EGR Valve inoperative - MOT Failure?
EGR Valve inoperative - MOT Failure?
Author
Discussion

flakeypaul

Original Poster:

436 posts

221 months

Tuesday 13th August 2013
quotequote all
Does anyone have any experience with getting cars through an MOT with a warning light on the dashboard? I know the MOT rules were recently changed but it's not clear whether these only cover safety warning lights or whether they cover all warning lights.

My car is giving the good old Renault 'Check Emissions' - I've had the error read and it indicates an EGR problem. I've had the valve off and it seems to be operating okay so I'm suspecting it's an over sensitive sensor or general Renaultness.

What I'm really trying to work out is whether to bother doing anything with it (I know of too many people who have thrown far too much money after trying to clear an unstoppable engine management fault) - will 'Check Emissions' automatically mean an MOT failure or is this dashboard warning not part of the checks?

Look forward to the 'you shouldn't have bought a bloody Renault / Diesel / French Car / MPV' style comments smile

TheEnd

15,370 posts

219 months

Tuesday 13th August 2013
quotequote all
You'll be fine as long as it gets through the smoke test.

Big Rod

6,265 posts

247 months

Tuesday 13th August 2013
quotequote all
Engine management warning light isn't an MOT failure IIRC.

My last car, (XJR8), passed its MOT with one Cat' almost completely collapsed and a year later it passed the MOT first time then the EMU warning came on reporting that the other one was operating below acceptable tollerances.

On the other hand, my Pajero has had the EGR function deleted and it's passed two MOTs like that.

As long as it passes the emissions test you'll be fine.

flakeypaul

Original Poster:

436 posts

221 months

Tuesday 13th August 2013
quotequote all
Hope so! I'm attempting bangernomics now with this motor - some of the quotes I've had for investigative work have been really stupid! The less I have to spend on it the more I get to spend on its replacement!

jagracer

8,248 posts

267 months

Tuesday 13th August 2013
quotequote all
I had a problem with my wife's Clio DCi where the engine management light came on. We did a code read and it came up as the EGR valve and brake light switch. I put a new EGR valve on, cleared the code and the light still came up after about 10 minutes, in the end cleaning the earth tab on the rear lights cured it.
Anyhoo I digress, your warning light is not a fail.

Big Rod

6,265 posts

247 months

Tuesday 13th August 2013
quotequote all
jagracer said:
I had a problem with my wife's Clio DCi where the engine management light came on. We did a code read and it came up as the EGR valve and brake light switch. I put a new EGR valve on, cleared the code and the light still came up after about 10 minutes, in the end cleaning the earth tab on the rear lights cured it.
Anyhoo I digress, your warning light is not a fail.
Electronics on cars are great ain't they?

I remember if you fitted the wrong spark plugs to a Senator it would cause the gearbox to throw a wobbly!