Should i claim on my insurance or not?
Should i claim on my insurance or not?
Author
Discussion

sider

Original Poster:

2,061 posts

252 months

Monday 12th August 2013
quotequote all
Hi All,

What would you do in this scenario – which is where I’m at right now.

Yesterday morning went to a car show and stupidly (and don’t really know how I managed it!) clipped a car on the way in. Was honest and got in touch with the owner via the shows tannoy announcer and met the guy. He was very good about it - even suggesting that the big scuff I’d left on his alloy didn’t need repairing as he’s just ordered some new wheels and was going to get the ones on his car refurbed anyway. I’ve basically scraped paint off his rear bumper, and round his arch. To my car – scratch on front bumper and headlight (but there is already a big stone dent just about said area on mine).

By the way, mine is a 2012 Passat (fleet vehicle), his a 2002 Passat (privately owned).

Situation I’m now in is:

1. Insurance route – I’d have to pay £100 to my employer towards the excess and get a black mark against my name on the fleet list (for what it’s worth) and obviously a claim would make my wife’s policy go up as I’m a named driver there.
2. None insurance route – I pay £250-300 to a mate of mine who has a small bodyshop to sort this chaps car out. Hassle would be him getting it to my mate and he may well be left without a car for a couple of days. My car would remain unfixed but I work in construction and cars are regularly getting bumped on sites or stones flicked up etc. So the risk I’d run is my car remains unfixed until the end of the lease and then I sort then. Alternatively, it gets whacked by a JCB before then and the repair gets swallowed as part of a the project’s costs!

What would you do?

In terms of timing – option 1 is the no brainer – spend £100 and get both cars back to normal. But my worry is the insurance increase to wife’s premium. Saying that, hers is only £300-400 a year and I’m named as an occasional driver on the policy which is for 6000 miles a year only (she only does 3k!). Surely I don’t pay the extra £150-200 to get my mate to sort? Surely the insurance isn’t going to rocket up another 50% because I’ve done a few hundred pounds worth of combined damage to 2 cars??

Any help appreciated - but happened at 11.00am yesterday and i need to let fleet know within 24 hours. So got 2 hours!

Lawbags

1,074 posts

159 months

Monday 12th August 2013
quotequote all
That's harsh about having to pay the excess. I've had fleet cars for years and have had several bumps and scrapes and have never had to do that!

Surely if it's a company policy, that won't affect your personal policy?

Mine don't anyway. When I renewed my private policy a few years ago, I told them about the bump in the company car and after a bit of discussion, turns out it doesn't affect me.
The company insurance cover note was stupid.
It said 'The person is who is in charge of this vehicle is insured blah blah blah'
No names, no vehicle details...nothing. And this (according to my insurers) is why it doesn't affect my private one.



sider

Original Poster:

2,061 posts

252 months

Monday 12th August 2013
quotequote all
Lawbags said:
That's harsh about having to pay the excess. I've had fleet cars for years and have had several bumps and scrapes and have never had to do that!

Surely if it's a company policy, that won't affect your personal policy?

Mine don't anyway. When I renewed my private policy a few years ago, I told them about the bump in the company car and after a bit of discussion, turns out it doesn't affect me.
The company insurance cover note was stupid.
It said 'The person is who is in charge of this vehicle is insured blah blah blah'
No names, no vehicle details...nothing. And this (according to my insurers) is why it doesn't affect my private one.


Thanks.

I think it's just because ours is such a big fleet - over 800 cars = a lot of bumps and they are trying to make us drive better.

Apparently, my next fault bump = £250, then £400, then after that £500 again or £250+driving training at my cost!

I don't mind. £100 is a pain to have to fork out but it's only similar to personal insurance.

I think it may affect the policy - because in theory as a named driver, i HAVE had an accident. But then have I made any claims? I'm sure T&Cs would dictate this to be the case, whether the policy is in my name or not.







TwigtheWonderkid

49,308 posts

181 months

Monday 12th August 2013
quotequote all
There is no excess on third party claims. Excess only applies to your own damage.

Lawbags

1,074 posts

159 months

Monday 12th August 2013
quotequote all
sider said:
Thanks.

I think it's just because ours is such a big fleet - over 800 cars = a lot of bumps and they are trying to make us drive better.

Apparently, my next fault bump = £250, then £400, then after that £500 again or £250+driving training at my cost!

I don't mind. £100 is a pain to have to fork out but it's only similar to personal insurance.

I think it may affect the policy - because in theory as a named driver, i HAVE had an accident. But then have I made any claims? I'm sure T&Cs would dictate this to be the case, whether the policy is in my name or not.
Hmm...tricky one. Do you have access to the cover note? It'd be interesting to see how it's written.


METHS

2,114 posts

167 months

Monday 12th August 2013
quotequote all
TwigtheWonderkid said:
There is no excess on third party claims. Excess only applies to your own damage.
This is correct.

CYMR0

3,940 posts

231 months

Monday 12th August 2013
quotequote all
Given that the third party would be left without a car for a couple of days, I wouldn't consider the two options comparable in terms of outcomes.

The increase on your wife's policy will be very small, given that you are a named driver and she presumably is a sensible, low-risk driver with lots of no claims (I'm paraphrasing). Expect 10% of the policy cost or less in the first year.

All in, the £100 excess plus the additional premium cost for your wife should not cost more than fixing the damage yourself.

This will also get your company car fixed (including the dent) meaning that the leaseco stings the company for less at the end.

The only reason not to go that route would, in my opinion, be that you are seriously worried that it would have a negative effect at work, which seems unlikely to me.


sider

Original Poster:

2,061 posts

252 months

Monday 12th August 2013
quotequote all
CYMR0 said:
Given that the third party would be left without a car for a couple of days, I wouldn't consider the two options comparable in terms of outcomes.

The increase on your wife's policy will be very small, given that you are a named driver and she presumably is a sensible, low-risk driver with lots of no claims (I'm paraphrasing). Expect 10% of the policy cost or less in the first year.

All in, the £100 excess plus the additional premium cost for your wife should not cost more than fixing the damage yourself.

This will also get your company car fixed (including the dent) meaning that the leaseco stings the company for less at the end.

The only reason not to go that route would, in my opinion, be that you are seriously worried that it would have a negative effect at work, which seems unlikely to me.
Nails hit on heads there - thanks.

Just spoke to 3rd party. He's insured - i've checked - but wants to avoid insurer. Apparently, he's been quoted £200 by a friend of a friend to sort - but will then add £460 to that to get the rest of his car sorted.

For me, this would cost me £100 more and leave me with a damaged car.

I've spoken with our accident management company and it's in their hands now. My car is having damage estimated tomorrow.

Not had a claim issue for years - but do i need to let my wife's insurer know now that a named driver on her policy with years of no claims has now made a claim?

TwigtheWonderkid

49,308 posts

181 months

Monday 12th August 2013
quotequote all
sider said:
but do i need to let my wife's insurer know now that a named driver on her policy with years of no claims has now made a claim?
Yes, but not until her next renewal.

ZOLLAR

19,920 posts

204 months

Monday 12th August 2013
quotequote all
METHS said:
TwigtheWonderkid said:
There is no excess on third party claims. Excess only applies to your own damage.
This is correct.
Not necessarily, they are rare but third party excesses do exist.

Also as his policy is a company one not a private policy the conditions could may well be different.