Staff Bonuses
Author
Discussion

russy01

Original Poster:

4,823 posts

212 months

Wednesday 14th August 2013
quotequote all
Evening Chaps,

Interested to hear different ideas on how you structure staff bonuses. Until now we have just allocated X% of our bottom line for staff bonuses and everybody has had an equal share.

However as we are growing this doesn't feel the best way forward and there are members of staff who now potentially deserve more or less of the pot. We are struggling to find a means in which to quantify who deserves what - there are no obvious factors like sales performance etc which can be used. So I want to put it out there and see who does what.

We have a mix of full time salary paid staff, hourly paid staff and sub contracted staff. Ideally we want to keep the bonus payable once annually.

Interested to hear your views.

Thanks.


rog007

5,832 posts

255 months

Wednesday 14th August 2013
quotequote all
Much has been written about bonuses stating that they are not the best way to incentivise or reward staff. Additionally, as you are now experiencing, they can be a challenge to implement fairly and equitably; get it wrong and you can in fact disincentivise the very staff you're looking to incentivise.

Some would say a fair days wage for a fair days work with good conditions of service and being led by quality leaders make bonuses redundant. By extrapolation, bonuses may be used by some organisations as a way of attempting to compensate for poor management practice elsewhere.


skeggysteve

5,724 posts

248 months

Wednesday 14th August 2013
quotequote all
I can't answerer your question but I'll give you my view being an employee.

1. Worked for a company that imported nice furniture. I moved house and wanted a few bits for the house, boss agreed to payment over a few months out of my wages. The deduction wasn't taken the first month and when I questioned it the boss said something along these lines 'I wanted to know that you didn't want them for free and as you didn't they are a home warming present'.

2. Boss got a gift card type thing for my birthday for a restaurant that he took time to he find that I visited a lot.

A bit of thought is worth a lot more than a few extra £'s in a wage packet.

bristolbaron

5,392 posts

243 months

Thursday 15th August 2013
quotequote all
First thing is how big is the business? how many employees and potentially how much are we talking about per person or pot size?

Totally agree with other comments about how well a 'bonus' actually works as an incentive. An annual 'we've made X so your share is X' is great, but if employees get £X per year for 3 years and the next year is tight, people work under harder conditions for half of £X - then feel worse the next year.

In a smaller company where you know the individuals and can offer something specific a bonus/extra days holiday can be more rewarding than a pay rise. I worked my ass off for a guy who promised the world, but never delivered. Insignificant sums would've been enough to recognise achievement and made me feel if I were ever in a position where I could reward staff that would be the way to do it. £100 the day before going on holiday, a bottle of something for a job well done or a day off with £50 for lunch would mean more to me than £1000 per year. Think smart.. the furniture idea was great thinking on the bosses behalf.

otolith

69,816 posts

235 months

Thursday 15th August 2013
quotequote all
A bonus can be a good way of aligning everyone's interest, and it can also be a way of offering attractive remuneration with minimal business risk.

russy01

Original Poster:

4,823 posts

212 months

Thursday 15th August 2013
quotequote all
Thanks for your replies. To answer a couple.

Furniture - nice idea but doesn't really work with our products.
Extra holiday - wont go into too much detail but our holiday offering is very good and working hours are very flexible. Seasonal products also mean that in the summer working hours can be short.

Current bonus - on our current scheme this years bonus would be equal to about 20% of the average salary - so I'd say its generous.

I'm wondering whether we should just make the bonus a set % of their salary and consider offering other lifestyle benefits. It's probably best to sit them down and see what they would like.

Siscar

6,315 posts

160 months

Thursday 15th August 2013
quotequote all
If people are on a wide range of salaries the bonus has to be related to salary partly so people are all getting something meaningful to them and also because your higher paid people should be making a greater impact on the business else why would you pay them more?

An approach is to tier the bonus, so people get a performance score of 1, 2 or 3 (for example), 1 gets you 150% of the base figure, 2 gets you 100% and 3 gets you 50% (or whatever), but the problem with that is that everyone expects to get a 1 and you have to be able to tell them why they didn't, if they didn't. We have a scheme where everyone gets a percentage of salary but we hold some back so we can pay an additional bonus to people who have done something exceptional.

LooneyTunes

9,541 posts

189 months

Thursday 15th August 2013
quotequote all
rog007 said:
Some would say a fair days wage for a fair days work with good conditions of service and being led by quality leaders make bonuses redundant. By extrapolation, bonuses may be used by some organisations as a way of attempting to compensate for poor management practice elsewhere.
All that assumes that 1) the revenue stream is fairly predictable and stable; and that 2) you don't need to keep staff on-board past key project milestones.

