Insurance Rant..
Discussion
Ok, no swearing because I don't want to let the emotion ruin the facts.. actually f
k it this is Pistonheads.
Background.. I'm an old git knocking 50, and I have a passion for older cars. I currently insure 3 old relics (an Opel Monza GSE, a Vauxhall Viva GLS and a Porsche 928GT) all of which costs me less than £500 to insure and all fully comprehensive. This also includes a Kawasaki ZZR1400 motorcycle. I have 10 years NCB, no accidents and no convictions, and I would like to think that I am a good risk insurance wise.
Due to a new contract I now find myself working some 20 miles away from home and my 5 litre V8 everyday drive is kind of negating any object in earning a salary. So the hunt for the fourth sensible commuter makes perfect sense, albeit not to my partner. I've looked at a lot of snotters and managed to find a mk3 Golf GTI 16V (as listed in the classifieds) for the sum of £350. It has issues - as expected and will probably cost me twice that to put right, but I wanted it because it is cheap and I can make a good car out of it over time.
So just how much would you think that snotter would be to insure? As my 3 litre fuel injected Monza was £78 fully comp, I thought it would be around that price. Well I tried Lancaster online as they are my main insurer of my classics and thought to add another would not be that costly..
Dear God how I was wrong

Then I tried a Google global quote with tpft - Shock horror! Why the f
k does it include "Diamond shaped for girls" ??? WTFlyingf
k???

So f
king 3rd party takes the premium up to a f
king grand for a piece of s
te that has no chance of earning any value due it being s
te in the first place. It also has an aftermarket alarm but that appears to make f
k all difference 
So now, somewhat f
ked off, I start to trawl through the previous insurers that have held me as a good risk with cars like an Ultima GTR with nitrous and a highly modified Nissan 300ZX Twin Turbo.. I know, I'll get a quote from Footman James.. they will save the day and f
k all the other t
ts..
Oh f
king no, have a really sensible night where you spend the best part of your life typing in stupid f
king boxes and getting "noo you didn't fill the answer in this box f
king properly you retard, this quote will now double as a result of your ineptitude in filling in online f
king stupid forms.. in addition to this we will anally ream you at every possibility
f
king t
ts
...
and for the final f
king performance, I give you Footman James.. with their best effort 



I mean what the f
king f
k f
k is that all about? Cannot even muster a quote because, "Due to the unique nature of your vehicle and your insurance needs..."
f
kety f
king f
k. It is a 17 year old POS, it is not fast, has decent security, is garaged, is worth £300 and will be owned by someone that has a good paperwork driving record.. Cannot quote???? - does this I've been revoked insurance and now have to declare this at every f
king box typing session?? What the flying f
k is occurring here???
Can anyone enlighten me as to why I am getting abused by insurance companies? I was told a few months back that it is how much damage I can do with my vehicle which sets the main marker for liability and premium costs. Clearly I could insure a f
king Sherman tank for less and enjoy creating more f
king damage so there is something f
king wrong here.
PS, I don't normally swear like this, I'm just waiting for some smarty to post, "Not enough swearing, could do better" but this is Pistonheads

k it this is Pistonheads.Background.. I'm an old git knocking 50, and I have a passion for older cars. I currently insure 3 old relics (an Opel Monza GSE, a Vauxhall Viva GLS and a Porsche 928GT) all of which costs me less than £500 to insure and all fully comprehensive. This also includes a Kawasaki ZZR1400 motorcycle. I have 10 years NCB, no accidents and no convictions, and I would like to think that I am a good risk insurance wise.
Due to a new contract I now find myself working some 20 miles away from home and my 5 litre V8 everyday drive is kind of negating any object in earning a salary. So the hunt for the fourth sensible commuter makes perfect sense, albeit not to my partner. I've looked at a lot of snotters and managed to find a mk3 Golf GTI 16V (as listed in the classifieds) for the sum of £350. It has issues - as expected and will probably cost me twice that to put right, but I wanted it because it is cheap and I can make a good car out of it over time.
So just how much would you think that snotter would be to insure? As my 3 litre fuel injected Monza was £78 fully comp, I thought it would be around that price. Well I tried Lancaster online as they are my main insurer of my classics and thought to add another would not be that costly..
Dear God how I was wrong

Then I tried a Google global quote with tpft - Shock horror! Why the f
k does it include "Diamond shaped for girls" ??? WTFlyingf
k??? So f
king 3rd party takes the premium up to a f
king grand for a piece of s
te that has no chance of earning any value due it being s
te in the first place. It also has an aftermarket alarm but that appears to make f
k all difference 
So now, somewhat f
ked off, I start to trawl through the previous insurers that have held me as a good risk with cars like an Ultima GTR with nitrous and a highly modified Nissan 300ZX Twin Turbo.. I know, I'll get a quote from Footman James.. they will save the day and f
k all the other t
ts..Oh f
king no, have a really sensible night where you spend the best part of your life typing in stupid f
king boxes and getting "noo you didn't fill the answer in this box f
king properly you retard, this quote will now double as a result of your ineptitude in filling in online f
king stupid forms.. in addition to this we will anally ream you at every possibility
f
king t
ts
...and for the final f
king performance, I give you Footman James.. with their best effort 


