Churchill on road tax (AKA there's no such thing).
Discussion
No, not the annoying dog; him with the cigar:-
"Entertainments may be taxed; public houses may be taxed… and the yield devoted to the general revenue. But motorists are to be privileged for all time to have the tax on motors devoted to roads? This is an outrage upon… common sense."
That was in 1926, and road tax was abolished in 1937, but, in a fine example of cultural persistence, people still think it exists.
http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/magazine-23694438
"Entertainments may be taxed; public houses may be taxed… and the yield devoted to the general revenue. But motorists are to be privileged for all time to have the tax on motors devoted to roads? This is an outrage upon… common sense."
That was in 1926, and road tax was abolished in 1937, but, in a fine example of cultural persistence, people still think it exists.
http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/magazine-23694438
What is an outrage is that there is any tax, given that we pay tax on the purchase of the car, tax on the servicing of the car, tax on parts and massive tax on fuel. It's really not so much to expect that when you pool all this revenue, that people expect roads to be provided to drive on.
I've always thought of it as either road tax or car tax, but not because "money raised is spent on roads", but because its a tax (well duty) to use roads/use a car on the roads. However, if I add up how much I spend a year in tax/duty for car related things, you do think they could do a better job of sorting the bloody roads!
I think road is just another money spinner for the government, having said that if It didn't exist we would probably be taxed higher in other areas.
I do think though that if it stays we should all pay one flat rate, some cars get free road tax but they do just as much driving on roads as other cars ?
Cyclists should also have to pay a small rate I think, they use the roads essentially for free...
I do think though that if it stays we should all pay one flat rate, some cars get free road tax but they do just as much driving on roads as other cars ?
Cyclists should also have to pay a small rate I think, they use the roads essentially for free...
They even call it a stupid name so people won't understand it:
Excise Duty:
A tax imposed on the performance of an act, the engaging in an occupation, or the enjoyment of a privilege.
A tax on the manufacture, sale, or use of goods or on the carrying on of an occupation or activity, or a tax on the transfer of property.
In current usage the term has been extended to include various license fees and practically every internal revenue tax except the Income Tax (e.g., federal alcohol and tobacco excise taxes).
Excise Duty:
A tax imposed on the performance of an act, the engaging in an occupation, or the enjoyment of a privilege.
A tax on the manufacture, sale, or use of goods or on the carrying on of an occupation or activity, or a tax on the transfer of property.
In current usage the term has been extended to include various license fees and practically every internal revenue tax except the Income Tax (e.g., federal alcohol and tobacco excise taxes).
JDMDrifter said:
I think road is just another money spinner for the government, having said that if It didn't exist we would probably be taxed higher in other areas.
I do think though that if it stays we should all pay one flat rate, some cars get free road tax but they do just as much driving on roads as other cars ?
Cyclists should also have to pay a small rate I think, they use the roads essentially for free...
Oh good lord.I do think though that if it stays we should all pay one flat rate, some cars get free road tax but they do just as much driving on roads as other cars ?
Cyclists should also have to pay a small rate I think, they use the roads essentially for free...
The stupid. It hurts.
JDMDrifter said:
I think road is just another money spinner for the government, having said that if It didn't exist we would probably be taxed higher in other areas.
I do think though that if it stays we should all pay one flat rate, some cars get free road tax but they do just as much driving on roads as other cars ?
Cyclists should also have to pay a small rate I think, they use the roads essentially for free...
The purpose of taxation is to extract as much as possible from a citizen before they breakdown. I do think though that if it stays we should all pay one flat rate, some cars get free road tax but they do just as much driving on roads as other cars ?
Cyclists should also have to pay a small rate I think, they use the roads essentially for free...
So the current system is very clever. It works on the premis that the more emissions you make the wealthier you are and so the more you can be taxed. In addition the same system serves to make old and inefficient vehicles worthless and encourage new ones to be bought.
If cyclists could be taxed beyond VAT on purchase they would be. They aren't because the cost on enforcement is higher than any revenue and there is no fear threat of asset confiscation as well as no efficient way of tracking the offender to an address. You would need ID cards and a huge offense to not carry at all times.
So taxing cyclists for road use is a concept only for people who do not understand what taxation is.
DonkeyApple said:
So the current system is very clever. It works on the premis that the more emissions you make the wealthier you are and so the more you can be taxed. In addition the same system serves to make old and inefficient vehicles worthless and encourage new ones to be bought.
Coupled with the fact that it appeases the green lobby. It's win-win for the taxman.DonkeyApple said:
JDMDrifter said:
I think road is just another money spinner for the government, having said that if It didn't exist we would probably be taxed higher in other areas.
I do think though that if it stays we should all pay one flat rate, some cars get free road tax but they do just as much driving on roads as other cars ?
Cyclists should also have to pay a small rate I think, they use the roads essentially for free...
The purpose of taxation is to extract as much as possible from a citizen before they breakdown. I do think though that if it stays we should all pay one flat rate, some cars get free road tax but they do just as much driving on roads as other cars ?
Cyclists should also have to pay a small rate I think, they use the roads essentially for free...
So the current system is very clever. It works on the premis that the more emissions you make the wealthier you are and so the more you can be taxed. In addition the same system serves to make old and inefficient vehicles worthless and encourage new ones to be bought.
If cyclists could be taxed beyond VAT on purchase they would be. They aren't because the cost on enforcement is higher than any revenue and there is no fear threat of asset confiscation as well as no efficient way of tracking the offender to an address. You would need ID cards and a huge offense to not carry at all times.
So taxing cyclists for road use is a concept only for people who do not understand what taxation is.
Gassing Station | General Gassing | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff



is a fee that you pay to be able to use the roads, similar to say a TV licence. The only fair system, and one that we used to have, is that all cars pay the same amount. 