Is a Monaro Fun Enough for a Weekend Toy??
Is a Monaro Fun Enough for a Weekend Toy??
Author
Discussion

McSwerve II

Original Poster:

325 posts

230 months

Saturday 10th August 2013
quotequote all
As above.

I had a brief test drive in one years ago, but against the 964 i had back then, it felt too ordinary.

Say verses a 996. Thoughts??


Baryonyx

18,297 posts

190 months

Saturday 10th August 2013
quotequote all
I'd still rather have the German sports car than the lazy GT cruiser, even if you went nuts with tuning the Monaro...

300bhp/ton

41,030 posts

221 months

Saturday 10th August 2013
quotequote all
Try a Camaro or Trans Am. Same motor and transmission pretty much. Less weight, more striking looking, optional T-Tops and LHD. Much more of an event to drive and just as capable.

Mik001

9 posts

164 months

Sunday 11th August 2013
quotequote all
Please 300bhp. There is no event driving a trans am. They are rubbish in every respect.
Maybe the new camaro but that's a different price.
Here in aus the Monaco are just another crappy commodore. No thanks

Baryonyx

18,297 posts

190 months

Sunday 11th August 2013
quotequote all
You mention LHD as though it were a boon. Eventful it may be, preferable it is not...

EmmaJ

4,525 posts

177 months

Sunday 11th August 2013
quotequote all
Depends what you want and how you drive. Every time I turn the key on my 'Ro as soon as the big V8 fires into life I've got a massive grin on my face. You can hustle them along but there are lots of cars that will run rings around a Monaro on the twisties. If you buy a N/A I don't think in standard guise they are all that quick but with forced induction they are properly rapid north of 100.

PGNTuscan

3,048 posts

197 months

Sunday 11th August 2013
quotequote all
300bhp/ton said:
Try a Camaro or Trans Am. Same motor and transmission pretty much. Less weight, more striking looking, optional T-Tops and LHD. Much more of an event to drive and just as capable.
Comedy gold

bridgdav

4,805 posts

279 months

Sunday 11th August 2013
quotequote all
It depends what you want to do on the weekend surely...

Rag the car around twisters of the English countryside, with a big grin on your face.
Drag it on a speedway somewhere
Show up to car meets all shiney
Cruise the car round town, with a V8 burble at the lights
Get on a track, drive at speed legally, feel the G force and test your and he cars driveability
Road trip to the far reaches of Europe
Take the trouble and rug rats shopping

Each of the above weekend wishes could have a different and suitable car, not many do ALL.

the Monaro could fit a number of them.. BUT, does it do any of them with great aplomb..?
It could do 3 & 4 I suppose....

balls-out

3,794 posts

262 months

Sunday 11th August 2013
quotequote all
Mik001 said:
Please 300bhp. There is no event driving a trans am. They are rubbish in every respect.
Maybe the new camaro but that's a different price.
Here in aus the Monaco are just another crappy commodore. No thanks
Ever driven a 4th gen? Mine was the most enjoyable car I've ever owned. Much better than an m5, and just pipped the caterham 7.
I never realised they "are rubbish in every respect", my mistake I guess.

I rather enjoyed my Holden HSV too, or crappy old commodore if you perfer.



Edited by balls-out on Sunday 11th August 08:37

007 VXR

64,187 posts

218 months

Sunday 11th August 2013
quotequote all
had mine 7 years and love it. I live at work so only get to drive her once or twice a week.
get a good tuned s/c one and you can tick most of the boxes.

RedBull

1,142 posts

253 months

Sunday 11th August 2013
quotequote all
As has been said, it all depends what you want from your weekend car. I've never had a Monaro but have had a couple of Camaros which are a similar ilk. Ignore the comment from 300bhp as looks are a purely personal choice and being LHD does not make it more of an event at all, but I have never found LHD to be a problem either. What makes any car an event is down to how it makes you feel when you drive it.
For me a weekend car has to look great, feel special, and just basically put a big grin on my face. My Camaros were for regular use rather than weekend toys, (I'm lucky though, as I have a van for work so don't use any car that much), but if the Monaro does it for you then why not?

