May have bought the wrong car....
May have bought the wrong car....
Author
Discussion

Tib

Original Poster:

458 posts

210 months

Friday 9th August 2013
quotequote all
Hi all...

I have a 2000 Boxster S. Bought it on an impulse and a modicum of research. That was about five months ago now and as things stand, I'm not vastly sure I've made the right choice...

As bizarre as this sounds, I find the car a bit too forgiving. It's a fantastic all rounder - easy to live with, decent enough on fuel, space for the luggage, all the usual credentials. I also find the car to be very accessible and pliable in terms of putting down speed; it's magnificently balanced and after driving it for five months I can't really tell where the engine is mounted by driving it. First car I've ever driven which has that property.

The problem is I'm not sure I really like this, it just feels a bit too mechanical to me, a little too refined and detached. Pretty hard to explain, but maybe some previous owners might sympathise. It seems that I'm actually more of a fan of working a car - shifting the weight around a slightly crap chassis, settling cars into corners and harboring a slight fear that I might be spat into a hedge for braking mid corner or such. I feel that the Boxster flatters the driver a little, and rather than that I'd prefer something harder to drive which requires more effort on my part. I realise the Box is a fantastic car, and I may yet keep it for years to come but I wouldn't mind the idea of people floating a few alternatives, or alternatively just being told to man up and accept that's simply how faster cars are (I've come from driving an MR-2 previously...)

Does that make sense to anyone, and if so does anyone have any ideas to throw out there? If I were to sell it I'd probably get about 7k, as it's a low mileage example in pretty decent nick, so that'd probably be my budget. I could wait a little and buy something slightly over that, should I find something that appeals mind. Having said that, I'm not too sure I could go back to anything 4 cylinder...

littleredrooster

6,417 posts

227 months

Saturday 10th August 2013
quotequote all
Right. MTFU, or go and borrow either a Daewoo Matiz or a Hyundai Getz for a couple of weeks.

I promise you that you will then appreciate the finer points of forward progress and (lack of) terminal understeer.

davepoth

29,395 posts

230 months

Saturday 10th August 2013
quotequote all
Trade it in for a Z4. Dynamically it's no match for a Boxster at all, but in your position I would have gone for the BMW. I like the feel of a big long bonnet and sitting over the back axle, and the handling balance of a front engined RWD car. There's something about it that just feels right to me.

g3org3y

22,529 posts

222 months

Saturday 10th August 2013
quotequote all
Z3 M Roadsters/Coupes in your budget? Pretty tail happy with 300+ bhp and old skool E30 rear suspension. I'd expect a tad more exciting than the Boxster.

Big Rod

6,265 posts

247 months

Saturday 10th August 2013
quotequote all
Maybe chalk and cheese but, I had a Jaguar XJR8.

I hated the 'Jagness' of it.

I bought an S class Merc of similar vintage. It's everything I hoped the Jag would be.

Go and try something different in the same class, that'll make your mind up.

Ray Luxury-Yacht

8,918 posts

247 months

Saturday 10th August 2013
quotequote all
You're not driving it hard enough.

I thought the same when I bought my 911.

Until I realised I had to re-calibrate what I previously thought was 'fast' on the road.

Once I started to take the absolute piss when I drove it, it was then a completely exciting handful, slithering around all over the gaff, the back going light under hard braking (and I mean hard - coming up to a turn / roundabout, thinking about braking...not braking...then getting scared and thinking that I REALLY SHOULD brake now...but still not braking...then counting to 3 and THEN braking...ahhh, see - it will stop in time, and the rear has now become my new best friend for a fast direction change!

Then chuck it into the turn with a light rear, which now swings around a little sideways, let off the brakes and hit the gas, using the traction to pull the car round and out of the turn, from sideways to pointing perfectly at the exit point, if I've done it right.

As mine was a Carrera 4, it was also fun (read: dangerous) to use the 4wd system for excitement around turns on roads with dodgy surfaces. Committing to a ridiculous speed around the turn, but with all the bumps and yumps making at least one wheel re-bound completely off the road surface, meant that the 4wd system was constantly making the car understeer, then oversteer, then understeer, than oversteer again - which all of which combined managed to get the car to the point where it would eventually exit the turn pointing the right way. Probably best done by starting the turn well over the centre-line so the car has enough lane width to keep getting out of shape and skitter across the lane, but not so much as it ends up in the verge / hedge by the time the exit arrives biggrin


Maybe you should try doing a track day, drive as hard as you can and maybe get the car to be out of control and even spin a few times so that you can learn the true limits. Then when next on the road, you know what you can do and get away with in order to enjoy it to it's fullest???