I mean what the f
king f
k f
k is that all about? Cannot even muster a quote because, "Due to the unique nature of your vehicle and your insurance needs..."f
kety f
king f
k. It is a 17 year old POS, it is not fast, has decent security, is garaged, is worth £300 and will be owned by someone that has a good paperwork driving record.. Cannot quote???? - does this I've been revoked insurance and now have to declare this at every f
king box typing session?? What the flying f
k is occurring here??? Can anyone enlighten me as to why I am getting abused by insurance companies? I was told a few months back that it is how much damage I can do with my vehicle which sets the main marker for liability and premium costs. Clearly I could insure a f
king Sherman tank for less and enjoy creating more f
king damage so there is something f
king wrong here.PS, I don't normally swear like this, I'm just waiting for some smarty to post, "Not enough swearing, could do better" but this is Pistonheads


I'll agree with Coldfuse and Toasterpilot. A hefty part of the calculated premium is based on statistics for the car type itself.
Golf GiTs, and especially older, cheaper ones tend to be the sort of car the fairly unemployable "wicked car innit" types aspire to and then drive like absolute wazzocks until they have a crash.
I had similar 'fun' when interested in an XR3i when I was younger. I kept getting XR3i quotes every year until I was about 27 just to giggle at how much more they wanted for a really bad car than I was paying for whatever I had at the time.
It's not very PH I know, but GTI/RS/GSi/VXR badges when applied to anything with a hatchback body and FWD just suggests "Compared to how lethal I'd be in a sportscar, it's relatively safe for me to skid round every corner with an arm full of understeer in my hothatch".
Much like Subaru Imprezas where the majority spoil it for the minority of genuine enthusiasts, hothatches just attract idiots and consequently hot hatches appear far more frequently than they have any right to on insurance claims paperwork. That and theft, of course - but it's the same type of driving mostly.
Might I suggest a 1990s 2.0 turbo Q-car type mid-exec car instead - Rover 620ti / Saab turbo or the like? All will be far cheaper to insure, faster and any I've come across have no trouble bettering 30mpg if the pedal isn't in the carpet too many times per journey.
Golf GiTs, and especially older, cheaper ones tend to be the sort of car the fairly unemployable "wicked car innit" types aspire to and then drive like absolute wazzocks until they have a crash.
I had similar 'fun' when interested in an XR3i when I was younger. I kept getting XR3i quotes every year until I was about 27 just to giggle at how much more they wanted for a really bad car than I was paying for whatever I had at the time.
It's not very PH I know, but GTI/RS/GSi/VXR badges when applied to anything with a hatchback body and FWD just suggests "Compared to how lethal I'd be in a sportscar, it's relatively safe for me to skid round every corner with an arm full of understeer in my hothatch".
Much like Subaru Imprezas where the majority spoil it for the minority of genuine enthusiasts, hothatches just attract idiots and consequently hot hatches appear far more frequently than they have any right to on insurance claims paperwork. That and theft, of course - but it's the same type of driving mostly.
Might I suggest a 1990s 2.0 turbo Q-car type mid-exec car instead - Rover 620ti / Saab turbo or the like? All will be far cheaper to insure, faster and any I've come across have no trouble bettering 30mpg if the pedal isn't in the carpet too many times per journey.
Do not declare that you have has insurance refused, this means the insures (brokers) will decline the cover in most case as it normally leads to a risk of fraud from there eyes.
I would also advise you over value the value of the golf. In most case's this can decrease the cost of the premium reason being as the insurers will potentially think you would take more care of the car etc.
But then again insurance is done on stastics, plus more and more young people have been buying mk3 gti's so could of been more & more accidents in this particular car.
Ring Adrian flux, I actually work for an insurance broker and would highly recommend them.
I would also advise you over value the value of the golf. In most case's this can decrease the cost of the premium reason being as the insurers will potentially think you would take more care of the car etc.
But then again insurance is done on stastics, plus more and more young people have been buying mk3 gti's so could of been more & more accidents in this particular car.
Ring Adrian flux, I actually work for an insurance broker and would highly recommend them.
9/10 for top class ranting Lord.
Had similar with OH renewing her policy at start of June.
Priced around £200 fully comp.
I was still banned so couldn't put me on.
2 weeks later got licence back and phoned insurance company to put me on as additional driver.
Cost? £180 then just over £100 per MONTH - worked out nearly £1500 so said sod that.
Cancelled insurance and went back to compare the market for new quote including me as named driver.
New price £11 per year more than original policy. Here's the crazy part - policy was with original insurer and exactly the same terms, excess etc.
Why was I such a risk after a 6 month ban?
Was it a high group Jap rally slag? A fire-snorting twin turbo monster?
Nope - 1.6 Mazda 3.
Madder than Mick McMadd the local loony.
Had similar with OH renewing her policy at start of June.
Priced around £200 fully comp.
I was still banned so couldn't put me on.
2 weeks later got licence back and phoned insurance company to put me on as additional driver.
Cost? £180 then just over £100 per MONTH - worked out nearly £1500 so said sod that.
Cancelled insurance and went back to compare the market for new quote including me as named driver.
New price £11 per year more than original policy. Here's the crazy part - policy was with original insurer and exactly the same terms, excess etc.
Why was I such a risk after a 6 month ban?
Was it a high group Jap rally slag? A fire-snorting twin turbo monster?
Nope - 1.6 Mazda 3.
Madder than Mick McMadd the local loony.
Useful thread update.. with NO swearing 
Thanks to all of the advice, this is what I found out from the insurers I spoke with today and it explains a lot:
£387 - Footman James
£263 - Lancaster
Both fully comp with similar levels of cover. A huge difference from the online quote as stated on here.
It's doubtful if I will go with the GTI. I like the idea of owning it but the car with an MOT, insurance and tax would owe me £500 and that's before investigating the main faults of ABS light on and oil leaks. I want to buy a fun car and I want to pay no more than £100 for insurance and £350 for a car and it's a buyers market at the moment for bangers
PS, I don't usually swear at all, but this was a rant and it's bad form on PH to present a rant with anything less