Edited by RedBull on Sunday 11th August 09:01

slippery

14,093 posts

270 months

Sunday 11th August 2013
quotequote all
Unless significantly modified, the Monaro will be no match for a 911 as a weekend toy. They are simply a very comfortable and refined GT as standard.

Hasbeen

2,073 posts

252 months

Sunday 11th August 2013
quotequote all
I found the original 327 a lot of fun around Bathurst.

I Found the last of the Monaros definitely the best thing that would do a good job of towing the kids horses to pony club on Saturday, & still be enjoyable in the mountains on Sunday. They can do it for years too, without falling to bits like most Europeans.

I have yet to find a modern German car I can stand to look at, & want to drive. Perhaps someone could advise me what the attraction is.

007 VXR

64,187 posts

218 months

Sunday 11th August 2013
quotequote all
slippery said:
Unless significantly modified, the Monaro will be no match for a 911 as a weekend toy. They are simply a very comfortable and refined GT as standard.
Does depend what you want from a weekend toy scratchchin

slippery

14,093 posts

270 months

Sunday 11th August 2013
quotequote all
007 VXR said:
Does depend what you want from a weekend toy scratchchin
I wouldn't disagree with that mate, but the OP has already said that it felt too bland against an earlier 911. A 996 is a lot less raw than a 964, but is still a much more focussed car than a standard Monaro. Buy one with a spec approaching yours and it is of course a very different kettle of fish. smile

300bhp/ton

41,030 posts

221 months

Sunday 11th August 2013
quotequote all
Mik001 said:
Please 300bhp. There is no event driving a trans am. They are rubbish in every respect.
Maybe the new camaro but that's a different price.
Here in aus the Monaco are just another crappy commodore. No thanks
I'm willing to bet you've probably not even sat in one. So why not keep your PS3 experience to computer forums.

r1ch

2,956 posts

227 months

Sunday 11th August 2013
quotequote all
I really like the Monaro, but i think i'd go for something a bit lighter and smaller as a weekend fun car, but thats just me.

V88Dicky

7,373 posts

214 months

Sunday 11th August 2013
quotequote all
I've had my Monaro for nearly 7 years now and for the last five it has been a weekend car / holiday car.

I've never owned a car that has such a positive response from members of the public, people always seem to want to chat about it in car parks or at the pumps.

As far as the looks are concerned, I like them, otherwise I wouldn't have bought one. The later VZ designations are more aggressive looking, with bonnet scoops, dual sided exhaust, and a nice gauge pod on top of the dash, amongst other things.

They're well screwed together inside and out, and have tough mechanicals, with servicing being ridiculously cheap if you use some of the independent specialists available. Vauxhall don't know much about them so are worth avoiding TBH.
A lot of Monaros have been modified in some way, usually to improve some of the weaker areas which they came from the factory with. Things like restrictive and very quiet exhausts, long gearing, slow steering racks, inadequate brakes (for fast road use), power steering coolers that rot, no proper underseal etc. it's worth looking for one that's had work like this already done, as it makes ownership a whole lot better!

As far as mine's concerned, it's got a completely hand-built stainless exhaust, tubular headers, free flow cats, remote control exhaust cut-outs, stainless braided brake hoses, upgraded discs and pads and a few other bits. Insurance with mods declared comes in at 400 odd a year, tax is £490 a year, but I claim about 200 back when I SORN it each winter, so not all bad. Fuel consumption is 20 - 31 mpg dependant on journey.

There's less than 500 Monaros left in this country, so they are a very rare sight, certainly compared to a 911. Of course they handle differently, and if you don't like heavy steering, brakes, clutch and gear change, then it won't be for you. But, each to their own, I've wanted a muscle car since I was a kid, I was never interested in the usual Ferrari/Lamborghini/Porsche super car thing, I just wanted a big V8, 2 doors and a manual 'box, in a decent looking coupe body. So when I saw that Vauxhall would be importing the RHD Holden Monaro in from Australia, I just had to have one. I honestly don't know what I would replace it with, if ever.

smile