have to go 'Righto guv' - or not. As you say they are unlikely to lose £1700 just to keep me happy.

I will have to consult my book on cunning to extract the goods from the mason.

Elderly

3,743 posts

269 months

Thursday 15th August 2013
quotequote all
There's a thread going in the Photography forum (you should go there sometime wink ) entitled "The future of photography?".
Out of curiosity, how did you judge the quality of the photography used by the fireplace company? biggrin

Simpo Two

Original Poster:

93,123 posts

296 months

Thursday 22nd August 2013
quotequote all
therealpigdog said:
In the absence of any terms and conditions, legally you can insist that they either supply you with the fireplace, or pay the difference.
Well there is still no news from the incompetent idiot mason, but I got another quote that came in at £1995 as opposed to £1270. I did suggest to the fireplace company that they meet me halfway on the difference but they said it 'wouldn't be possible'. I said 'yes it is, you just write a cheque and post it' but they still weren't biting.

So I shall have to pay another £735 and wait up to another 14 weeks because the mason they chose is a cock.

The issue is that if legally I can insist they provide the goods (quote above) and take a hit then they should say 'fair cop guv'. But of course they won't, they will send my deposit back and call it a day. There is such a gulf between what the law says, and what actually happens. Perhaps if the penalty was jail people might get justice, but all that happens is that solicitors grow fat.

therealpigdog

2,592 posts

228 months

Thursday 22nd August 2013
quotequote all
Simpo Two said:
therealpigdog said:
In the absence of any terms and conditions, legally you can insist that they either supply you with the fireplace, or pay the difference.
Well there is still no news from the incompetent idiot mason, but I got another quote that came in at £1995 as opposed to £1270. I did suggest to the fireplace company that they meet me halfway on the difference but they said it 'wouldn't be possible'. I said 'yes it is, you just write a cheque and post it' but they still weren't biting.

So I shall have to pay another £735 and wait up to another 14 weeks because the mason they chose is a cock.

The issue is that if legally I can insist they provide the goods (quote above) and take a hit then they should say 'fair cop guv'. But of course they won't, they will send my deposit back and call it a day. There is such a gulf between what the law says, and what actually happens. Perhaps if the penalty was jail people might get justice, but all that happens is that solicitors grow fat.
You can insist that they take the hit, trundle off to the small claims court and argue your case. If it is as stated, you will probably win and get the additional money. They will feel hard done to because they are out of pocket through no fault of their own, but could then chase the mason to cover their loss (assuming the terms of their contract with him allowed them to do so).

The question is whether it is worth the time and effort over £735 - and my opinion is/was that it isn't. Plenty of people would have chased it through the small claims though.

I won't bite at the comment about solicitors getting fat, save to remind you that you've not had to pay a penny for any of the legal advice given here wink

Simpo Two

Original Poster:

93,123 posts

296 months

Thursday 22nd August 2013
quotequote all
Fear not, all PHers are exempt from the brush of tar smile

(as ever it's the system that's at fault not the people in it)

I think the only action left to me, given that I want this damn fireplace before Christmas, is not to spend time going legal now but to look for another supplier. The local stonemanson who's a decent sort says there are other stones that look similar to Thassos so he's doing some numbers for me too. Then I'll decide the supplier and place the order, then I can decide at my leisure if I want to pursue the fireplace company retrospectively.

I don't really have the enthusiasm for a fight but it keeps the option open.

How does that sound?

johnfm

13,752 posts

281 months

Thursday 22nd August 2013
quotequote all
When a deal is too good to be true, it usually is.

It seems that the market price for what you want isn't what you were quoted.

For the sake of £700, I would just find a more reliable supplier.