£3k motorway driver - suggestions please
£3k motorway driver - suggestions please
Author
Discussion

MSJW

Original Poster:

37 posts

159 months

Friday 9th August 2013
quotequote all
I've been searching the web for the past few weeks to decide on a car to upgrade to. It seems like the most relevant, truthful info is on pistonheads, so I thought id register and ask for your advice.

I'm due to start a new job in a few weeks which will involve a 70 mile round trip each day. 90% of this will be in the motorway.

I've held my license for around 2.5 years, and have been driving a tiny Ford KA for the past 12 months. Fuel efficiency is pretty good, but on the motorway the car really needs to be pushed at 70, which doesn't make for the most comfortable journey, so I'm looking for an upgrade.

Being a pretty young driver (22), I need something which wont be ridiculous to insure. My existing policy works out £1300 a year, and having looked into Focus Zetecs, Fiestas etc. my quotes have dropped significantly to £800-900. These quotes are for 1.6 petrols. I know diesels are more efficient, but they generally have huge mileage already clocked up, and come in over budget. I've read that 1.6 Fords can be a bit of a push at 70-75mph and don't offer the best mpg at these speeds. I'm unsure if going for a bigger 2l engine car would make more sense. The insurance will be more (around what i'm paying atm), but they could offer a better drive and long term savings.

I've drifted into looking at BMW 325 compacts, as I've heard they can offer 50mpg at motorway speeds. Ideally i'd like something with around 50,000m or less on the clock that can cope with motorway speeds and offer good fuel economy.

If you have any suggestions/real life experiences with motorway cars then i'd love to hear.

Cheers,
Michael



anonymous-user

85 months

Friday 9th August 2013
quotequote all
What is your budget?

14-7

6,233 posts

222 months

Friday 9th August 2013
quotequote all
Astra 1.7 diesel? A few on auto trader at less than 3k. Cheap to run and insure.

Or, slightly bigger, a Ford Mondeo. Again a few on auto trader that are less than 3k and around 50k miles. Decent motorway cruisers as well and shouldn't be too bad to insure.

Blue Oval84

5,399 posts

192 months

Friday 9th August 2013
quotequote all
MSJW said:
I've drifted into looking at BMW 325 compacts, as I've heard they can offer 50mpg at motorway speeds. Ideally i'd like something with around 50,000m or less on the clock that can cope with motorway speeds and offer good fuel economy.
325 Compact is good for about 35mpg TOPS on the motorway in my experience of that engine (albeit in a Z4)

I drive a 2.0 Mondeo Zetec, perfectly adequate, comfy enough, and on a 350 mile drive with cruise set at 70mph my best economy was 41mpg.

nagsheadwarrior

2,789 posts

210 months

Friday 9th August 2013
quotequote all
325 Compact,50mpg,ever?

Something leftfield, 1.6 Hyundai Coupe?

Or try to catch the insurers out with an unusual car for a youngster,volvo s80 d4 maybe.

Fittster

20,120 posts

244 months

Friday 9th August 2013
quotequote all
Something with a VAG 1.9

TimS2000

453 posts

238 months

Friday 9th August 2013
quotequote all
For a motorway car at that budget, you wont find better than an s60 d5 - 40-50mpg on the motorway, and the best seats and stereo you will find in anything even close that budget. However I got rid of mine because as my only car it was far from fun in the twisties... my 330d is a lot more fun handling wise, but the comfort doesn't come close and the performance to economy ratio is worse.

Blue Oval84

5,399 posts

192 months

Friday 9th August 2013
quotequote all
TimS2000 said:
For a motorway car at that budget, you wont find better than an s60 d5 - 40-50mpg on the motorway, and the best seats and stereo you will find in anything even close that budget.
I think Tim wins the thread actually.

I don't mind my Mondeo but if I had my decision to make again it would be S60 all the way.

lbc

3,340 posts

248 months

Friday 9th August 2013
quotequote all
MSJW said:
I'm due to start a new job in a few weeks which will involve a 70 mile round trip each day. 90% of this will be in the motorway.
Look for a diesel Peugeot 306/406.

Most older petrol cars will not do more than 40mpg unless you drive like Miss Daisy.



Rammy76

1,054 posts

214 months

Friday 9th August 2013
quotequote all
MSJW said:
I've read that 1.6 Fords can be a bit of a push at 70-75mph and don't offer the best mpg at these speeds.
A 1.6 Focus will not be "pushed" at those speeds, my 1.8 never felt strained at all at even faster speeds. I would think fuel consumption will be typical of any 1.6 petrol and be reasonable at 75 mph so I wouldn't let that put you off.

I do a lot of motorway work and my Passat 1.9 PD 130 is quick enough and cruises effortlessly. It also manages an easy 50mpg. Look for one of the many cars with this engine in, and don't let high mileage put you off either, they seem pretty reliable.

MSJW

Original Poster:

37 posts

159 months

Friday 9th August 2013
quotequote all
DR10 said:
What is your budget?
£3000 tops - Thanks

14-7 said:
Astra 1.7 diesel? A few on auto trader at less than 3k. Cheap to run and insure.

