M-I-L and Tyres
Author
Discussion

Slashmb

Original Poster:

414 posts

288 months

Monday 12th August 2013
quotequote all
Ok, so here we go...

Mother in Law has a Clio that is 7 years old. She has owned it from new and has done about 18k miles in it. All four tyres have cracks in the sidewall and an advisory was given in March for the M.O.T. highlighting this.

She has decided to change all four tyres and I would agree with this as the cracks are quite bad. I always have premium tyres on my car but would it be a waste of money on a car that does about 2500 miles a year and never goes faster than 55mph?

I called a local tyre place today and was quoted £48 for a Goodyear, £43 for a falken and £34 for a budget. He said I'd be wasting money on premium tyres and to just fit the budget ones as they would still have to be replaced in 7 years because of sidewall cracks rather than tread.

It goes against all what I believe to tell my mother in law to get the budget tyres but then it does seem a bit of a waste to go for the Goodyears.

What would you do in the same situation?

Exige77

6,523 posts

222 months

Monday 12th August 2013
quotequote all
For the small difference in cost on smaller tyres I would at least stick the mid priced ones on.

Ex77

MissChief

8,022 posts

199 months

Monday 12th August 2013
quotequote all
Agreed. For the price increase from ditchfinders to at least something with a reputation I would pay the extra for the Falkens.

jagnet

4,442 posts

233 months

Monday 12th August 2013
quotequote all
I'd put the Goodyear tyres on, it's not as if they're expensive to start with. Less than a tank of fuel difference in price between them and the budget tyres for peace of mind.

Alternatively, source some decent part worn tyres.

10 Pence Short

32,880 posts

248 months

Monday 12th August 2013
quotequote all
I'd go for the ditchfinders. The MIL isn't, I imagine, going to test grip levels or journey in conditions that make the extra cost worthwhile. Why spend more in those circumstances?

Gtom

1,905 posts

163 months

Monday 12th August 2013
quotequote all
Agree with the above but for another £5 per tyre I would go with the best.

Exige77

6,523 posts

222 months

Monday 12th August 2013
quotequote all
Just need that one winter evening when you need to make that one emergency stop when an idiot does something stupid in front of you to make them worthwhile.

Ex77

Rickyy

6,618 posts

250 months

Monday 12th August 2013
quotequote all
It's the MIL! Convince her to keep the cracked tyres!

talksthetalk

10,821 posts

166 months

Monday 12th August 2013
quotequote all
Get her the expensive ones.
Then arrange for a mate to pull out of a junction a bit in front of her.
She stops in time.
You were right to think of her safety and get massive brownie points.
ETA hehe

stug45

98 posts

166 months

Monday 12th August 2013
quotequote all
Those Goodyear's are still cheap....my jazz costs 60-70 per tyre (I pick the best and always shop around)

Or ditchfinders if you want inheritance....

GC8

19,910 posts

221 months

Monday 12th August 2013
quotequote all
Very, very bad advice. I suspect that the REAL reason for the advice was that there is FAR more profit on the ditchfinders than there is on Falken or Goodyear tyres.

New POD

3,851 posts

181 months

Monday 12th August 2013
quotequote all
What did the car come with. Insist she keeps them and tell her she'll have to declare it as a modification if she changes brand.

Slashmb

Original Poster:

414 posts

288 months

Tuesday 13th August 2013
quotequote all
Exige77 said:
For the small difference in cost on smaller tyres I would at least stick the mid priced ones on.

Ex77
This is what I was thinking at first but then it's only another fiver per corner for the Goodyears.

Slashmb

Original Poster:

414 posts

288 months

Tuesday 13th August 2013
quotequote all
jagnet said:
I'd put the Goodyear tyres on, it's not as if they're expensive to start with. Less than a tank of fuel difference in price between them and the budget tyres for peace of mind.

Alternatively, source some decent part worn tyres.
There is that peace of mind thing too and if they last another 7 years then £50 is nothing really.

I did also think about the part worn option too but I'm put off because you never know what's happened to them in the past. I might look in to this though, just to see what's out there.

Slashmb

Original Poster:

414 posts

288 months

Tuesday 13th August 2013
quotequote all
10 Pence Short said:
I'd go for the ditchfinders. The MIL isn't, I imagine, going to test grip levels or journey in conditions that make the extra cost worthwhile. Why spend more in those circumstances?
This is what I am torn between. Every fibre of my body says get the Goodyear but its not like she drives like she stole it so why spend more.

Slashmb

Original Poster:

414 posts

288 months

Tuesday 13th August 2013
quotequote all
Rickyy said:
It's the MIL! Convince her to keep the cracked tyres!
Surprised it took until the 7th reply to get one like this. smile

davepoth

29,395 posts

230 months

Tuesday 13th August 2013
quotequote all
Go for the best. If she doesn't know where the limit is she'll likely do things from time to time that get close to it without realising. I have seen people brake hard enough to get the ABS to cut in in the dry in normal driving and not think it was remarkable.

AuralisMatty

75 posts

160 months

Tuesday 13th August 2013
quotequote all
Put the good years on if she has an accident it will give her an excuse to blame you LOL for fitting cheap tyres.

g3org3y

22,529 posts

222 months

Tuesday 13th August 2013
quotequote all
Can you not explain to her the pros and cons of each option and then she can make her own decision?

Slashmb

Original Poster:

414 posts

288 months

Tuesday 13th August 2013
quotequote all
GC8 said:
Very, very bad advice. I suspect that the REAL reason for the advice was that there is FAR more profit on the ditchfinders than there is on Falken or Goodyear tyres.
I'm not so sure TBH. They are THE cheapest place in town and I ask for prices for one tyre, then asked if he could do me a deal for four. He reckoned that it was the lowest he could go and only made £10 per tyre. That was on the Goodyear too.

Could he really be paying a lot less than £24 for a budget tyre?