I'd structure something that divided a "pot" in a way that took into account:

1) Length of service (encourage loyalty)
2) Contracted hours (pro rata)
3) Impact on the business (which you could do crudely based on base salary or more intelligently based on "banding" jobs in some way)

(mix the % distribution up as you see fit)

I'd also perhaps be tempted to hold back a small % of the pot for allocation on a discretionary basis for if someone has gone way above expectations.

The important things are that it needs to be transparent - people need to be able to have confidence in the scheme - and that the bonus should ideally be based on things within the employees sphere of influence (I'd base the size of the "pot" on a % of profit).

Beware of accidentally including things that drive the wrong behaviours though - for example, a "green" element that encourages people to save energy is fine unless it stops sales folk using their cars to go and get orders...

Siscar

6,315 posts

160 months

Thursday 15th August 2013
quotequote all
brickwall said:
3. Give bonuses to employees based on performance in their annual review (or whatever it is you use). Under performing employees get the low amount, standard performers get the medium, and over performers get the high amount.
But do be prepared to have to talk to good employees about why you don't think they are an over performer. Unless you have an objective measure you can use (number of widgets made, sort of thing) it's very hard to explain to someone who is good why they are only standard. You can end up with everyone as an over performer and only those where you can identify something they aren't doing well as being standard.

russy01

Original Poster:

4,823 posts

212 months

Thursday 15th August 2013
quotequote all
Thanks for your help chaps, although some of your suggestions would be hard to apply purely because of the way we operate.

We have a small team of core staff who are loyal and have worked for many years, these staff are employed full time and all have very different roles. You could say some staff contribute directly to the bottom line, where other staff may do what would seem an administrative job which doesn't contribute directly to the bottom line - However they are all instrumental in our success. It's this which makes it hard to quantify performance and none of the staff can be compared side by side.

Also if I look back over the years I struggle to think of an employee who wouldn't get "full marks" in a review. Call me lucky that we have a great team or call me naive that I am blind to any problems - but as far as I am concerned we have a very good team which I wouldn't change and are happy.

I am starting to wonder whether a big change to our bonus structure would give any benefits and maybe I should investigate other benefits instead.

scottri

951 posts

213 months

Thursday 15th August 2013
quotequote all
russy01 said:
However they are all instrumental in our success. It's this which makes it hard to quantify performance and none of the staff can be compared side by side.
In which case i'd suggest a flat % rate based on salary is best. IMO the problem with paying a fixed amount, for example £2k bonus to everyone, is that the low earners will see that as great and the higher earners will probably be annoyed as its less meaningful to them. I have heard people complaining about this in my office.

edit* and as suggested above, keep some back to offer additional exceptional payments where performance has far exceeded expectation.

Edited by scottri on Thursday 15th August 09:05

LooneyTunes

9,541 posts

189 months

Thursday 15th August 2013
quotequote all
russy01 said:
maybe I should investigate other benefits instead.
Be ready for some people to feel screwed if you do - personally I've never felt that any "other benefits" is as good as cold hard cash. Worst are those things that are actually tools for the job (phone/laptop etc) that companies try to pass off as benefits.

Lots of people spend most/all of their pay each month and like bonuses because it gives them a sudden cash injection that otherwise they don't get. I know that when I got bonuses they used to pay for/contribute to "big stuff" (major home improvements etc) that otherwise would have been a struggle to save up for on a month to month basis.

If you go down the "alternative incentive" route - e.g. extra days off - be ready for people to say that they won't use the extra time and, if they don't already use all of their holiday (except to prevent losing it), ask for you to buy back unused time off at the bonus rate.

Remember, impact on the business (as suggested earlier) doesn't necessarily mean direct revenue generation. Crude example, but there is no reason why for example the admin chaps responsible for such things can't have a metric based on things like ensuring say 95% of invoice collections from customers are within term + 7 days.

Siscar

6,315 posts

160 months

Thursday 15th August 2013
quotequote all
I agree on the 'other benefits' type of thing, everyone is different and what works for one doesn't work for others. We just use money these days, we have things like health schemes but they are on an opt in and pay basis for those who want them.

russy01

Original Poster:

4,823 posts

212 months

Thursday 15th August 2013
quotequote all
Siscar said:
I agree on the 'other benefits' type of thing, everyone is different and what works for one doesn't work for others. We just use money these days, we have things like health schemes but they are on an opt in and pay basis for those who want them.
I didn't make myself clear before. I appreciate cold hard cash - I personally relied on bonuses to fund big holidays and car purchases so I know how great they can be - whatever happens the bonus stays.