Thanks to all of the advice, this is what I found out from the insurers I spoke with today and it explains a lot:
- I had listed SD&P but WITH commuting to a permanent place of work - this was a
because Classic Insurance presumes that you are only bringing your baby out after work and not subjecting her to the risk that is rush-hour traffic.
- As mentioned, it is better to make the value of the car more not less. The insurers' viewpoint is why would you want a classic policy if you were not the kind of person to keep the car in constant improvement state rather than a shed state. A higher value shows that you value your car and that you are more likely to look after it - and drive it like Miss Daisy.
- A Golf GTI has bad credence with general insurers. There are specific insurers with policies especially catered for these cars which are endorsed by the owners clubs, including the VAG Club of GB and the GTI club. Most generic insurers viewpoint is that these cars are cheap performance for hoods that cannot afford a modern car. Their record is based on a lot of data for getting smashed and crashed and nicked/left in hedges and is a higher risk than most other hot-hatches. There is a very good reason for this; the Golf GTI was the first hot hatch that changed the game and they have had more vehicles to get data on.
- Modern Classic policies require a garage. I have a garage but they are aware that my Porsche is in it and that it is a single garage. This was dutifully pointed out by the insurer as I had already stated my other car was garaged. The fact that my Porsche would reside in another garage was not picked up on, just the fact that quote was based on no garage and that was a condition of the insurance for the classic policy, hence the inability to quote from an automated system. Got all that? No, thought not

£387 - Footman James
£263 - Lancaster
Both fully comp with similar levels of cover. A huge difference from the online quote as stated on here.
It's doubtful if I will go with the GTI. I like the idea of owning it but the car with an MOT, insurance and tax would owe me £500 and that's before investigating the main faults of ABS light on and oil leaks. I want to buy a fun car and I want to pay no more than £100 for insurance and £350 for a car and it's a buyers market at the moment for bangers

PS, I don't usually swear at all, but this was a rant and it's bad form on PH to present a rant with anything less

Bmills92 said:
Do not declare that you have has insurance refused
Blimey... Bmills92 said:
this means the insures (brokers) will decline the cover in most case as it normally leads to a risk of fraud from there eyes.
There you go, fraud in not mentioning the previous/recent refusal of insurance (sic)
.Bmills92 said:
I would also advise you over value the value of the golf. In most case's this can decrease the cost of the premium reason being as the insurers will potentially think you would take more care of the car etc.
But then again insurance is done on stastics, plus more and more young people have been buying mk3 gti's so could of been more & more accidents in this particular car.
But then again insurance is done on stastics, plus more and more young people have been buying mk3 gti's so could of been more & more accidents in this particular car.

Bmills92 said:
Ring Adrian flux, I actually work for an insurance broker and would highly recommend them.
I'm sure their pet poster "Ash" on here would categorically NOT agree to what you're suggesting above
.Can anyone remind me again why I, as a middle-aged bloke, am paying £750 to insure 3 not-really-sexy-in-any-way-in-the-great-PH-scheme-of-things cars for a year in a dodgy postcode again
??? Ah, right *penny drops*
. 

Gassing Station | General Gassing | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


