'Fun' car for £5K max?
Discussion
I am getting fed up of looking now, so just incase I've missed some obvious motors, can anyone help me out here?
I have £5K max, and I have to look at cars less than 10 years old. It's preferable that it be cheap to run and insure, but not essential. I know you can't guarantee reliability, but this car will do low miles, I'd like it to be reliable enough to go for a fair few years more.
It's a second car, though I have a dog, wife and 2 year old, so if it has 4 seats then that's a bonus.
I'm sure many cars that get mentioned will be on my list already, but sod it, I just wanted to see what people think...
Cheers, Alan
I have £5K max, and I have to look at cars less than 10 years old. It's preferable that it be cheap to run and insure, but not essential. I know you can't guarantee reliability, but this car will do low miles, I'd like it to be reliable enough to go for a fair few years more.
It's a second car, though I have a dog, wife and 2 year old, so if it has 4 seats then that's a bonus.
I'm sure many cars that get mentioned will be on my list already, but sod it, I just wanted to see what people think...
Cheers, Alan
I'd recommend a Mk3 MR2, VX220 (my top two recommendations), Clio 182/197, Mini Cooper S (a very capable all rounder) or a Civic Type R (another very capable all rounder). 
ETA: On paper and in reviews the RX8 seems great. Maybe the one I drove was broken but I didn't get on with it at all.. Definitely worth a look as you get a lot for your money with so many people avoiding them due to the mpg.

ETA: On paper and in reviews the RX8 seems great. Maybe the one I drove was broken but I didn't get on with it at all.. Definitely worth a look as you get a lot for your money with so many people avoiding them due to the mpg.
Edited by RobM77 on Thursday 15th August 16:19
tannedstamina said:
You could pick up a low mileage Rx8 for 3k and save the rest for petrol!! good seats, great to drive, practical but a little thirsty. Great for the odd trackday too!
This. Although I have no idea why the op mandates is just be under 10 years old. Seems a rather limiting factor. Blimey, the replies soon came through! Cheers...
I suppose I should mention I'm 6' 2". I've had a Mk3 MR2, amazing little car, way too small though. I only sold it because I did my ACL in playing football, getting too and from physio in that was a p!ss take
I've owned 2 puma's, 2 CTR's, 2 boxster S's, an e36 evo, a 330ci, and a few more less worthy of a mention. It could do with being quick enough to excite, though I know from the puma, it doesn't need bags of power to be a superb car.
The 10 year thing is mainly to filter out rusty nails. A lot of cars less than 10 years old are battered, but I'm no mechanic, and unless I find a really well cared for example, some of the more exciting older cars are going to be rotten, surely?
Top of the list is a MCS, I've been looking for weeks though, and some of them (for 5K you struggle to get newer than 54 plate) are really loose and rattly. Obviously most of the ones I looked at (70K miles max) needed new bushes etc, and I'd rather not bother unless it's tight feeling to start with.
Had 2 CTR's, never did get a 182/197 though, so maybe I should take a more serious look at them. Mate had an RX8, I've looked at them seriously though, as mentioned, they are CHEAP MOTORING to buy, just not to run. I decided against them, just too thirsty even with my low mileage, and it needs selling on at some point too.
I don't think a roadster will cut it, I test drove a lovely Mk2.5 MX5 sport and although great to drive (felt slow though?) it again felt too small for me. And the dog can't fit in with the baby either
Cooper S or RS Clio then, any other little hatches? I guess the Suzuki swift and Panda 100hp are going to feel too slow? I'd love an integra, but hard to find!
I suppose it's reassuring that most of the cars already mentioned were on my list. Just need to find a good'un... Cheers, Alan
I suppose I should mention I'm 6' 2". I've had a Mk3 MR2, amazing little car, way too small though. I only sold it because I did my ACL in playing football, getting too and from physio in that was a p!ss take
I've owned 2 puma's, 2 CTR's, 2 boxster S's, an e36 evo, a 330ci, and a few more less worthy of a mention. It could do with being quick enough to excite, though I know from the puma, it doesn't need bags of power to be a superb car.The 10 year thing is mainly to filter out rusty nails. A lot of cars less than 10 years old are battered, but I'm no mechanic, and unless I find a really well cared for example, some of the more exciting older cars are going to be rotten, surely?
Top of the list is a MCS, I've been looking for weeks though, and some of them (for 5K you struggle to get newer than 54 plate) are really loose and rattly. Obviously most of the ones I looked at (70K miles max) needed new bushes etc, and I'd rather not bother unless it's tight feeling to start with.
Had 2 CTR's, never did get a 182/197 though, so maybe I should take a more serious look at them. Mate had an RX8, I've looked at them seriously though, as mentioned, they are CHEAP MOTORING to buy, just not to run. I decided against them, just too thirsty even with my low mileage, and it needs selling on at some point too.
I don't think a roadster will cut it, I test drove a lovely Mk2.5 MX5 sport and although great to drive (felt slow though?) it again felt too small for me. And the dog can't fit in with the baby either

Cooper S or RS Clio then, any other little hatches? I guess the Suzuki swift and Panda 100hp are going to feel too slow? I'd love an integra, but hard to find!
I suppose it's reassuring that most of the cars already mentioned were on my list. Just need to find a good'un... Cheers, Alan
Since you like the Puma, what about a Racing Puma? 
I would add, you can get a nice 350Z for your budget. They don't seem very well liked on Pistonheads, but I thought it was a great car. Not massively fast, but it will keep any hot hatch honest, and will sound like a junior supercar in the process. Running costs aren't too horrible, great all-round cars and they definitely have a sense of occasion, worth a look.
Oh and I had a DC2 Integra too, and they are definitely worth trying to find a decent ones, very thrilling cars to drive. I loved mine.

I would add, you can get a nice 350Z for your budget. They don't seem very well liked on Pistonheads, but I thought it was a great car. Not massively fast, but it will keep any hot hatch honest, and will sound like a junior supercar in the process. Running costs aren't too horrible, great all-round cars and they definitely have a sense of occasion, worth a look.
Oh and I had a DC2 Integra too, and they are definitely worth trying to find a decent ones, very thrilling cars to drive. I loved mine.
irocfan said:
Prof Prolapse said:
Crossfire?
Get out.
says the man who's owned a micra! lol. Seriously though rather than just regurgitating some stuff you've read why not? As with the 350Z it's not loved on here and realistically it's a good, cheap choiceGet out.
350Z is a cracking shout however.
Gassing Station | General Gassing | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff



