Getting ridof all traffic laws, replacing them with a permit
Discussion
OK, this might be a bit of theory, but it would be great to have the feedback of the PH community. The article is in relation to a planned 'Startup City', and it would be unlikely that a country like the UK would adopt it anytime soon, but it would be good to hear what you guys think of the principle.
http://startupcities.org/?p=338
http://startupcities.org/?p=338
Haven't had time to read the article fully, but have always been of the opinion that there's bound to be a better way than how we manage this now.
Car tax for example IMO should be linked to use, not co2 output. However I know the gov would only manage this through the use of trackers and that leads to all sorts of stuff I don't agree with.
Car tax for example IMO should be linked to use, not co2 output. However I know the gov would only manage this through the use of trackers and that leads to all sorts of stuff I don't agree with.
Jawaman said:
Haven't had time to read the article fully, but have always been of the opinion that there's bound to be a better way than how we manage this now.
Car tax for example IMO should be linked to use, not co2 output. However I know the gov would only manage this through the use of trackers and that leads to all sorts of stuff I don't agree with.
Or on fuel use? Real (non manipulated) CO2 output is a function of Fuel consumption, I don't see why they can't just charge a little more fuel tax and do away with Road Tax, So long as it balanced out to be the same for the average user. Car tax for example IMO should be linked to use, not co2 output. However I know the gov would only manage this through the use of trackers and that leads to all sorts of stuff I don't agree with.
crosseyedlion said:
Or on fuel use? Real (non manipulated) CO2 output is a function of Fuel consumption, I don't see why they can't just charge a little more fuel tax and do away with Road Tax, So long as it balanced out to be the same for the average user.
Far too sensible, it has two main hurdles. It would reduce the number of jobs at the dvla and the companies that supply them with services.
Anyone doing enough mileage to be worse off will whinge about it.
That sounds completely unworkable. The "worst possible case" for a car would amount to millions of damage done, per day (put a few people in a wheelchair and the compensation for the care they'll need for the rest of their life could easily reach that). Assuming you would prosecute those who did not pay the worst-case fee that they couldn't show did not apply to them, then everything that is illegal now will be illegal here for everyone except a few billionaires - so it pretty much reduces to the current system, except you'd have to submit vast quantities of evidence to - who exactly? - in order to drive (and you really think this system would not be incredibly abused by anyone who knows how to, say, fake GPS logs?). And since it's pretty inherent to experimental vehicles that the true risk they pose is not yet known, they would be charged the prohibitive fee too - so it would not encourage innovation at all.
If you want to encourage innovation, here's a much simpler idea: implement a vehicle certification regime that can be made flexible for experimental vehicles, until we know what the correct safety standards for that vehicles should be. The UK already has a system for type-approving low production volume vehicles, which may need improving but the idea is there.
If you want to encourage innovation, here's a much simpler idea: implement a vehicle certification regime that can be made flexible for experimental vehicles, until we know what the correct safety standards for that vehicles should be. The UK already has a system for type-approving low production volume vehicles, which may need improving but the idea is there.
Gassing Station | General Gassing | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


