Approved samples now wants to return because they're not the
Approved samples now wants to return because they're not the
Author
Discussion

mrloudly

Original Poster:

2,815 posts

266 months

Friday 16th August 2013
quotequote all
Have a customer who buys some bits we import. He trialled and approved the parts and we have supplied nearly 3000 units @ £20 ea. Further to a problem in the field, due to a faulty unit, he has now picked up on a shortcoming in the product and is saying he wants to return the units and claim costs to do so. Any legal bods know where we stand?
He sample approved the parts, tested and had all the paperwork pertaining to the units from us. Short of it is, we supplied, and he approved a "Class 2" electrical product and after the fault in the field, he has now decided the parts should have been "Class 1" . Could do without it...

We have also offered a "fix" to the problem, but they're not accepting it...

Nowhere have we received an exact spec from the customer. He sent us a pic of a unit and asked us could we supply, he then approved after his own testing.

Thanks

Andy M

mmm-five

12,407 posts

315 months

Friday 16th August 2013
quotequote all
I guess you're question to yourself would be "Is this customer worth £60,000 (or cost price) to me?".

therealpigdog

2,592 posts

228 months

Friday 16th August 2013
quotequote all
What does the contract say?

CHIEF

2,270 posts

313 months

Friday 16th August 2013
quotequote all
We've been at both ends of this, I have recieved samples from the far east that were spot on then we ordered a batch and i'd say 50% were crap so we scrapped the lot, Thankfully it wasn't a great deal of money so not big deal but still pee'd me off.

Other side was someone who we helped source a product that was of high quality but cheaper than anyone in the UK, we brough them in at a cost of 80k, shipped them out and because we wouldn't commision them for nowt he got all shirty and got his legal team involved and picked holes in the tech spec and threatened us with legal action even though there was nothing wrong with the product, but as a small company we couldn't afford to spend 50k going up against his legal team.

In the end we said fk it, went and got the goods back and gave the guy his money and walked away. We cant and wont deal with companies who are dishonest and crap on people.

Could you either do the follwoing?

Offer the product at a knock down price just enough to cover your costs then walk away?

Take them back, tell him to go forth and multiply and sell through another channel?


Simpo Two

93,127 posts

296 months

Friday 16th August 2013
quotequote all
Is one failure out of 3,000 units reasonable or unreasonable?

CHIEF

2,270 posts

313 months

Friday 16th August 2013
quotequote all
Simpo Two said:
Is one failure out of 3,000 units reasonable or unreasonable?
Reasonable. I wouldn't even bother raising the issue the percentage is that small.

The Moose

23,710 posts

240 months

Friday 16th August 2013
quotequote all
CHIEF said:
Simpo Two said:
Is one failure out of 3,000 units reasonable or unreasonable?
Reasonable. I wouldn't even bother raising the issue the percentage is that small.
Although I read the OP as 1 failed, but upon further investigation, this 1 failure lead him to discover something he's not quite happy with that's present in every single one.

Simpo Two

93,127 posts

296 months

Friday 16th August 2013
quotequote all
You could view it as the client admitting that his own inspection was not adequate... who's fault is that?

Dunno, sorry.

Condi

20,573 posts

202 months

Friday 16th August 2013
quotequote all
Simpo Two said:
You could view it as the client admitting that his own inspection was not adequate... who's fault is that?

Dunno, sorry.
This would be my understanding, but surely check your paperwork. If you have an agreement to supply Class 2 products and he signed that then tough st. If the wording is more vague then you have more of a problem, but I would have though assuming your contract is reasonable you stand a good chance of fighting it.

mrloudly

Original Poster:

2,815 posts

266 months

Friday 16th August 2013
quotequote all
The thing is we had an agreement to supply as the sample he had approved (class 2). Strange how when he discovers a manufacturing fault, in one unit, all of a sudden requires class 1... No "class" of product had been mentioned or specified until one unit went wrong... From my perspective, he tested, he approved and we supplied to meet that approved spec. Sure, one went wrong, we never said they wouldn't... We'll stand by our product and replace any that are faulty, as far as changing them all because the spec's not right, rock on... It's £400k they're trying to claim. Third party costs LOL!!!

HoHoHo

15,407 posts

281 months

Friday 16th August 2013
quotequote all
I'm not sure about the legalities of Class 1 against 2 however a fault has been identified and you have offered a fix presumably at no cost to him?

I would argue the class issue is irrelevant unless its pertinent to the certification/use of the product.

Send him a lovely email apologising that there appears to be a small defect and you'll help resolve the situation.

Fix the problem.

The end.

rhinochopig

17,932 posts

229 months

Friday 16th August 2013
quotequote all
Are they facing a penalty clause for late delivery by any chance? They could be looking for a scape goat and you've just given them the perfect excuse. See it a lot in the defence industry - not to mention civils.

johnfm

13,752 posts

281 months

Friday 16th August 2013
quotequote all
You will need to lawyer up I expect I it gets to a £400k claim.

Start collating all the paperwork (emails in the pre contract negotiations etc), draft contracts etc.

Have they paid for the gear in full?

Simpo Two

93,127 posts

296 months

Friday 16th August 2013
quotequote all
Spend £60K and get £400K back? Nice wheeze.

Send him a free replacement with a nice but firm letter saying that concludes your liability.

therealpigdog

2,592 posts

228 months

Friday 16th August 2013
quotequote all
therealpigdog said:
What does the contract say?
Any news on this yet?

johnfm

13,752 posts

281 months

Friday 16th August 2013
quotequote all
therealpigdog said:
therealpigdog said:
What does the contract say?
Any news on this yet?
And, of course, this!

mrloudly

Original Poster:

2,815 posts

266 months

Sunday 18th August 2013
quotequote all
Contract, in which the customer makes no mention of "class" of equipment required, was against our std terms and conditions which they have signed. In this it is clearly stated
we will not assume 3rd party onward costs, or legalise to that effect. Shame really, they're a £300k anum account. Had they been sensible we'd have worked with them to resolve the
issue, as it is now, we don't want their business...

We have a comprehensive paper trail in which their own testing is detailed and their ultimate acceptance of the goods. Aside from this, why did they order/accept them if they weren't happy
to start with... They've screwed up big time and are trying to pass the buck!