Sorry for a what car, but am I missing anything?
Discussion
Trading in the Jag S-Type R, few issues (main one rust on three of four arches) that are looking expensive.
Want list:
- large hatch or estate (probably an estate) so I can throw a bike in, driving me mad that I can't pick up a bike (push) unless I have the van or fit the towbar and carrier to the Jag
- want to be able to tow a small caravan
- don't really want FWD again, every car up to the Jag was FWD
- would choose 4x4 over RWD but don't need a proper big 4x4
- like something with a bit of pace
- 7-8k miles per year so mpg in the 20s is fine
- reliable
- £10k budget, less would be better!
So, this has left me with Subaru and Audi. Audi range would be the S4, nothing else has really caught my eye and the S4 potential problems scare me, sure a good one would be great but at that budget there's a lot of dogs.
Which leaves me with a Scooby, drove a Legacy 3.0R Spec B but can't find a good one. Current top runner is a Forester 2.5 XTen but it's not a looker!!
Am I missing anything or should I have a better look RWD and test some of the 3 series range?
Want list:
- large hatch or estate (probably an estate) so I can throw a bike in, driving me mad that I can't pick up a bike (push) unless I have the van or fit the towbar and carrier to the Jag
- want to be able to tow a small caravan
- don't really want FWD again, every car up to the Jag was FWD
- would choose 4x4 over RWD but don't need a proper big 4x4
- like something with a bit of pace
- 7-8k miles per year so mpg in the 20s is fine
- reliable
- £10k budget, less would be better!
So, this has left me with Subaru and Audi. Audi range would be the S4, nothing else has really caught my eye and the S4 potential problems scare me, sure a good one would be great but at that budget there's a lot of dogs.
Which leaves me with a Scooby, drove a Legacy 3.0R Spec B but can't find a good one. Current top runner is a Forester 2.5 XTen but it's not a looker!!
Am I missing anything or should I have a better look RWD and test some of the 3 series range?
You've named the most common ones. What about a E61 550i? Very rare and a nice 4.8 V8 lump. May be a little over budget but shop around and you might get lucky.
http://www.pistonheads.com/gassing/topic.asp?t=101...
http://www4.autotrader.co.uk/classified/advert/201...
http://www.pistonheads.com/gassing/topic.asp?t=101...
http://www4.autotrader.co.uk/classified/advert/201...
Nissan Murano:
http://www.pistonheads.com/classifieds/used-cars/n...
Actually, I quite like the Cayenne suggestion...
http://www.pistonheads.com/classifieds/used-cars/n...
Actually, I quite like the Cayenne suggestion...
Thanks for all the suggestions!
The Allroad, definitely something I've looked at but there's just something I don't like about them. Not overly keen on a modern diesel with the associated risks, Mondeo ST tdci felt like a ticking time bomb. Think the performance would leave me wanting more. Did they ever do one with a V8???
Cayenne - really don't like these. Would have a Disco or RR sport over that but unless I see a good one in a garage I'm in they're unlikely.
x30/335 - really need to get a look at these. Know how good they're meant to be, would like 4x4 but the van on winter tyres was unstoppable last year. Number of times I'm likely to be stuck in a muddy field towing is fairly low too.
550 - lovely car, need to have a look to see what is available.
Outback/Leggy - fairly sure I spotted the LPG one the other night, I'm in Edinburgh, not a problem to travel but have to arrange everything prior to travelling which makes local better.
XC/V70 - had a T5-R before and loved it. Never felt like a reliable daily though and I've heard some horror stories about the V70R 4x4 system. XC70, had a look the other day but couldn't spot one locally I wanted to look at.
The Allroad, definitely something I've looked at but there's just something I don't like about them. Not overly keen on a modern diesel with the associated risks, Mondeo ST tdci felt like a ticking time bomb. Think the performance would leave me wanting more. Did they ever do one with a V8???
Cayenne - really don't like these. Would have a Disco or RR sport over that but unless I see a good one in a garage I'm in they're unlikely.
x30/335 - really need to get a look at these. Know how good they're meant to be, would like 4x4 but the van on winter tyres was unstoppable last year. Number of times I'm likely to be stuck in a muddy field towing is fairly low too.
550 - lovely car, need to have a look to see what is available.
Outback/Leggy - fairly sure I spotted the LPG one the other night, I'm in Edinburgh, not a problem to travel but have to arrange everything prior to travelling which makes local better.
XC/V70 - had a T5-R before and loved it. Never felt like a reliable daily though and I've heard some horror stories about the V70R 4x4 system. XC70, had a look the other day but couldn't spot one locally I wanted to look at.
I know u didn't love my cayenne suggestion and this is possibly a similar train of thought but what about a vw toureg v10 tdi ?
So etching like this ....
http://www.pistonheads.com/classifieds/used-cars/v...