V8RX7

28,982 posts

294 months

Saturday 10th August 2013
quotequote all
You are far from alone.

Many modern cars are simply too good to be fun on the road unless you are willing to risk a ban every time you drive them.

That is why I still drive a supercharged MX5 despite owning many "superior" cars that have come and gone.


Fantuzzi

3,297 posts

177 months

Saturday 10th August 2013
quotequote all
Are you looking for a trickier car or a less capable car, or alternatively a more engaging car but still as capable, or more engaging but less capable?

All seem to give you what you want.

What about ticking 2/3 and buying an older mid engine car, X1/9 or mk1 MR2.

Sticking with mid engine cars, You might find an elise too 'good' if you want to play around with less than capable cars, although you wont find yourself detached by any means

Or go for something heavy with a poor chassis and a front engine layout!

NadiR

1,071 posts

178 months

Saturday 10th August 2013
quotequote all
davepoth said:
Trade it in for a Z4. Dynamically it's no match for a Boxster at all, but in your position I would have gone for the BMW. I like the feel of a big long bonnet and sitting over the back axle, and the handling balance of a front engined RWD car. There's something about it that just feels right to me.
I agree, chop the Boxster in for a Z4, or maybe even (if you could live with 4 cylinders) an S2000.

wibble cb

4,185 posts

238 months

Saturday 10th August 2013
quotequote all
I think you have to absolutely rag it to death in order to find the limit of what it (and you) are capable of, I had a Boxster years ago (the 2.7) in order to get the most enjoyment you had to hold the gears, and use the steering and brakes to make the most of the chassis. I got to the point of understanding that it was so much better than any previous car I owned, as by the time you get near its limits, most other cars will have you in a ditch (Z4 included).



I miss it a lot, but it wasn't practical to own a car 3500 miles from where I lived (let alone 2)....one day when they are far too expensive as a classic, I will no doubt try and own one then......

torres del paine

1,588 posts

252 months

Saturday 10th August 2013
quotequote all
The Z4 is a turkey compared to the Boxster. Cars like the Boxster are competent in so much as they allow you to drive faster, harder and more on the edge. I like competent cars but some people don't. Maybe ypu should try a TVR or something.

jackh707

2,132 posts

187 months

Saturday 10th August 2013
quotequote all
Try a caterham on cheap skinny road tyres.

Feel like your going x2 as fast as the porsche but actually going slower a lot of the time.

Run back to porsche open armed.

jamieduff1981

8,092 posts

171 months

Saturday 10th August 2013
quotequote all
TVR.

nagsheadwarrior

2,789 posts

210 months

Saturday 10th August 2013
quotequote all
I know exactly what you mean.

Amongst others i drive a 2.8i Capri,its noisy,slow,tail happy,lurches around on its cart springs and is generally a bit of a handfull, all of this is what makes it so good!

I had a 924s at the same time,it was quicker,quiter,more efficient and handled "better" but was knowhere near as much fun.

Horses for courses tho,some people love that Germanic competency,I just dont.

forzaminardi

2,298 posts

218 months

Saturday 10th August 2013
quotequote all
It's possibly, as others have said, an example of a car simply being 'too good', or at least having levels of power, grip and so on that they can't really be explored on a public road. I have swithered over Boxters and Caymans but am being persuaded more by the 'not so good' and 'flawed' alternatives as somehow they are more appealing.

wemorgan

3,583 posts

209 months

Saturday 10th August 2013
quotequote all
Sounds like the OP needs to test drive a Lotus Elise.

A900ss

3,314 posts

183 months

Saturday 10th August 2013
quotequote all
TVR Chimaera - although at £7k be wary of what you buy.

Good luck.

crolandc

290 posts

227 months

Saturday 10th August 2013
quotequote all
Spot on, had a 3.2s ( 03 ) for a couple of years and found it too good!! sounds mad but that is the only way i can describe it, you have to be going at silly speeds to appreciate how balanced these cars are. As some one said earlier on a tuned MX5 is far more fun or tvr, lotus perhaps.

*Al*

3,830 posts

253 months

Saturday 10th August 2013
quotequote all
Try a sportsbike, you really have to work hard. More rewarding than any car I've ever owned.

Agrilla

834 posts

214 months

Saturday 10th August 2013
quotequote all
Have you thought about an S1 Elise? You're certainly unlikely to lose much (any?) in depreciation if you decided I'm another 5 months you fancied a change.