Comparison websites
Comparison websites
Author
Discussion

anonymous-user

Original Poster:

85 months

Friday 16th August 2013
quotequote all
Hey guys

A bit of a vague question, but I have what I think is a good idea for a business but I'm worried about just how much money it would cost to set up a website for it.

Ideally I'd like to have a comparison website service, not too much unlike what you find for insurance but with nowhere near as many viables. In fact in truth not much more needed is a postcode to match customers with services and the price of said services, but I'm concerned that even a basic comparison type website would cost loads to have built?

Does anyone have any sort of experience in implementing a comparison website, either building it or having one built? Any rough idea of costs involved?

grumbas

1,180 posts

222 months

Friday 16th August 2013
quotequote all
Run an insurance comparison site - the hard part isn't building the site (not that it's easy/cheap), it's agreeing terms with the providers, going through legal, getting access to their APIs and finally testing/sign-off.

You don't say which product/service you're targeting but may well find the same issues.

Pappa Lurve

3,827 posts

313 months

Wednesday 21st August 2013
quotequote all
Also depends very much on what you are comparing.

Let us assume this is for amobile phones for an example;

Simple comparisson will be "sim free galaxy s3" whihc really only has to look at one or two variables, cost and delivery.

Go up a step to just galaxy s3 and things start getting complex as it will show loads for free because of contracts. Thats great but not terribly helpful as it is tough to compare contracts as well.

Really rather more difficult but perfectly possible is a full comparisson which will be capable of comparing tarrifs as well as the phone itself

Then if you want to get really clever you can do a lot more allowing for comparitive models as well for example, but that starts getting a tad more tricky.

Very much depends on what exactly you are tryng to compare and to what details level you wish to go.

Marketing spends are very dependant on what you are comparing. I used to run business dev at what at the time was the largest comparisson site in the world. Some catagories could be set up in a day or two, very simple but phones, betting odds, financila stuff, flights and feature based comparissons could get a little involved sometimes both developing the engine and marketing it correctly. We had more cash than we knew what to do with back in the day so we could afford to drop tens or even hundreds of thousands to get it right.


Kudos

2,674 posts

205 months

Wednesday 21st August 2013
quotequote all
Getting people to visit your website is the big issue - companies pay millions to get people to come and visit. Without them, you'll not do very well

anonymous-user

Original Poster:

85 months

Wednesday 21st August 2013
quotequote all
Thanks for the input guys.

I'm thinking in one of its first incarnation it would have to operate on a manual quotation system, I.e the website takes the details of the customer and supplies to a client and then the client manually quotes them. The problem is I have with that is the big part of the idea was to streamline a process that can be a pain until ultimately all the customer would have to in effect enter their card details and it is done... I suppose I have to start somewhere.

Thanks again chaps

LooneyTunes

9,541 posts

189 months

Wednesday 21st August 2013
quotequote all
279 said:
Thanks for the input guys.

I'm thinking in one of its first incarnation it would have to operate on a manual quotation system, I.e the website takes the details of the customer and supplies to a client and then the client manually quotes them. The problem is I have with that is the big part of the idea was to streamline a process that can be a pain until ultimately all the customer would have to in effect enter their card details and it is done... I suppose I have to start somewhere.

Thanks again chaps
The only places I allow to quote on a comparative basis are:

1) Already trusted; or
2) Ones that will allow me to enter a bullst email address*

'*if the quote doesn't appear immediately (e.g. "we'll email you"), or isn't attractive, I won't go through with a legitimate email address.

I don't want to (and won't) provide a genuine email address until such time as I am confident that it is worthwhile and that I won't be bombarded with spam.

Based on the number of places that say that an address such as "a@b.com" is already in use, I don't think I'm alone in this.

boony

382 posts

268 months

Thursday 22nd August 2013
quotequote all
The question I would answer to start with is whether the details about the product/service you're comparing are readily available from the various providers via an API.

If not, you need to really be sure that

(a) there's a market for your comparison website and
(b) you can access that market

BEFORE you build it.

If the data is available via API, a comparison site is easy to build and shouldn't cost a lot (although I have seen some crazy quotes for websites in the past biggrin).

I've spent the last 2 yrs building my sports arbitrage product which essentially compares the odds offered by various bookmakers to find risk-free betting opportunities. None of the bookmakers offer APIs so I've had to write code to extract the data from their websites. This has been an endless battle for me - every little tweak they make to their web site breaks my code and I have to rewrite parts of it.

Since I'm the developer, it doesn't cost me anything but my time - but it's taking more time than I'd like to devote to it and I'm nowhere near the scale I originally envisioned getting to. If I was having to pay a developer for all of the changes then I honestly think I'd have wound the project up by now.

As already mentioned, it can cost big money to drive traffic to your site. Luckily for me I've been able to get enough paying customers to make it feel worthwhile continuing with it. Since the product essentially generates free cash for my users, once they've used it for a few days they generally recommend it to friends/family so word of mouth/referrals has meant a steady flow of new customers for me without having to advertise - is this likely to be the case for your comparison website? i.e. is it for a product that many people are going to be interested in comparing?

Best of luck with it.

vescaegg

30,710 posts

198 months

Thursday 22nd August 2013
quotequote all
I had the idea of setting up a similar website a year or so ago. The main problem is getting the relevant information from suppliers which can be accessed through your site, even though many just re-direct once quoted anyway. A lot of the suppliers in the field I was going for would not give much access to their data although I didnt look into it that much.

I spoke with a website designer and to make one which wouldnt look totally crap, it was in the tens of thousands of pounds. Game over for me at the moment!

uber

860 posts

201 months

Thursday 22nd August 2013
quotequote all
Building the website is the easy bit in this game its the cost of advertising which is going to be your biggest issue. I work with lots of people in this game and a 50-100k a month PPC budget would be seen as small.




All that jazz

7,632 posts

177 months

Sunday 25th August 2013
quotequote all
279 said:
Thanks for the input guys.

I'm thinking in one of its first incarnation it would have to operate on a manual quotation system, I.e the website takes the details of the customer and supplies to a client and then the client manually quotes them. The problem is I have with that is the big part of the idea was to streamline a process that can be a pain until ultimately all the customer would have to in effect enter their card details and it is done... I suppose I have to start somewhere.

Thanks again chaps
I 100% agree with LooneyTunes above. Quote sites need to be instantaneous these days for people to use them. Entering your details for someone to (possibly, if they can be arsed) phone you back at some point in the future are very much old skool now and people don't/won't use them - myself included. If this is the route you plan to take, the best advice I can give you is don't waste your money.