Or, slightly bigger, a Ford Mondeo. Again a few on auto trader that are less than 3k and around 50k miles. Decent motorway cruisers as well and shouldn't be too bad to insure.
I've looked into Astra's, and there's potential. But finding a diesel one with low mileage is impossible.

Blue Oval84 said:
325 Compact is good for about 35mpg TOPS on the motorway in my experience of that engine (albeit in a Z4)

I drive a 2.0 Mondeo Zetec, perfectly adequate, comfy enough, and on a 350 mile drive with cruise set at 70mph my best economy was 41mpg.
Mondeo's look like a contender then - I'm not sure if they're a bit boring, I'll check them out and see if they tickle my fancy

nagsheadwarrior said:
325 Compact,50mpg,ever?

Something leftfield, 1.6 Hyundai Coupe?

Or try to catch the insurers out with an unusual car for a youngster,volvo s80 d4 maybe.
Would the Hyundai be good for 70-75 in 1.6? It looks like the nicest car of the bunch. I'd prefer something which isn't too big; as I wont be giving many people lifts I don't require a 5 door car, so something like the Coupe or a hatchback would be best.

TimS2000 said:
For a motorway car at that budget, you wont find better than an s60 d5 - 40-50mpg on the motorway, and the best seats and stereo you will find in anything even close that budget. However I got rid of mine because as my only car it was far from fun in the twisties... my 330d is a lot more fun handling wise, but the comfort doesn't come close and the performance to economy ratio is worse.
Thanks for the suggestion - it seems more than capable. I'll check out insurance quotes over the weekend and use this to wittle down your suggestions. Again, I only require the car for transporting myself, so if there are any slightly less family-orientated cars, that you would recommend then keep them coming.


Thanks to all of you for your quick replies. I'll look into each one with regards to prices, insurance etc and let you know my findings.




Blue Oval84

5,399 posts

192 months

Friday 9th August 2013
quotequote all
MSJW said:
Mondeo's look like a contender then - I'm not sure if they're a bit boring, I'll check them out and see if they tickle my fancy
They are perfectly capable (and drive very well round corners for such a large car) but they aren't "fun" unless you have a V6 smile

The S60 is by far the best car I've seen suggested, if you get an SE then it has the Dolby sound system which is awesome and the seats are the best I've ever sat in. I'm kicking myself for not buying one myself but I needed a ca quickly...

anonymous-user

85 months

Saturday 10th August 2013
quotequote all
A late VW Bora 1.9 TDI 130 (remapped, obviously).

MSJW

Original Poster:

37 posts

159 months

Saturday 10th August 2013
quotequote all
So I've looked at insurance for the Volvo and Hyundai, and they come in as follows:

Volvo S60 2.5l = £1505 Annual / £2515 Monthly
Volvo S60 2l = £1442.66 Annual / £1674 Monthly
Hyundai Coupe 2l = £935.66 Annual / £1140 Monthly

I like the look of the Hyundai, but wonder if it can compete at motorway speeds with the Volvos fuel consumption. TBH, the Volvo looks a bit big for me so if anyone has experiences with the Coupe, let me know smile

HaloGen8

1,413 posts

160 months

Saturday 10th August 2013
quotequote all
lbc said:
Look for a diesel Peugeot 306/406.

Most older petrol cars will not do more than 40mpg unless you drive like Miss Daisy.
I'd go with this. A tidy Pug 306 can be bought for peanuts and should be cheap to insure. Then spend the rest on a weekend toy to get away from the daily grind like an ageing MX5 for a bit of fun smile

MSJW

Original Poster:

37 posts

159 months

Saturday 10th August 2013
quotequote all
HaloGen8 said:
I'd go with this. A tidy Pug 306 can be bought for peanuts and should be cheap to insure. Then spend the rest on a weekend toy to get away from the daily grind like an ageing MX5 for a bit of fun smile
I wish I could afford insurance on two cars! The cheapest I've been offered is around £800 for various Fords.

It would be nice to have a niceish car as my daily driver due to the time I'll be spending in it. I'm going to look more into the Hyundai, and maybe re-consider a Focus, it does seem 40mpg with a petrol is the most I'll be getting smile

Axionknight

8,505 posts

166 months

Saturday 10th August 2013
quotequote all
If you want something cheap as chips to run buy a Renault Clio with a 1.5 dci engine, one of the higher horse power ones, it will cruise at 70mph fine enough and they are dirt cheap to run - the road tax on mine was £35/year, insurance friendly too, I bought it as a second car at 23 and it was reasonable even with 3 points on my license.

It might not have the most street cred but I ran one for 18 months when I was doing around 800 miles a week as a contractor, second car for business mileage and it was spot on.

MSJW

Original Poster:

37 posts

159 months

Saturday 10th August 2013
quotequote all
HaloGen8 said:
I'd go with this. A tidy Pug 306 can be bought for peanuts and should be cheap to insure. Then spend the rest on a weekend toy to get away from the daily grind like an ageing MX5 for a bit of fun smile
I wish I could afford insurance on two cars! The cheapest I've been offered is around £800 for various Fords.

It would be nice to have a niceish car as my daily driver due to the time I'll be spending in it. I'm going to look more into the Hyundai, and maybe re-consider a Focus, it does seem 40mpg with a petrol is the most I'll be getting smile