Car purchase gone wrong!
Discussion
12 months ago I bought a low mileage 996 T from a dealer; paid a bit of a premium due to it having only 12k miles; no problem and was happy to do that.
It was a 1 owner car and apparently the last 5 years it had been unused at the back of the first owners garage. Car then acquired by Independent dealer and then I bought it from the Independent dealer.
Right then, so 2 weeks ago I sold the car and the buyer is due to collect on Monday; part of the deal was for me to put 12 month MOT on it which I did yesterday.
Last night whilst getting all the paperwork together I noticed the new MOT certificate had included 4 mileage readings from the last 4 mot's - 12500 current, 11800 from 2012, 12450(!) from 2011 and 11900 from 2010.
So it looks like it's had a haircut before I bought it. I didn't get any of the 2011, 2010, 2009, 2008 or 2007 MOT cert. when I bought it but was told it was off the road in storage and unused.
So now it appears it was not in storage and was infact being used and MOT'd each year.
I have told the new buyer (who paid in full via bank transfer) and they are spooked and want their money back. I am about to transfer it back after my coffee!
Where do I go from here? Back to the Indy I bought it from? What are my rights if they say '...that was 12 months ago, it ain't my problem so get stuffed'
I know what my natural reaction will be, but what about my legal position?
Any help appreciated...
It was a 1 owner car and apparently the last 5 years it had been unused at the back of the first owners garage. Car then acquired by Independent dealer and then I bought it from the Independent dealer.
Right then, so 2 weeks ago I sold the car and the buyer is due to collect on Monday; part of the deal was for me to put 12 month MOT on it which I did yesterday.
Last night whilst getting all the paperwork together I noticed the new MOT certificate had included 4 mileage readings from the last 4 mot's - 12500 current, 11800 from 2012, 12450(!) from 2011 and 11900 from 2010.
So it looks like it's had a haircut before I bought it. I didn't get any of the 2011, 2010, 2009, 2008 or 2007 MOT cert. when I bought it but was told it was off the road in storage and unused.
So now it appears it was not in storage and was infact being used and MOT'd each year.
I have told the new buyer (who paid in full via bank transfer) and they are spooked and want their money back. I am about to transfer it back after my coffee!
Where do I go from here? Back to the Indy I bought it from? What are my rights if they say '...that was 12 months ago, it ain't my problem so get stuffed'
I know what my natural reaction will be, but what about my legal position?
Any help appreciated...
What mileage do all the earlier MOTs say? Use www.motinfo.gov.uk Where they all done at the same place?
They could just be a careless inputting error, which on such a low miles car now stands out like a sore thumb
Do all the rest go up in a continuos fashion bar the blib?
They could just be a careless inputting error, which on such a low miles car now stands out like a sore thumb
Do all the rest go up in a continuos fashion bar the blib?
Edited by Mustard on Saturday 10th August 08:08
Edited by Mustard on Saturday 10th August 08:11
This looks like a fuss about nothing.
Even if the car was misrepresented as having been stored, it is hard to see that the purchaser has sufered any loss in consequence. The market value of the car is probably unaffected.
Anyway, why are people obsessed with low mileage? Low mileage is a bad thing. Lack of use is not good for machines.
Even if the car was misrepresented as having been stored, it is hard to see that the purchaser has sufered any loss in consequence. The market value of the car is probably unaffected.
Anyway, why are people obsessed with low mileage? Low mileage is a bad thing. Lack of use is not good for machines.
It is possible that the car was driven, clocked each year and then MOT'd. I've seen articles where dealers who clock cars end up in jail, so it is quite serious.
On the other hand it could just be an inputting error. If it was stored, why does it have MOT's from years after 2006? Are they all from the same place? Can you give them a ring and ask them what they think has happened?
On the other hand it could just be an inputting error. If it was stored, why does it have MOT's from years after 2006? Are they all from the same place? Can you give them a ring and ask them what they think has happened?
As suggested above, use the MOT test number and check the VOSA records to see if there's anything before this. It could just be inputting error on MOTs... a car I had recently looked like it dropped 10k miles, but when you looked at all other documentation it was clearly a mistake on the MOT (e.g. it had a service a week later and was back to being where it should've been with 10k miles more again).
johnnyBv8 said:
p.s. You'd have to think if an owner was clocking their car to cover mileage each year, they'd be smart enough that it wasnt clocked to a lower mileage than the last MOT. To me this would also suggest just an error in the records.
This.Cock up somehwere along the process.
Ref typos/mistakes for mileage on the old mot's...odd that they'd have done this twice tho, in 2010 and 2011, and if it was off the road from 2006 to 2012 then why did it have mot's?
Sounds like it was well used during that period and someone was too stupid to clock it to the "correct" mileage each year for the mot, conveniently lost these mots and didn't know that old mot dates/miles were printed on them now, or that you could look online and get these details. OP do you know where (and who) would have had these phantom mots done? (garage/owner?)
Perhaps the garage will claim ignorance and that this was the original owners doing. OP can you get his details and ring him (and the garage) to try and get to the bottom of it?
Hope that it is all somehow an innocent mistake, else that you can get it sorted to your satisfaction.
Sounds like it was well used during that period and someone was too stupid to clock it to the "correct" mileage each year for the mot, conveniently lost these mots and didn't know that old mot dates/miles were printed on them now, or that you could look online and get these details. OP do you know where (and who) would have had these phantom mots done? (garage/owner?)
Perhaps the garage will claim ignorance and that this was the original owners doing. OP can you get his details and ring him (and the garage) to try and get to the bottom of it?
Hope that it is all somehow an innocent mistake, else that you can get it sorted to your satisfaction.
Gassing Station | General Gassing | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