Just another option maybe. I did look for v8 Volvo xc90's for u but seem to be rare and pricey but I think I'm right in sayin it is the Yamaha built v8 that is also used and turbo'd that goes in the new noble which is good bragging rights lol. Saying that the toureg can tow basically anything, caravans, car trailers, the moon....
So etching like this ....
http://www.pistonheads.com/classifieds/used-cars/v...
Just another option maybe. I did look for v8 Volvo xc90's for u but seem to be rare and pricey but I think I'm right in sayin it is the Yamaha built v8 that is also used and turbo'd that goes in the new noble which is good bragging rights lol. Saying that the toureg can tow basically anything, caravans, car trailers, the moon....
That's exactly why I put this thread up, I'd never have considered a v10 toureg without it! Nothing near but will have a look round both a toureg and a xc90 at the weekend. Even a smaller engined one is at least different enough to the jag to not completely miss the power. Definitely going to look at these cheers.
Had a look at the 300c in diesel flavour locally. Couldn't put up with the interior and a Diesel engine, too many compromises but the v8 could be a different story. Back on the possible list...
Shame they didn't make a Mazda 6 MPS estate and that WRXs haven't got a great towing limit or the shopping list would have two other contenders.
Had a look at the 300c in diesel flavour locally. Couldn't put up with the interior and a Diesel engine, too many compromises but the v8 could be a different story. Back on the possible list...
Shame they didn't make a Mazda 6 MPS estate and that WRXs haven't got a great towing limit or the shopping list would have two other contenders.
large hatch or estate (probably an estate) so I can throw a bike in, driving me mad that I can't pick up a bike (push) unless I have the van or fit the towbar and carrier to the Jag - Large Hatch
- want to be able to tow a small caravan - Check
- don't really want FWD again, every car up to the Jag was FWD - 4x4
- would choose 4x4 over RWD but don't need a proper big 4x4 - 4x4
- like something with a bit of pace - 9sec 0-60....hmm
- 7-8k miles per year so mpg in the 20s is fine - 40+
- reliable - "sounds like a volkswagen"
- £10k budget, less would be better! - £8995
http://www.autotrader.co.uk/classified/advert/2013... or search autotrader for Skoda Superb 2.0 TDI CR 170 2009 - no relation to seller - thinking of buying something similar myself - intersted in your thoughts....
Guy
- want to be able to tow a small caravan - Check
- don't really want FWD again, every car up to the Jag was FWD - 4x4
- would choose 4x4 over RWD but don't need a proper big 4x4 - 4x4
- like something with a bit of pace - 9sec 0-60....hmm
- 7-8k miles per year so mpg in the 20s is fine - 40+
- reliable - "sounds like a volkswagen"
- £10k budget, less would be better! - £8995
http://www.autotrader.co.uk/classified/advert/2013... or search autotrader for Skoda Superb 2.0 TDI CR 170 2009 - no relation to seller - thinking of buying something similar myself - intersted in your thoughts....
Guy
guy10 said:
large hatch or estate (probably an estate) so I can throw a bike in, driving me mad that I can't pick up a bike (push) unless I have the van or fit the towbar and carrier to the Jag - Large Hatch
- want to be able to tow a small caravan - Check
- don't really want FWD again, every car up to the Jag was FWD - 4x4
- would choose 4x4 over RWD but don't need a proper big 4x4 - 4x4
- like something with a bit of pace - 9sec 0-60....hmm
- 7-8k miles per year so mpg in the 20s is fine - 40+
- reliable - "sounds like a volkswagen"
- £10k budget, less would be better! - £8995
http://www.autotrader.co.uk/classified/advert/2013... or search autotrader for Skoda Superb 2.0 TDI CR 170 2009 - no relation to seller - thinking of buying something similar myself - intersted in your thoughts....
Guy
At those miles a year why not give the diesel a miss and go for the 3.2 V6 DSG 4x4 Superb estate?- want to be able to tow a small caravan - Check
- don't really want FWD again, every car up to the Jag was FWD - 4x4
- would choose 4x4 over RWD but don't need a proper big 4x4 - 4x4
- like something with a bit of pace - 9sec 0-60....hmm
- 7-8k miles per year so mpg in the 20s is fine - 40+
- reliable - "sounds like a volkswagen"
- £10k budget, less would be better! - £8995
http://www.autotrader.co.uk/classified/advert/2013... or search autotrader for Skoda Superb 2.0 TDI CR 170 2009 - no relation to seller - thinking of buying something similar myself - intersted in your thoughts....
Guy
Bonkers car....
Another interesting suggestion, thanks. Agree that the diesel wouldn't be worth the risk for the mileage I'm doing. Finding a 3.6 looks like it would be challenging though! Had a look at the 2.8 V6 and can't see any benefit of having it over the 3.6 apart from there are more available and at a lower price.
Added to the list of possibilities.
Added to the list of possibilities.
Gassing Station | General Gassing | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff



. Should get a nice example 2003 ish kind of age with 50,000 on it for that sort of budget.