However I am considering offering something else over and above the current bonus. Also I think I may have recognised certain members of staff who may appreciate this more than an extra couple hundred quid - however I think I would offer a cash alternative as well.

How would this work? Any of you do such things? I know of a big firm who pay a bonus but then offer 2% of their salary towards benefits - which include private health, dental care, Travel insurance, Gym membership, etc etc. Personally this all sounds like a pain in the arse to offer, but at the end of the day its about keeping the staff rewarded so I think it would be good to at least consider.

Any experience with this?

anonymous-user

85 months

Thursday 15th August 2013
quotequote all
if you start awardng bonuses based on individual performance you may find that you incentivise people to compete with each other.

if you award bonuses in a 'flatter' way, you may find that you incentivise teamwork, and increase performance overall.

just a thought.

form what you've written russy, it seems that your current structure seems to help strengthen your team rather than detract from it.

Edited by anonymous-user on Thursday 15th August 09:52

LooneyTunes

9,541 posts

189 months

Thursday 15th August 2013
quotequote all
russy01 said:
How would this work? Any of you do such things? I know of a big firm who pay a bonus but then offer 2% of their salary towards benefits - which include private health, dental care, Travel insurance, Gym membership, etc etc. Personally this all sounds like a pain in the arse to offer, but at the end of the day its about keeping the staff rewarded so I think it would be good to at least consider.

Any experience with this?
You have to be a little careful with these though, and clear with employees about what exactly the deal is - things may have changed, but IIRC things like private health used to be a taxable benefit. I'd be a bit pissed off if I thought I was getting something as part of a bonus and ended up getting unexpectedly taxed on an ongoing basis for it (reducing monthly take home).

Likewise, if you're offering things like gym/healthcare, you need to think carefully about how you'll handle rising fees/premiums. If someone has opted in at one rate, then after 2-3 years the cost of provision has increased beyond their bonus allocation, are they out? Or do they make up the difference? Or does the company top up?

The only thing I'd entertain would be:
1) Childcare vouchers
2) Additional (employer) pension contributions

The common thing with each of these is that the accounting treatment is, IIRC, relatively simple and potentially beneficial to you as an employer.

aquarianone

502 posts

208 months

Thursday 15th August 2013
quotequote all
A software company I worked at back in the day split the bonus based on...

50% - company objectives / results
25% - team objectives
25% - personal objectives..

So everyone's (you'd hope) working to a common goal(s), collectively and individually...you just need to have in place a method of measuring success.

Current place is completely random, no guarantee if there is one or how much!

Keeps you on your toes a bit type

Siscar

6,315 posts

160 months

Thursday 15th August 2013
quotequote all
russy01 said:
Siscar said:
I agree on the 'other benefits' type of thing, everyone is different and what works for one doesn't work for others. We just use money these days, we have things like health schemes but they are on an opt in and pay basis for those who want them.
I didn't make myself clear before. I appreciate cold hard cash - I personally relied on bonuses to fund big holidays and car purchases so I know how great they can be - whatever happens the bonus stays.

However I am considering offering something else over and above the current bonus. Also I think I may have recognised certain members of staff who may appreciate this more than an extra couple hundred quid - however I think I would offer a cash alternative as well.

How would this work? Any of you do such things? I know of a big firm who pay a bonus but then offer 2% of their salary towards benefits - which include private health, dental care, Travel insurance, Gym membership, etc etc. Personally this all sounds like a pain in the arse to offer, but at the end of the day its about keeping the staff rewarded so I think it would be good to at least consider.

Any experience with this?
Yes, but this is where the problems start. Private health, great but some people object to it, others have it already, Gym membership - great if you want to go to the gym and it's a gym you want to go to, otherwise not so great. Travel insurance - also great if you want it and haven't got it but no use if you have it through another source, and the list goes on.

Since people are taxed on this stuff as a benefit in kind it's only any good if it's something they actually want, otherwise you can find that your kindness is costing you money and costing them money since they pay more tax, but not actually benefitting them much at all.

It's a minefield.

VX Foxy

3,962 posts

274 months

Thursday 15th August 2013
quotequote all
How about an unofficial/unwritten bonus whereby you reward individuals as and when you see fit;

"Well done Fred, you did a great job on that project - here's a £500 bonus" or "take your wife out for dinner and put it on expenses".

So staff don't expect anything and it's a nice surprise.

VX Foxy

3,962 posts

274 months

Thursday 15th August 2013
quotequote all
That ^ was a crap idea then?! biggrin